News
Despite community support, boy to be deported
Boaz Fyler
Published: 18.10.12, 01:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
75 Talkbacks for this article
1. I'm a Jewish Israeli. This is a crime.
Dan   (10.18.12)
Shame on us.
2. Deport this Heartless Moronic Minister instead....
Jarred Stone ,   London UK   (10.18.12)
3. Sickening way to to treat HUMAN BEINGS
Jarred Stone ,   London UK   (10.18.12)
For a people that should know better on how it feels to be treated in such a despicable manner this dumb and hard-heart minister should know better. Deport him instead...
5. Deport Eli Yishai instead
Haim ,   TA   (10.18.12)
6. keep just the boy
Bluegrass Picker ,   Afula   (10.18.12)
This country's history is full of separated families. Keeping the boy here is good for building our country. He can visit his mom in sudan twice a year. I'll help pay for those tickets, honestly
7. Sad case, but not Israeli responsibility!
Alex   (10.18.12)
Israel can't take care of every god damn African seeking a better life. We need to take care of our population first, there are thousands of Israeli children and elderly living in bad conditions and lack of food. But these illegal immigrants get everything for free, school, welfare, health care while our own people get NOTHING! It's despicable.
8. little moses and his mom,are pure of heart
andrew brown ,   bridgeport ct usa   (10.18.12)
dear prime minister netantyahu and president peres,please allow little moses and his mom to stay in israel ,you have stopped the infiltrators and these two people seem pure of heart, i am a very strong supporter of israel and my heart will be broken if you deport them they are sick and this would be a death sentence!!!for moses and his mother,i understand about single healthy men who cross the border,but please think of these poor children,please have a heart,you must be a light amoung the nations,he will grow up to be a fine young man and who will love his country,and probable become a good jew, i am going to pray for moses and his mother,remember you have the power to save a child dont bring bad karma on yourself,save these children and g-d will reward you,how many children perished during the holocaust that could have been saved,dont have a childs blood on your hands!!!,you will have the blessing of hashem!!!
9. Send him home!
David ,   Israel   (10.18.12)
This is a Jewish state for the JEWISH people. Send him on a vacation to the US and let him stay there forever
10. what a sweetiepie
Olliethedog   (10.18.12)
11. We cannot break down for this matter
My Planet Israel ,   LA-Jerusalem   (10.18.12)
It is what it is and we cannot allow ourselves to get overly emotional about such situations. We CANNOT afford to accommodate illegal immigrants, regardless of their background story (this is different that qualified refugees). Its sad he'll be sad for a while but he is not Israeli, never was and its not in our interest to invite such massive cultural differences into the 'Jewish Homeland' when we are trying to ESCAPE the world's lack of humane treatment of us Jews as we try to rebuild our SAFE HAVEN and HOMELAND. This is NOT apartheid, racist, prejudice or the like: it is the result of the worlds horrendous treatment of us and our earned right to establish our safe haven once and for all. Blowing it for ourselves by capitulating to this boy's background will be the gateway to our demise. Its foolish, INHUMANE FOR US JEWS and HE ALREADY HAS A HOMELAND. Let him go back and live his life in his homeland, not ours. Peace to him; wish him only well, but the Jews cannot be duped into destroying our cultural heritage and people via 'multi-culturalism'. It will fail everyone. Period.
12. I'm ashamed
the mad Zionist ,   sf-ny-is   (10.18.12)
I understand that this has to happen at times, but they really really should do it in a individual manner. i feel bad for Moses and his mother. I hope it gets enough media attention to change their mind, i doubt it though. Makes me wonder why hanan zoabi, who actively speaks for the destruction of Israel, and gets paid for it too, can stay. And these 2 have to go. Backwards Jake
13. if the mom's not jewish, neither is he
ma nishma ,   modiin   (10.18.12)
it does not matter how well he speaks Hebrew, or how many Biblical or Hebrew names he has, he is not Jewish. Let us not let our hearts rule us. We should find a friendly European country to take them, like, England (big hearts?) or Austria (big ovens?). We are not responsible for all illegal immigrants. Maybe USA will take them.
14. All Jews are welcome in Israel, unless they're black or Arab
Simba   (10.18.12)
15. Racism
Zuri ,   Glasgow Scotland   (10.18.12)
We are so bothered by illegal refugees that we do not know who to help anymore
16. Need for compassion
Ilan   (10.18.12)
We should not be cruel and heartless like those that threw people from their homes during the girush/disengagement.
