Opinion
Who are the extremists?
Andreas Fagerbakke
Published: 02.01.13, 11:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Andreas, while you ask these questions start packing &leave
tom ,   tel aviv   (01.02.13)
Eurabia! Answers are aplenty, but they make no difference: Europe's going to get what it's asking for. Come to Israel or China :-))
2. The answer.
Jules   (01.02.13)
The extremists are Arab League agents, whose living expenses are paid by the oil revenues.
3. yes the world is all upside down and inside out
Ilana   (01.02.13)
However, this is nothing new. I am so glad of these articles. There are sane, right side up people in the world!! Yay!! Thanks!
4. Andreas, thank you for your efforts!
R ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
They are many and you are one person, it takes guts to do that, thank you!
5. Kol Hakoved
Ellen ,   Israel/NYC   (01.02.13)
Thanks for telling it like it is. We now all need to continuously work to get this message out. The ideas that are pushed re: Israel are such hate and such lies. We have only ourselves to blame unless we are ALL "screaming from the rooftops" what the truth is!
6. The Jewish people's and that of Israel's toward the Arab
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (01.02.13)
Israeli conflict has always been one that relies on solid grounds of international law, on universally accepted ethical values and on historic rights of the Jewish people. The people who need to answer hard questions are those singling out the Jewish people - clearly, an act of anti-Jewish racism!! - and deny it and only it its historic rights, its universally accepted ethical right of national self-determination and independence, and its legal right to that part of the country between the Jordan River and the Med. Sea, only 23% of "Palestine" - to be "the national home for the Jewish people" as it is spelled in several instruments of international law. Indeed, it is time to be on the offensive, demanding of people why they treat us, Jews, with a sense of racism, anti-Jewish racism at that.
7. Thank you for trying
Veronique ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
Thank you for trying to talk to people who don't want to listen, who have been brainwashed so many years that they are unable to see the truth. All you can do is try to convince them one at a time and then slowly the tide will turn. A lot of Moslems are actually starting to see the truth and to talk but those are the crazily bravest ones. The others wait to see who is going to be the strongest. Keep trying and God bless you!
8. The world did not turn upside down..
L.A ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
it's just turning muslim.
9. #1 Why China? I'm kinda curious.
Avan   (01.02.13)
10. An even better question.
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (01.02.13)
Why does the Western politics and Human Rights organizations support Islam regimes and extremist movements over Jews, when Islam represents everything repulsive to the West. The list is endless, Islam is the anti-thesis of the progressive ideals of the entire Western world. Answer: The West has no free will, it has degenerated to the point they cannot function for their own welfare. A symptom of civilization prior to imploding.
11. Thank You Mr.Fagerbakke for your support of Israel & the
Moshe ,   Usa   (01.02.13)
Jewish People.
12. We would not need the checkpoints
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (01.02.13)
or the walls, if we stopped occupying Palestine. Doesn't matter how much you spin it, we are occupying another people's land and they are understandably pissed off about it And unfortunately with the advent of modern communications Planet earth know what we are doing. You talk about having to defend our opinion, why do you think that is? The vast majority believe in Israel's right to exist, the problem and it is all our problem is that Planet Earth also believes in the Palestinian people's right to exist. Until our politicians sort this out, we will have to continue to attempt to defend the indefensible.
13. Unfortunately some of the worst offenders
Ralph Haglund ,   Sweden   (01.02.13)
are Israeli leftists. Barak took away most road blocks to appease Obama, not because statistics showed you could do it, and terror in Judea/Samaria is approaching a third intifada. And what is the orders to IDF? Attack Jews there, not terrorists!
14. Excellent article, I agree totally.
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (01.02.13)
The principle of Israel's policy is defensive. Arabs have questoned the very existence of jewish state since the beginning. And no change ever since, they attack by wars, with nazi style propaganda, terrorism against induviduals etc. Israel must defend itself if does not want to be annihilated. A very simple matter recognised by the author, who is an objective person. Unlike the millions of european antisemites, who have no eyes to see and no ears to hear. I recommend this self defensive tactic for europeans too, against the same muslim agressors in their own countries. Vote for B. Netanyahu !
15. Boyle Spoiles the Planet
Kenny Karph ,   Canada   (01.02.13)
For the past three decades, Francis A. Boyle has provided the leadership of the Palestinian people with advice, counsel, and representation at all stages of the Middle East Peace Process http://www.counterpunch.org/2012/12/04/an-interview-with-professor-francis-boyle/
16. #12 do you really believe that?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (01.02.13)
Is that why everybody has to take off their shoes to get on a plane in the world? Because we live on OUR land? Or that the hundreds of thousands of terrorist attacks from Judea, Samaria and Gaza that happened from 1948 to 1967 were because of the 'occupation'? Obviously you are totally clueless and ignorant of every fact. Hamas has in it's charter to kill every Jew in the world, the PLO merely every Jew in Israel.
