Jewish Scene
Polish court bans ritual slaughter
AFP and Ynetnews
Published: 28.11.12, 13:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Have faux “mercy” on animals
Mark Levin   (11.28.12)
and you will end up not having true mercy on people! Germany perfect example.
2. But slaughter of Jews is ok.
SG ,   Teaneck   (11.28.12)
3. As Yizak Shamir once said; 'They drink antisemitism with...
Wise Historian ,   Ramat Gan   (11.28.12)
their mother's milk"
4. but why?
jew ,   europe   (11.28.12)
there is absolutly no reason why it should be forbbiden. Already in Uk they proved (and not first time) that animal doesnt suffer, contrary suffer less that slaughtering by electric shock or guns. ANTISEMITISM with all this cirses in europe they have time to bother them self with jewish ritual staff... it something remained me.....
5. No2
sasha ,   us   (11.28.12)
What a coincidence!, Steven Spielberg has just started work on a new Hollywood blockbuster title 'Jews killed millions'...highlighting the countless savage atrocities committed by the >predominantly Jewish< communists in Soviet Russia, Spain, Poland and all the other countries subjected to the red terror murder machine. Mr Spielberg who is himself Jewish, said that; "it's about time that a movie was produced showing the terrible crimes carried out by Jews against gentiles
6. Great !!! ,...
snag ,   USA   (11.28.12)
A creative way to got rid of invadors ;)
7. Go vegan so we can all get along...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.28.12)
and so the animals won't have to suffer for our supper.
8. But Israelis will still go to Poland, spend money there?
Sue ,   Los Angeles   (11.28.12)
9. #1 Hey, you remind me of those "merciful" PETAists
10. Exports go down, imports rise, what dingbats.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.29.12)
11. Animal versus human rights
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (11.29.12)
These articles always remind me of Nazi Vienna. When the Jews were rounded up for deportation, the equivalent of the RSPCA or NSPCA went around collecting the dogs and cats that belonged to Jews, to make sure the dogs and cats did not suffer! Jewish Law was concerned with animal welfare long before any animal rights group existed. If you look at Samson Raphael Hirsch's two volume Horeb, he lists an entire section of Torah laws governing our treatment of animals.
12. ritual slaughter
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.29.12)
Ritual slaughter is one of the most painful way killing animals. It is disgrace for the human kind. Have ever some of us seen ritual slaughter. It is NIGHTMARE. It reminds me How some people are cruel and ...
13. #5
Jew-biker ,   Canada   (11.29.12)
You come across as a rabid Jew-hater. "predominantly Jewish communists" you have to worry! No slander should go unpunished! Yobani pidar!!! Jhidi naidut tebya i tviyu mamu!!!
14. sasha @ 5 ,...
split ,   US   (11.29.12)
He should join forces with M. Gibson and have a promotion for free ;) ,...
15. 12: To Thomas: you dont know what are you saying..
jew ,   europe   (11.30.12)
I am sure you dont know dettails, please do me a favor. Go tu one Rabbi and ask him about a whole process and after judge. You cant judge from what you see if you are not a docktor or veterinar! But please ask Rabbi he will be happy to teach you what it is.
16. #16
Thomas ,   Poland   (11.30.12)
I know that animal is conscious until its last breath. The moment of death is horrible. You and I and all people around the whole world will understand some day.
17. It is about...
Walt k ,   Sherbrooke, Canada   (11.30.12)
Time to turn vegetarian.
18. In Mongolia, they carefully slit a horse's neck & put some
Moshe ,   Usa   (11.30.12)
blood into a large wooden (about 15"deep by 3 1/2 feet wide) then they add grown ingredients. I believe it is grain, maybe with some fruit. But my point is that when they have enough horse blood, they put a bandage round the neck of the horse & the horse is not alarmed. They ferment the mixture & the nomadic tribe drinks it. The horse does not feel hurt, just helpful. Of course if an animal bleed out fully it goes to sleep (as unconcious) , collapses & dies as in Kosher slaughtering.
19. 18 - Not so ,...
split ,   US   (12.01.12)
Mongols made their booze from fermented mare's milk they call it kumys - Sometimes they used horses blood as a food sustenance but they didn't cut their veins they poked it with the tip of knife. After they were done they pressed the wound for a while to stop the bleeding ,...
Back to article