Opinion
Opportunity in E1 siege
Avi Zimmerman
Published: 27.12.12, 20:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
31. #11 International law
Raphael ,   Netanya   (12.28.12)
As a proficient lawyer, you might know that the Green Line was never an internationally recognized border, at the express demand of arab negotiators in Rhodes 1949. So private arab property is respected by the israeli courts, but wasteland and public or religious properties are under israeli sovereignty as long as no boundaries are bilaterally agreed upon.
32. To No. 20
Bertram ,   London, UK   (12.28.12)
It is said that neurotics build castles in the air and that psychotics live in them. You have clearly made the transition from from the former to the latter. You have your own 'reality' which is shared solely by those who are similarly deluded. This is much the same as the story of the sycophantic courtiers of the 11th century Danish king of England, Canute, who believed he could use his 'divine' powers to hold back the incoming tide. The wise king demonstrated in no uncertain terms that he did not possess such powers. Thus, it will not need the world to stop the 'repatriation' of the Arab population to Jordan, merely the Jordan government to say 'thanks, but no thanks'.
33. #23 rm - arrogance?! Yes!
solomon ,   bklyn   (12.28.12)
Except you speak of the “Pals”. Those who openly say that Israel should let them return, yet their land will be judenrien. Those who twist and turn so as to not actually sit and talk. Those who have rejected generous offers, but in return say that they want everything they demand, and THEN they’ll talk. Sorry, but Israel cannot, and will not, commit the national suicide you wish upon it. Yes, I copied this from another one of my posts. That's because willfully blind people are copy cats of fiction.
34. castles in the air
yosef ,   williamsburg US   (12.28.12)
Sarah b sometimes gets a little annoying but you know what....there is very little she says that i don't agree with and with posts like yours we need someone to annoy others! .You obviously are the one who is deluded because your rant made no sense.
35. RM #23
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (12.29.12)
In this matter the EU is irrelevant. It's not their business to be telling other governments how to run their countries. To think they can is arrogant in itself. Israel may seem like a small potato to you but it has God's blessing. You don't have to believe that but like it or not you are going to continue to see it. It's ironic that you should be pointing your finger at others. I suspect they all have a finger they would just love to give you for your opinion.
36. Interesting view.
bob k ,   orlando usa   (12.31.12)
One thing is true: European Christians used to be able to tell Jews what they could do - where they could live, what they could work at, whether they could own land, when to get inside the ghetto gates, whether they could live or die. or in tolerant lands whether they would have equal rights. Everything has changed, except the desire of these Europeans to tell Jews what they can do. Now though, the EU cannot force Israel to transfer land to the PA. After Gaza, the Palestinians will have to make peace with Israel before more land is transferred to them. I don't want the Palestinians in a Jewish state and they cannot be expelled nor should they be unless they all attack Israel. But another Arab state is a very big risk ffor Israel not the EU or anyone else. Israel should tell the EU to pressure the PA to recognize Israel as the Jewish state, give up all demands for tranferring Arabs into Israel which negates the very idea of a Palestinian state, end all rocket attacks on Israel and make a full peace..
37. Dont forget your medication
Jon ,   USA   (01.03.13)
because when you are off it you think that what you wish inside your heart is reality. You can do a reality check with your Dr.
38. To #35 God's blessing????
Jon ,   USA   (01.03.13)
Who told you that? God? when that happen? If it has God blessing, couldn't he be more benevolent and give up the Saudi Arabia oil?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article