News
Gaza man shot dead by IDF troops in Eshkol
Ilana Curiel
Published: 26.11.12, 08:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
31. Do Even the Zionists Believe
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (11.26.12)
1. That a guy only armed with a knife attacked and threatened the lives of multiple IDF thugs, armed to the teeth, and had to be shot to protect their own lives? 2. That this was anything more than a criminal break -in, as the "security services" first concluded, before they started searching for justification for cold blooded murder and suddenly changed their mind and said it was nationalistic?
32. #18 Salma
donsaliman ,   Nahal Oz, Israel   (11.26.12)
Forget this person had a knife, he broke through the fence and entered a house that is not his and yet you say he is innocent. You call the Israeli army cowards, but it is your own so called army that hides behide innocent people, and uses them as human shields. Your leaders hide underground and let you out in the open to be injurned or killed for their acts. Wake up Salma, your leaders are more dangerous to the people in Gaza, then Israel, and what makes it worse for you and us, is that you believe them and trust them. You could have had a state as your own since 1948, if you would have made peace with Israel. I am sure you will not heed from what I wrote but sometimes the truth hurts
33. How would you react to assailant with a knife attacking
meir elazar   (11.26.12)
you in your apartment at 4am. Would you give him "treats"? Would try to psycho-analyze him? Any rational person would kill the animal on the spot. He forfeited any reason to allow him to live. PERIOD.
34. #26 another jew replied to u
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
read comment no. 27 :P
35. To: No. 31
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.26.12)
1. Yes. 2. He crossed into Israel illegally, and sought to commit a crime -- probably murder. The IDF did their job. The criminal would have been apprehended, but he chose to attempt a futile assault on armed IDF troops. Stupid move on his part, but you'll never lose any money betting on ersatz "Palestinians" to always do the stupid thing.
36. Salma no 24
(11.26.12)
You cannot even wash your hmm
37. חבל ששכחתם להגיד בכותרת שהוא מחבל
נופר   (11.26.12)
מי צריך תקשורת זרה עויינת כשיש את YNET
38. 16 they are the same person
(11.26.12)
39. i guess
gingimax ,   istanbul   (11.26.12)
they could have tied him to a motorcycle and dragged him through the streets
40. #32 suppose he's found guilty
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.26.12)
why didn't they arrest him ? this is the question
41. fence
spookey ,   birmingham uk   (11.26.12)
hamas wants the wall taken down and more crossings opened , and it will end up like here in the UK with scum we have from eastern europe robbing and killing us ,
42. #24 salma
aaron ,   toronto,canada   (11.26.12)
sure you can.We jews are smarter than that.Salma did you ever see the movie THE UNTOUCHABLES where sean connory says to the man that came into his house to kill him with a knife?He says "JUST LIKE A TIPICAL WAP COMES TO A GUNFIGHT WITH A KNIFE"that sums up you palis.
43. #40
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.26.12)
Why should they arrest him? He could have stayed home and broken into your house where I am sure he would have been treated with respect. He made the choice and Israel took out the trash. You should be thanking them.
44. #35 - You Say You Believe This, But I Can Not Really
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (11.26.12)
believe you are that naive and stupid. Although it is clear from your posts that you are a raging racist, so perhaps that is clouding your thought process. How many times have Isreali security forces been caught in a total lie, that was only uncovered due to irrevertable video evidence? And how many IDF forced have come clean through "Breaking the Silence" about the attrocities they witnessed that were covered up by the IDF. You are either a liar (e.g., Hasbarist) or totally blinded by your racism and sense of racial superiority.
45. A friend asked me "How did this happen?"
David ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
When I told him of this event... I replied it happened because we didn't really finish the last operation with a ground invasion. Not even a week can pass without something evil coming out of Gaza
46. to 44
jew ,   europe   (11.26.12)
doug wake up and change your wrong news chanel are you living on a mars?
