Gaza man shot dead by IDF troops in Eshkol
Ilana Curiel
Published: 26.11.12, 08:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
1. As they said in the Old West, give him a fair trial and take
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.26.12)
him to the nearest tree and hang him.
2. salma?
David ,   Haifa   (11.26.12)
was it salma? no! too bad Thank you Zahal for protecting us
3. Thank God!
Johannes ,   Norway   (11.26.12)
4. Baruch Hashem! Thank you IDF for doing a good job.
Keep it up!   (11.26.12)
meir elazar   (11.26.12)
Breaking in to a woman's (or anyone's) apartment at 4am and attacking her with a knife! He shoot be shot to death on the spot. Not to be released in a furture prisoner exchange. The only possible exception might be if the person is part of a terrorist organization and one must get information about other members of the cell.
6. Talk about a case for personal gun ownership
Cameron ,   USA   (11.26.12)
7. To: Cameron at No. 6
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.26.12)
The intended victim fought back and caused the attacker to flee. Evidently, she did not need a gun.
8. no7
ashqelon   (11.26.12)
9. #7 Sarah B. She was stabbed! We don't know the extent of her
meir elazar   (11.26.12)
injuries. At least she had the guts to fight back for which I commend her. Not everyone could do as much. It is hard to say what the outcome would have been had she had a gun. But apparently she did all the right things and possibly would have shot the attacker as well before sustaining injuries.
10. # 1 Bunnie, I love your comment & its sentiment
Moshe ,   Usa   (11.26.12)
11. Bunnie, I would pay for the rope ....
trump   (11.26.12)
12. Arab terror
Best thing just shoot & kill the trespassers, save time, and money
13. why you killed him ? :(
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
SHAME ON YOU. #2 he he he, be aware !
14. Salma no 13
LION OF JUDAH   (11.26.12)
What do you expect ? To give him a prize for his crime. Salma, you know you have donkey brain.
15. Salami no 13.
16. #13 Salma B. Gaza /USA armchair terrorista
They pop up everywhere. He he he
17. Seriuos question to Salma 13
Dear Salma, Can I send you a robber & killer with knife to your home middle of the night to rob you and to kill you. Please let me know your address and will be sent this evening.
18. #14 no, but why didnt they arrest him ?
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
I don't believe a word from your coward army. am sure he is innocent .
19. To: Meir at No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.26.12)
Actually, the article mentions that she sustained light injuries. I'm just not a big fan of guns in the home. A good alarm system is equally effective. Although I do acknowledge that, given the rabble that surrounds Israel, guns are necessary. But the attacker is dead, and that's a good thing.
20. To: No. 18
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.26.12)
You also believe that the ersatz "Palestinians" have a country. They don't. You also believe that the ersatz "Palestinians" have a long and storied history in the State of Israel. They don't. No one really cares what you believe or do not believe. Your grasp of reality is tenuous at best. Your comment at No. 18 only serves to underscore your dissociation from the truth.
21. Salma no 18
any comments to talkback no 17
22. no 18 Salma
yes like a married women with 20 children and claim she is still innocent &VIRGIN never been touched by a man
23. #18
J ,   L, UK   (11.26.12)
Yes, I'm sure there was a completely innocent explanation for breaching the border and entering someone's house with a knife at 4am. That smacks of innocence, such innocent behaviour. Seriously, do you not apply any critical faculties ever, do you just assume the opposite of what Israelis say, even if it makes not one iota of sense?
24. #17 sure you can , I have one condition
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
send me a JEWISH robber and killer and I will know how to take the knife from him without killing anyone ;)
25. This happened thanks to the new "easements" allowing arabs
hippocrates ,   earth   (11.26.12)
in aza to get much closer to the security fence....stupid decision, clearly, and this example proves it. If anything the 300 meter buffer should be increased to 400 meters, as weapons technology gets greater. Terror must face consequences not rewards.
26. sorry salma we dont have jewish robber and killer
jew ,   europe   (11.26.12)
we have to send you arab one , those are too many so you will get him for free . enjoy!
27. #24
Job ,   beer sheva israel   (11.26.12)
just give me your address
28. The Palestinian attacked his equal.
Israeli ,   Haifa   (11.26.12)
A woman. Its all he could do. Won't DARE attack an Israeli MAN!
29. #21 done :)
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
30. # 24 Oh Salma!
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.26.12)
You are killing me. I am dieing laughing.
Next talkbacks
Back to article