Shuafat teen: I was beaten by undercover cops
Noam 'Dabul' Dvir
Published: 10.12.12, 23:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. Shafat Teenage
There is no smoke without fire. He must have been involved by throwing stones. These teenagers must understand that by throwing stones at IDF & Israeli Police, these stones can kill and can injure person forever. Throwing stones not throwing sweets. He deserve what he got.
2. A Palestinian child will never getr justice in a jewish cour
3. 2 You are right because...
Walt K ,   Sherbrooke, Canada   (12.11.12)
His parents won't be jailed... because they didn't make their job.
4. To No 1
Basel ,   Jerusalem   (12.11.12)
You have talked and acted like those officers who beated him. Israel calls it self the most democratic country in the region?! The soldeirs have beaten the guy without knowing his name?!, what he did?! They basically acted like the judge and the police. Israel is democratic only fr the Jews!!! More acts like this will grow hate rather than peace. Israel is already goal ally does not to be internally isolated.
5. To: No. 2
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.11.12)
For one thing, I do believe that if you participate in a riot and then resist arrest, you are no longer a "child." Violent youths -- as young as ten or eleven -- are treated and sentenced as adults in United States courtrooms. They cannot be sentenced to death, but they can be -- and frequently are -- sentenced to life imprisonment. They serve their sentences in the juvenile justice system until they turn eighteen; then they are sent to state penitentiaries. Don't do the crime if you cannot do the time; don't resist arrest, but be thankful that you resisted arrest in Israel. In most American jurisdictions, you'd be shot dead in your tracks.
6. Play with fire : get burned : don't cry !
YIsrael of Jerusalem ,   Jerusalem, ISRAEL   (12.11.12)
I'm supposed to feel sorry for this punk ? If it was a Jew attacking an Arab cop, he would have been shot outright, no questions asked.
7. No, nor a Palestinian child get care in a Jewish hospital.
Serge ,   Montreal, Caada   (12.11.12)
And a Palestinian will never sit as a Supreme Court justice in a Jewish country. And an Arab will never serve as a diplomatic emissary of Israel. Aren't you getting tired of your lies yet?
8. Police beat up
Anita   (12.11.12)
charedim all the time but ynet's only concern is when arabs get beaten up.
9. Youthful THIEF was trying to steal Neshek
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.11.12)
he should be thankful that he wasn't short
10. #2 He's not a child, he's 17 years of age
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.11.12)
Don't ttry to make him out to be an infant with a lollypop . At age 17, Hamas or the PA would be quite eager to enlist him in either of their terroirist organizaitons He was lucky that he wasn't shot, which he should have been, when caught in the act
11. A Jew child will never get justice in a jihadish court
12. In most countries....
Dan   (12.11.12)
If you raid a police post, you should expect to be roughed up
13. #2
No Jew in any Islamic country will get a fair trial or any real justice!
14. He definitely caught an ass beating
Cameron ,   USA   (12.11.12)
Damn little sympathy though. He went out of his way to raise hell with others, and they took the time to raise some hell with him. So be it.
15. Shuafat teen
David ,   Germany   (12.11.12)
Poor boy, sitting around doing nothing but sending a text message to his mother and then the big bad Jews come by and beat him up. Save your garbage for CNN and the German DPA! They love to report news like that. Dear Arab propaganda department, the rest of the world is starting to see your through your bullshit!!!
16. what is this so called democracy human rights are...
thomas   (12.11.12)
you people getting insane, all the rules changes if there is an existential threat
17. #8 - Anita
Ariel ,   Modi'in, Israel   (12.11.12)
A criminal is a criminal and deserve what ever they have coming to them whether they are arabs, haredim or secular!!
18. Freedom for Palastine! End.
Murat   (12.11.12)
19. Don't complain, LEAVE!
Terry ,   Sydney, Australia   (12.11.12)
If the pretend Palis don't like Israel defending itself from their perpetual vicitmhood inspired violence and hatred, then let them leave. there are a host of sharia compliant hellholes surrounding israel where they could feel at home. No jobs for them. No economy for them. No future for them. But that's what they want to reduce Israel to, sans Jews, of course. Don't whinge, pretend palis, LEAVE!
20. # 7 Serge you are a liar
Yerach ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (12.11.12)
There is an Arab judge on the Israeli Supreme court & there are Arab Israeli diplomats as well as Arabs sitting in Keneset. Your lies stem from your ingrained Anti-Semitism. Arabs living here have more rights & freedoms than in any Arab country & in some cases have more rights than Jews (ie.affirmative action) Get your facts straight & tell the truth.
21. What happened here was wrong
Sarah   (12.11.12)
Police should never allow themselves to loose their temper,and act in such a violent way. On the other hand,the youth in question,was no innocent bystander. He was involved in a violent riot throwing rocks and firebombs,which do kill. And police officers friends were injured,which is probably why they lost their cool with him in the first place,and number 2,if you want to talk about children not getting justice,what about the Fogel children? They were sentenced to death without a trial. The 4 month old baby was just sleeping in her crib when she was stabbed to death, not out rioting throwing firebombs and trying to murder police.
22. Arab must be innocent
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (12.11.12)
According to Israel's enemies they always are!
23. Basel no 4
Personally I do not think this guy is innocent. If so, he deserve what he got. I have seen many videos as well as on Aljazeera, and do you remember the small blonde girl when she was cursing and shouting to the IDF, and her mother was encouraging her. What do you expect. Jews were like mouse in Arab lands, and cannot even open our mouth. Israel is democratic country to all her citizens including Arabs. How many Arab members of the kenesset. Israel is isolated by your nation.
24. Murat
Freedom for BALESTINE is in hell
25. He wont be attacking Jews gain for a while.
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (12.11.12)
And, it sends a message to his other gang members NOT to attack Jewish soldiers.
26. #16 trhomas
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.11.12)
This "child" or his brothers & sisters have been caught at our checkpoints, wearing explosive vests Feel free to t ke chances with your own life, not mine
27. #21 Sarah
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (12.11.12)
Forget the rock throwing, nobody sneaks into Police Station to throw rock, they go into to steal GUNS
28. Suspect
Lio ,   London UK   (12.11.12)
"Youth suspected of attacking border police post....." suspected being the operative word here, yet most of you have him hung, drawn and quartered before he's even been tried. Even Sarah B the ersatz "lawyer" who should know better than to find someone guilty by dint of his ethnicity.
Back to article