17. I think he will prefer to stay in Europe
mmm ,   Europe   (01.02.13)
and so do I
18. Andreas is right, the rest of the world is wrong.
(01.02.13)
19. Simple, concise, to the point
Ezra ,   San Diego USA   (01.02.13)
Good article, it needs to be repeated in other areas on line. It will be because I'm going to copy/paste and save it for later arguments will idiots on youtube. Suggest everyone do the same.
20. Poorly argued
Ferdinand ,   France & Israel   (01.02.13)
Support for Israel is always welcome, but this op-ed was disappointing. The poor rhetorics aside, it makes the fundamental error of thinking that the extremists have to be EITHER the Israelis OR the Palestinians. As anyone with the slightest insight already knows, the picture is much more complex. There are extremist and moderate Israelis and there are extremist and moderate Palestinians. There are definitely more moderate Israelis than more moderate Palestinians (by a wide margin) but let's not forget that we have our fair share of extremists who just as uncompromising as the more extreme Palestinians.
21. To #12
ilana ,   netanya   (01.02.13)
I know that you are probably not interested in opposing views, but anyway... The other day there was a survey showing that 67% of Israelis support a 2-state solution, i.e. a state for the Palestinians. As far as we can tell, Hamas supports a 1-state solution - they say they want to get all Jews out of Israel, make it ALL Palestine. In this state of affiars, how exactly is it Israel's responsibility to solve the problem? I would be really interested to know.
22. US Jews have turned upside down
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (01.02.13)
By voting for Obama. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
23. Who are the extremists?
Abiytal ,   Canada   (01.03.13)
Excellent points. The extremists are those that wish to see Israel the Jewish state destroyed. Those that hide their anti-semitism behind anti-Israel statements.
24. Is #12 another sockpuppet or "Sarah B" is just a coincidence
leo ,   usa   (01.03.13)
25. Unhappily it is not true
Veronique ,   Israel   (01.03.13)
We got out of gaza with no preconditions and what happened? Now a lot more Israelis are in danger everyday. So sorry, no! When the Palestinians will have enough, we will sign peace and we'll get rid of the checkpoints! We have to pity our kids who man the checkpoint! Remember the Israeli soldier and the little Palestinian girl who was later invited to Turkey to receive their congratulations! Mind boggling!!!!
26. Extremists
Robert ,   tampa   (01.03.13)
The settlers who believe that they are a "master race" and non-Jews are sub-human and act out these views violently are the terrorist extremists and they aren't Palestinian.
27. Extreme Denial
Tom ,   Columbus USA   (01.03.13)
Fagerbakke's shrill skreed is so full of half truths and fabrications it is breathtaking. He infers that he wants "both Arabs and Jews to live freely in all of Jerusalem." When he makes a case that Palestinians who were driven from their homes in West Jerusalem should have the same status in Israeli courts to recover their property as Jews who were driven from their homes by Jordanians, then we can believe him. Otherwise it is difficult to understand why YNet gives this truth torturer a platform.
28. war
JS ,   USA   (01.04.13)
"Those who want millions of Palestinians to return to Israel, a development that would practically destroy the only safe haven that the Jewish people have on this earth"-this is a canard used by extremists who actually seek nothing more than the status quo. The fact of the matter is that war, real war, decides these matters. Its unfortunate that the Israelis fought over one of the last non-soveriegn pieces of land left on the earth but the biggest mistake was to leave it as that.... thus occupied. TB'rs like Salma and Nour should be Israeli citizens right now living in and ruled by Israeli law.
29. "right to defend".
TINSC ,   Fairbanks, AK   (01.04.13)
Andreas: Israel does not have a RIGHT to defend its citizens. It has a RESPONSIBILITY to defend its citizens. Don't fall into the anti-Semites' trap! Israel need not request or even demand the "right to defend" its citizens. Israel is a nation. It's leaders are held accountable by the public. The nation is RESPONSIBLE for defending the public. There's a difference! Regards, TINSC (aka There is NO Santa Claus)
30. #26 you are an extremist
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (01.04.13)
No Jew has ever stated what you claim - nothing a racist moron like you write is even remotely close to a fact. Why don't you put your white sheet and hood back in the closet, go to bed and sober up before posting anymore of your racist lies.
Next talkbacks
Back to article