News
After UN vote, Israel to suspend PA funds
Omri Efraim
Published: 02.12.12, 12:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
111 Talkbacks for this article
61. To: No. 57
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.02.12)
Clearly you seem to think that Israel is acting extralegally. I invite you to cite to international law and statute that prevents Israel from doing exactly what it is doing. Hint: You will be old, trembling and grey before you can cite a single statute or principle of international law that Israel has violated. The fact remains that Israel has violated NONE. And you had better do some research into how U.S. aid to Israel is structured.. It is evident to all the intelligent and knowledgeable people on this forum that you are completely ignorant. So, the ball is in your court. Put up or shut up.
62. Abbas pay your bills like the rest of the world do
zionist forever   (12.02.12)
This decision to take the money to pay the electric company was to punish Abbas for going to the UN but at the same time Israel has been providing the PA with power and turning a blind eye whilst they don't pay their bills for decades. Its Israeli taxpayers through higher bills who have been paying so Abbas can have free electricity and its time to get tough on the PA. Palestinians want a state then let them act like one and pay their bills like the rest of us do. We should be taking more of this money we collect to pay for other services that Israel provides free of charge like hospital treatment, water etc.
63. Israel failure
tinux ,   Sweden   (12.02.12)
It is clear that no one likes Israel even its most lovable friends. The reason? It is clear that those who are anti-Peace anti-Justice and pro-Nazis/Apartheid system can no longer see sense. you starve a dog but you can not stop him from barking. sooner the west will leave Israel alone with no friends and help and no support surrounded by Victims of crimes and occupation. the Day Palestine wakes up not even the UN can stop them. That day is when Jerusalem will be return back to its owners.
64. Israeli military, go to hell
Mary Sparrowdancer ,   Tallahassee, Florida   (12.02.12)
May IsraHell and its inhabitants vacationing on stolen land in Palestine from New Jersey, New York, and Miami, all go to hell.
65. punish Pals ??
Iletzter ,   TA- Israel   (12.02.12)
More bla bla. I don't understand. If they owe the money , why doesn't Israel transfer the funds and pay the debts , as normal practice ? Why are the telling everyone about punishments etc ? Are we still in kindergarten ? Instead of doing- the government excels in talking. DO MORE and TALK LESS. Initiate massive building without any announcements ! Transfer the funds and pay debts - without any announcements. With announcements- Bibi will get a call from Hilary in a half hour- and will rescind this decision for punishment!
66. To: Olavi at No. 58
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.02.12)
Even if they could, the EU wouldn't. When the EU was flying high, they never did anything for the ersatz "Palestinians." Now that the EU is broke, I doubt they will do anything more than pay lip service. That's all they can do, and it is all meaningless.
67. Netanyahu's words merely echo UN 242
hmp49 ,   Asheville   (12.02.12)
what's the difference between: "I would like to clarify once again – there will be no Palestinian state without an agreement guaranteeing the security of Israel's citizen, there will be no Palestinian state before the State of Israel is recognized as the Jewish people's state, and there will be no Palestinian state before the Palestinians declare the end of the conflict" and UN 242 which states Israel will occupy until: " Termination of all claims or states of belligerency and respect for and acknowledgment of the sovereignty, territorial integrity and political independence of every State in the area and their right to live in peace within secure and recognized boundaries free from threats or acts of force"
68. Will the Twain never meet??
Jo ,   uk   (12.02.12)
Wow you do know your history! Thank you for sharing that. . . May God and Grace be with the parties who are attempting to broker peace for the people of Israel. SHALOM.
69. Palestinian Electricity Account
Frank ,   South Africa   (12.02.12)
When I'm overdue on a services account it gets CUT-OFF. Surely the same should apply to the Palestinians. And then they should lodge a deposit to cover one months supply. Itjust good credit control - nothing to do with politics!
70. Israel should not give them even a cent
Oleg ,   USA   (12.02.12)
Do not provide them with money, water, electricity and most important - jobs. If they are the country, they should think about themselves on their own. let them starve, if they want.
71. # 61
Giora Me'ir ,   USA   (12.02.12)
As for as the colonization goes? The 1949 Geneva Convention. Not to mention promises, explicit and implicit, to the US regarding expanding the illegal settlements. It's a one way street. The US gives aid, military and non-military, and Israel does what ever it wants.
72. Pot, kettle, black
Michael ,   Australia   (12.02.12)
Comment # 1 - From a country that has actually stolen land from its original inhabitants, that's a bit rich. Selfish and childish behaviour is more often demonstrated in our country than it is in Israel.
73. Support for Israel
Michael ,   Australia   (12.02.12)
Dont worry, there is a lot of support for Israel in every nation especially amongst born again Christians. Secondly, whatever the West (or the world) tries to visit on Israel, will be visited upon them in a manifold way. We forced Israel to tolerate the Intifada so we opened the door for terrorism to come to our own lands(9/11, Spain, London, Bali and more recently France). We are forcing Israel to accept near annihilation and destruction - so too will it be visited back on us. God have mercy on us.
74. Stop the wimpy statements & response and do what Israel MUST
Esq62 ,   Israel   (12.02.12)
adopt the Levy Report and annex all of Judea & Samaria. NOW.
75. PA? What's the PA? You mean PALESTINE
Nour ,   Palestine   (12.02.12)
The State of Palestine joined the comity of nations on Nov. 29, 2012, as per UGNA resolution 67/19, and covers the entire West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and the Gaza Strip. The State of Palestine had the blessings of 138 nations directly, and 41 indirectly - while only 3 nations opposed, and a bunch of obscure islands. From this point onward, it is called the State of Palestine - and NOT the PA. Some countries have already started the legal renaming (Norway), and you can rest assured that the remaining 138 nations are taking steps as I type this to upgrade Palestinian missions to full diplomatic missions (Embassies and attached immunity to diplomatic staff). Mabrook Palestine!
