News
Migrant denied treatment, gives birth to dead baby
Omri Efraim
Published: 24.10.12, 22:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. terrible
Il;ana   (10.24.12)
SHameon the IPS. SHame on Yishai.
2. I hear so much about so called Jewish 'values' ,...
split ,   US   (10.25.12)
A few months ago rebbe Ovadia Joseph introduced us to some of them verbally now we see it in real life enforced by his herd on Goyim,...
3. So sad.
Birdi ,   Israel   (10.25.12)
4. Biased Article
EGGM ,   Petah Tikva, Israel   (10.24.12)
While the article presents both sides of the story, the position of the author is clear as he tries to downplay what the IPS says and takes the complainant's claims at face value. Yes, it's possible the IPS may have screwed up and are covering it up, but it's just as likely (if not more) that they are being truthful and the complainant just wants to use her case to prevent her family's deportation. Every reader chooses what side to believe. Personally I believe the IPS more.
5. Eli Yishai had blood on his hands
Haim ,   TA   (10.25.12)
6. Migrant
Tom ,   New York   (10.25.12)
Migrant infers someting else than someone who snuck into the country. Considering that her husband's name is Mohammed is this the type of immigrant Israel needs ?
7. #4
A Pernat ,   Paris   (10.25.12)
If all this were happened to a jewish Israeli citizen in france or germany , would you belive the Population and Migration Authority of this countries is right ? There are about 30000 Israelis in Berlin and no one harm a hair on them. some of them cash allowance money or scholarships and they are medically insured. One should not treat others in ways that one would not like to be treated. If you want tolerance be tolerant. I am a disapora jew and I don´t want to be harmed , I want to be respected and have rights. everyone in this world deserve respect. This poor illegal people in Israel too, thank G-d you are not in their situation
8. A choIce to be evil was made. Own it.
Josh   (10.25.12)
They idea that "we" shall run every aspect of "teaching" outsiders with brutal means to not do this or that is disgusting. " the country holds a moral obligation" doesn't fix the garbage you do to others. G-d as a witness, there will be accountability one way or another for a nation devoid of morality to begin with. The superiority and and harsh "lessons" dispatched by overly proud Israelis is not without witness. You can't fix it. The child cannot be broght back to life and you are all not some Jesus characters. WITH A LOUD VOICE, I SAY SHAME ON YOU. None of the higher ups will pay for this and an investigation will find none to blame. Liars.
9. Dump Eli Yishai and change our archaic Ministry of Interior
Scott ,   Haifa   (10.25.12)
10. So because she didn't scream & flip out nobody did anything?
Charles   (10.25.12)
When people here in Israel complain about the rudeness and screaming at each other, blame yourselves. When those in positions of responsibility and authority only move or act when people can't take it anymore and have to yell and scream, you have a cultural problem with laziness and apathy. This is evident from the banks, iriyia, doctors & nurses, phone services, etc. Everywhere. Good luck if this ever changes at all for the better.
11. What normal person ....
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.25.12)
.... embarks upon a lengthy walk through very unforgiving terrain when they are pregnant? The whole story reeks of manipulation to me.
12. To Sarah #11
MG   (10.25.12)
Probably a very desperate person, who deserves a little compassion…
13. what normal person
Frank ,   Pardes Hanna   (10.25.12)
A normal person doesn't manipulate in this way. A person in fear of their life flees and seeks asylum. I'm sure some of our grandmothers were pregnant when they fled the pogroms of Eastern Europe and Nazi Germany.
14. Shame on nobody but the ILLEGAL ones
Ramon ,   ShapitaTel Av - iv   (10.25.12)
They are ILLEGAL, they are not entitled to anything. Stop blaming Eli Yishai for all of this he personally had nothing to do with this. Anybody that disagrees suggest you come live in my neighborhood.
15. To: No. 12
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.25.12)
I feel considerably more sorry for the baby whose life she endangered .... and who was, indeed, stillborn. You cannot pin the blame on the Israeli Prison Service. As for compassion -- call in the United Nations. It's their job, not the job of the State of Israel.
16. MG #12
David ,   Haifa   (10.25.12)
they are arabs. they can go to egypt for help
17. Compassion is not a job, Sarah. It's feeling.
MG   (10.25.12)
18. #sarah 11
A Pernat ,   Paris   (10.25.12)
Sarah tell me in which conditions emigrated your ancestors in the USA ?
19. Sarah # 11
(10.25.12)
Do you not read the newspapers if it does not concern Israel? Are you not aware that a genocide occurred in Darfur? Or perhaps it is that you just lack compassion and humanity?
20. You mean...
Me ,   USA   (10.28.12)
a democracy should only allow people with certain names to be the "type of immigrant Israel needs?"
21. #11 Well, that's because you're stupid
Talula ,   Israel   (10.30.12)
Do you have any idea how many Yemenites risked their lives and those of their unborn children to get to Israel? You are just a nasty nobody who thinks she knows it all.
Back to article