17. Please let Moses stay
Rachel   (10.18.12)
In Israel where he belongs with his mother and friends the people who love him.
18. Who wants him to integrate
Mordechai   (10.18.12)
Lets make this simple we don't want non Jews integrating into Israeli society. We don't want this non Jew getting involved with a Jewish girl. It is not Israels responsibility to provide eye surgery to every non Jew in the world. Let Egypt do that. Or Saudi Arabia or Russia or the US. Israel is the one Jewish state in the world and it won't stay that way with an open immigration policy for non Jews.
19. moses jacob
harvey gefen ,   toronto canada   (10.18.12)
yishais policies are merciless ..how anyone can extradite this mother and son is unbelirvable and reflects terribly on israel.
20. Good riddance
PersianJew ,   Holon,TA,Israel   (10.18.12)
Not Israeli, not Jewish, not a westerner of any kind, send him back to the country (a beautiful one, mind you) that his people ruined before he ruins ours.
21. "I wish to give back if only I am given the chance."
Ken Quinn ,   Ashalim   (10.18.12)
Smart kid, but this doesn't ring true. Send them back to their own country, they will be better off there. "Diversity" doesn't really work, it just sows resentment because cultures are supposed to be grouped in one place. If the bleeding hearts want to make a difference in these peoples lives, I suggest that they go to Sudan and show the Sudanese how to prosper. Otherwise don't advocate giving away the children's bread to obvious criminals.
22. YOU MAKE US ALL LOOK BAD
Daniel ,   Sde Boker, Israel   (10.18.12)
Micheal GO BACK TO YUR HOLE!
23. No 4. I'm gob-smacked
(10.18.12)
The term neanderthal springs to mind in response to your comment. Wow! Racism is alive, well and flourishing in Israel.
24. The problem is..
Ivan ,   South Africa   (10.18.12)
If this family stays,Sudanese back home will see Israel as a weak country, and thousands more will arrive.....for the sake of this kid and his mother, I hope they can stay..
25. Got 2 free eye surgeries
Fred   (10.18.12)
She was given shelter for 5 years and 2 free eye operations after illegally entering the country. Now her country has received independence and is no longer at war. Israel offers her a free plane ticket back. She still complains.
26. "Those who save one life save the world"
Mabsurfing ,   Nahariya, Israel   (10.18.12)
The Talmud says that those who save one life save the world. I am in favor of returning infiltrators, they are refuges when they cross the border of their neighboring country, however exceptions can be made. This is an old woman and a young kid. The article doesn't say if this woman is working or not, just that she had 2 eye surgeries, if she is working and also contribute to the country, both of them should part of people given a chance to stay.
27. #4 It's a Shame
Alex ,   Tel Aviv   (10.18.12)
As a Jew it shames me to hear things like this from Israel. People like you give Israel a bad rep. You are a racist, idiotic excuse of a man.
28. Every infiltrator is a sob story, do you keep them ALL and
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.18.12)
invite more to come? Give them all some money and a plane ticket and let them be thankful for that. Illegal aliens have harmed America beyond reason, all because the leftist, liberal fools think illegals should come before their American neighbor. And, look at our worst illegal alien that has done more to destroy the US than anyone else, obumma, would you want him as your leader?
29. Oh, there's always a story
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.18.12)
Those stories rarely resemble the truth. The more it twangs your heartstrings, the more likely it is to be highly fictionalized. Send them home. If they want to seek refuge, there are other places they can go. Israel will NOT become a dumping ground for disaffected Africans. The United Nations will find a place for this mother and son. They are, after all, the U.N.'s responsibility. Why should Israel do the United Nations' job? Here's the deal: when Israel has finished caring for the needs of Israelis with all manner of issues, and with Jews throughout the world who are suffering and are unable to leave the countries where they reside -- Syria and Iran come to mind -- then, we can turn our focus elsewhere. In the meantime, however, let the well-funded United Nations worry about everyone else.
30. sorry, but no. The real crime is having allowed this to....
go on for so many ,   years   (10.18.12)
with every year these illegal infiltrators think they have more right to stay. The fact is, they are, Illegal infiltrators. And as such they should be deported as soon as they are found. By telling people there is a chance they can stay just encourages that idea. By wanting special circumstances to be checked in every case it means thwarting the law. There is no reason that any illegal infiltrators should be allowed to stay for years, it is a disservice to us and to them as well. Its a sad case for the boy but he should want to build up his country, the Sudan, not Israel. They are not jews plain and simple
Next talkbacks
Back to article