76. Another anti Semite
(12.02.12)
Maybe you should take it up with G-d who gave all this land to His people.
77. #71 but you support colonization
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (12.02.12)
According to just minor treaties like the UN Charter - it's Israeli territory. You are supporting the colonists that are attempting to steal our land. As for your threats about aid - it is less than 2% of our budget. Our aid to the Arabs is over 50% of their budget. Think about it. We should simple use their tax money to protect ourselves from them
78. no 64
(12.02.12)
may allah the muslim god punish this show dancer who is currupting young muslims men for sex
79. @1 Look At You White Treatment of Native Austarilians
emanon ,   USA   (12.02.12)
You're treatment of the original people o f Australia was even harsher, and longer lasting, that what the white settlers inflicted on the Native American peoples. What is more, you have the arab - Israeli situation totally backwards. Look how many times Israel has offered to negotiate peace, look at the land Israel has needlessly given away to the arabs, look at which side DELIBERATELY targets civilians (even their own) and look at how many times the arabs have either rejected these offers outright or moved the goal posts.
80. tinux Sweden no 63
(12.02.12)
You are right no one likes Israel, because the Jews will not let the European or the world to dictate to Israel what to do or not to do ? Secondly it is fact that the European do not like Jews. Jews were slaughtered like sheeps in Europe because our land Israel was occupied by invaders, but now thank G D that we have liberated our Country Israel and we made it from dessert to Paradise. Ah, Jerusalem already been returned to the real owners the Jews. Nothing is written in the Quran and the OLD/NEW TESTAMENT that Israel, Jerusalem, & other places belong to Islam. I am not sure if you are White Swedish or immigrant ? If you are white Christian Svenska, start to practice Islam, by NO alcohol, no bacon, no pig meat, no X'mas or Easter holidays, so sex until you get married, and start to wear veil and cover your ugly face.
81. Impotents
Taxpayer ,   Hod Hasharon   (12.02.12)
Little people with little minds doing little acts to show their childish pique. This government, which does not know how to make war and does not know how to make peace, has brought upon us the latest defeat, and now they want to rob us of what is left of our dignity by their pathetic childish behavior. Surely between them there must be somone with an IQ in double figures who is capableof understanding that they are getting us nowhere
82. #4 is that why
the mad Zionist ,   sf-ny-is   (12.02.12)
millions of Jews were massacred in the holocaust? Is that why the grand mufti collaborated with Adolph Hitler in the 30's to help exterminate the Jews? Your point is well taken by ignorant misinformed followers. You make it sound like the Jews started being disliked after they rebuilt the lost country of canaan. The only problem is your 2000 years off the mark doggie. Let me ask you a question, If the Palestinians decide they want peace and recognize Israel and start their first state alongside Israel, will you then be ok with Israel? Or will you not be happy until Israel is completely dismantled and a 1 pali state replaces it? If that's the case, tough titty. Even if you don't believe that there ever was a Jewish state in the past, there is one now and it will be here until the sun swells and dies. I'm all for the Palestinians getting their first state ever, it's people like you and the Palestinians that don't want peace until Israel is destroyed. Just be aman about it, say it in those words. I'm sick and tired of people like you with balls too small to come out and say that.
83. Nour
AL QUDS ALYAHUDI ,   QUDS HAKA AL YAHUD   (12.02.12)
What Mabrook Palestine ? Did you get independent and Jerusalem the capital for Palestine ? Let Norway start legal action against Israel with pleasure . We will see who will win. Israel will shame all Europe including Mahmoooooooood al Hamooodi . WELCOME TO ICC
84. #1
SA ,   USA   (12.02.12)
Hey Rob, it's too bad for you that "utterly selfish and childish behavior" is not a crime that is liable to lead to sanctions. Good luck with that one! On the other hand it's nice to see Israel having some balls. --Sam
85. To: No. 75
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.02.12)
Sadly for you, United Nations General Assembly resolutions are unenforceable and nonbinding. Are you prepared to go to war to enforce it? LOL! We'll make short work of you. Perhaps Norway and the remaining 138 nations will invade Israel on your behalf. I don't recommend holding your breath, though. In the meantime, however, Israel will continue to build, Israel will withhold the millions of dollars in financial aid to the ersatz "Palestine" Authority, Israel will revoke all ersatz "Palestinian" work permits and Israel will annex Judea and Samaria. What are you planning to do then, chica? What's a "state" without land? Of course, you can have Gaza. Good luck there.
86. #64, Hey Mary !
Gabe ,   Canada   (12.02.12)
It is time to take your pills ! All of them. At once.
87. Paving the road for BDS, more sympathy for Palis,...
split ,   US   (12.02.12)
A tribe of thieves and rip-off artists that's how the civilised world see you ,...
88. A reasonable business-like response
Dallas ,   Canada   (12.02.12)
Israel is behaving exactly as things happen in business - abuse your financial responsibilities and there is consequence. That's the real world, and is a completely reasonable response. Any Pali state will have to address their chronic welfare status and stand on their own - a wake up call to bring this fantasy back to earth.
89. Israel
Nathan ,   Sellersburg. USA   (12.02.12)
The world attempts to hold Israel to a standard no other country has ever been held to. Without holding the Palestinian terrorists to any accountability. So glad Israel refuses to bow to pressure'
90. Blessing in disguise
Can   (12.02.12)
UN vote was blessing in disguise that forced Israel to build and please build massively including my lovely Bethlehem in Judea of all places. What I meant is that Judea and Samaria is for Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article