Jewish Scene
US Jews: Ashamed of Israel, proud to be Jewish
Tali Farkash
Published: 31.10.12, 20:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
1. we are tired of defending israeli actions and settlements
shlomo   (10.31.12)
2. stop harassing obama
david   (10.31.12)
3. I AM REPUBLICAN JEW, I LOVE ISRAEL
...DACON9   (10.31.12)
THOSE SURVEYS ARE TAKEN BY corn flake box tops mail ins. also ''peel off; from peanut butter labels
4. Traitor or Antisemite? maybe both pc. of sh..
srrr   (10.31.12)
5. shkutz
Gary Hess ,   Jerusalem   (10.31.12)
what a joke. his father is an outcast and so is the son. they hate the "settlers" and their self-righteous arrogance has no end. they just pretend to be frum!
6. ashamed of israel
arne ,   chicago usa   (10.31.12)
some joke--thank g-d we live in a time and was able to see the re-birth of israel, something our grandparents never saw and couldn't ever imagine. shame on those who are ashamed.israel is the light on to the jewish people. heaven forbid i live to see the world without it
7. It's the economy stupid!
Joe ,   Baltimore, USA   (10.31.12)
Any American of any background knows that votes go to whomever will better manage the economy. President Obama said that if he can't manage the economy, he will be a one term president. Then he went back on his word!
8. Like they say in my neck of the woods....
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.01.12)
A picture is worth 1000 words: "'Obama feels very comfortable around Jews and Judaism' Photo: AFP"
9. The republican Jews believe Jordan is Palestinian State
E.M Jordan is Pale S ,   SF   (10.31.12)
And the democrats Jews mostly support the people who captured State of Israel in 7century and since then they did not let Jews come back to their historic land and for this reason I will vote for republican because they support undivided able State of Israel. Yes I am Jewish American but I always remember what did happen to European Jews too. Israel is my promise land and this the only State that can protect the entire Jews all around the world. Go Romney.
10. NO! NO! NO!
ira berkowitz ,   emeryville, californ   (10.31.12)
NO, Mr. Kurtzer, you are entirely wrong. There is a vast proportion of American Jewry that understands the history of the confict with the Arabs, and who are PROUD of Israel for many reasons. The only shame I feel is to have weak, limp wristed matza ball-less jews making ridiculous statements about American Jewish shame regarding Israel. You shoud get a real job, Mr. Kurtzer, because from where I sit, the only thing you do is to create worthless ideas about ther people, because you are really ashamed of yourself!
11. Shame?
Howard ,   Chicago USA   (10.31.12)
Two things about this article: I don't feel an ounce of shame for the "occupation". It is the arabs who are occupying land in Israel. And second, if you can't se what a turd Obama has been to Israel, you are not muchof a Zionist.
12.  Poll: Israeli Jews favor Romney by wide margin
Sarah C. ,   Cleveland, OH   (10.31.12)
Look it up. "Obama feels very comfortable around Jews and Judaism" ? Right - just look at that picture of Michelle and Barack. They look like they can't wait for the party to be over.
13. Responsibility
Sam ,   IFAD saba   (11.01.12)
At least 75% of the responsibility of the state of relations between Obama and Bibi lies on Bibi's shoulders
14. lets be honest..american jews are embarrasing...period
JL   (10.31.12)
15. Not all US Jews, though.
Kobi Marin ,   Tel Aviv   (10.31.12)
Ersats "Sarahs", who comfortably from their chairs in Brooklin advocate the One State solution are the dangerous ones. Most of US Jews are now aware that Israeli right is driving the country to the abyss and they are leat leat distancing themselves from Israeli policies. The dangerous lie with Ersats Sarahs that preach the end of the Jewish State by means of incorporating millions of Arabs in our midst. Time for US Jews help us, decent Israelis, to dissociate us from Palestinians by negotiating and giving them their State. Time to recognize that they have a leadership that can govern them and leave us alone, in respect and dignity. Ersatz Sarahs, who never served the army, who never drained a swamp, has no right to mess in our businesses.
16. I wonder where Mr. Kurtzer got his idea that America never
rachel ,   tel aviv israel   (10.31.12)
persecuted her Jews? Not on the state level, perhaps, as what happened in Nazi Germany, but in individual cases and places, Americans have attacked Jews for being Jews since the early 1800s. Even George Washington addressed this attitude, as did Mark Twain and others. Most of Hollywood original actors and producers were Jews and if they were not being persecuted, why did so many of them change their names to more Anglicized versions? If Jews were not persecuted, harassed and assaulted, why did Leo Frank die at the hands of a Georgia lynch mob? If Jews were openly allowed to live as Jews why weren't my grandparents able to buy a house or land in the US when they had the money to afford either one in the 1950s? Mr. Kurtzer may be a "Jewish scholar," but his American history education is seriously lacking as is his knowledge of the history of racism in the US.
17. "US Jews ashamed of Israel" is just a fat lie.
Jake ,   USA   (10.31.12)
18. Speak for yourself
AMERICAN JEW ,   ATLANTA, GA   (10.31.12)
Speak for yourself.....this American Jew stands behind and supports Israel wholeheartedly! G-d bless Israel!
19. Most American Jews are also liberals and ethnic Jews only
Vlad   (11.01.12)
They are assimilating and intermarrying at rapid rates, and will be gone soon anyway.
20. This is a left wing propaganda piece. American Jews love and
ron ,   la   (11.01.12)
support Israel. What they ashamed of is those kartziot who claim to represent them.
21. Not in Line of Fire
Zivron   (11.01.12)
The USA and many Gallus Jews are not in the line fire less even than the Haredim even the Arabs who see the convulsions in the Islam world and some prefer peace.They ought be better Treated .
22. I love my Israel and I am American & Jewish
Dina ,   USA   (11.01.12)
The Arabs are Occupiers of most of the middle east with a capital O! I wish Professor K would stop being so divisive and try to unite us. Storms are created by speech and we here in NY are still coming out of the biggest one ever, please Professor K let us be...
23. Shame?
Marsh w ,   Buffalo,ny   (11.01.12)
This rabbi is nuts.. Gets attention by writing his ultra lib message.. Just a load of BS He should pray for Israel instead of undermining it!
24. religious
JGrosman ,   Houston   (11.01.12)
I find the more religious you are the more Republican you are. It is the assimilated you are the more democrat you vote.
25. Take Shas for example
Yonatan ,   Washington DC   (11.01.12)
With such lunatics as Ovadia Yosef and his ilk its no wonder US jewry is distancing its self from israel. That man makes us ashamed to be Jewish.
26. Bibi-Obam bad relations comes as Obama cannot read His Bible
Jouko ,   Finland   (11.01.12)
27. Every true Cristian is proud of Israel and prays for her!
Jouko ,   Finland   (11.01.12)
28. I am ashamed of Arabs-they are occupying the land of Israel!
Jouko ,   Finland   (11.01.12)
29. More self-hating garbage from Jews, forget it.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.01.12)
30. This article is pure Obama propaganda. I
Gila   (11.01.12)
Next talkbacks
Back to article