47. Looks insane to me. Not a terrorist & not a criminal.
Michael ,   California, USA   (11.26.12)
Is there such thing as postmortem psychological evaluation? I would bet he left a record back home.
48. no peace
mehrdad ,   germany   (11.26.12)
you can not have peace with beasts who only want to break into your house to butcher your 3 months old babies with knives.
49. #13 - right, perhaps he was just mentally retarded
William ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
as is the case with all of the other racist Arab attackers, no? More than likely, he resisted arrest and lunged at the soldiers with his own weapon. Now the good news - he gets 72 virgins (or raisins, depending on who you ask), and Israel has one less prisoner to support until a prisoner swap.
50. Why Y-Net ????
A Shvitzer ,   israel   (11.26.12)
Your paper calls him an assailant this person was a TERRORIST use the correct terminology!
51. #18 - really? This is a tough one to justify
William ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
He's crossed into enemy territory, broke into a home at 4am, had a knife, and attacked a woman resident. So, let's see how "Palestinians" would turn this into victimhood. "He was so desperately hungry due to the punishing blockade on Gaza and only ventured into Israel to find food for his starving family which had shared their last olive pit between them. He entered a home near the border and went directly to the kitchen to make himself a sandwich and gather more food. He was spreading hummous with a knife when he was discovered by an evil Jewess who tried to seduce him (or drink his blood, depending on who you speak to). The Bedouin swung around quickly, startled, and begged to be left alone with his dignity intact. She came closer, stripping her clothes in the process, and he instinctively brought his arm up to cover his eyes but forgot of the knife in his hand which accidentally cut the woman's face and shoulder. She screamed and he ran in fear, back to Gaza towards his family with no food in tow. When he was caught by the IDF, he pleaded to return to his family but the evil Zionist soldiers taunted him, cursed Muhammed, and tore pages from a Koran they always carry in their vehicles to offend peaceful Muslims in this manner. Knowing his end was imminent at the hands of the filthy Jews, he took his knife and ran towards them yelling 'Allah u'Akbar" and "Long live Hamas!" before he was shot dead." I hear there'll be a mini-series on this just in time for Ramadan 2013.
52. #24 - you'll promise him a peace plan that you'll break?
William ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
53. #31 - even if just a criminal action...
William ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
shooting him is fully justified, especially considering where he came from and the typical actions from Gaza for years. Like the article said, he could have entered the house and robbed them blind without waking the woman, but he intentionally woke her and attacked her. Pretty sure if this happened in Rochester as well, it wouldn't be considered an innocent theft.
54. #44 - you mean "edited video evidence"?
William ,   Israel   (11.26.12)
by the very groups that support "Palestinian" violence and still refuse to hand over the unedited raw video they took? Sure. There's credibility for you. And too bad you consider Sarah B a racist for stating facts. But then again, when people like you run out of counter-arguments, they revert to name calling. Even Jimmy Carter did it so you're in good company with fellow useful idiots.
55. GO IDF! Kill them one at a time if you have too!
Michael ,   Canada   (11.26.12)
56. #13 Salma - Also she was protecting her 4 children
meir elazar   (11.26.12)
From information that has come out since, the woman contact people to get help and people in that location are all too familiar with terrorist infiltrations. I don't know what happened when IDF caught him 2 km away but I stand on my original statement that such TERRORISTS must be killed on the spot.
57. For Salma
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.26.12)
An old aphorism said : in the middle of so much trees you can see the forest. Applied to Moslem Word in general and Salma particullary; With so much criminals in your mist you are not able to distinguish from good and wrong from good and evil, from pervert people to genuine people and on and on because your fraude people has long list of "achivements"
58. A terrorist less. Next !
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (11.26.12)
59. excellent work troopers
jack bauer   (11.26.12)
60. Gaza man shot dead ,...
split ,   US   (11.27.12)
Now you can blame him for a terror attack and whatever you wish like it wasn't in your interest to find out how he penetrated your air-tight border.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article