Woman jailed for drowning son seeks IVF
Naama Cohen-Friedman
Published: 01.01.13, 22:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
9 Talkbacks for this article
1. We HAVE gone through the looking glass
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.01.13)
Fertility treatments? For this sorry piece of sh*t? Oh, I don't think so. Her inability to concieve is quite the best thing that ever happened to civilization. Let's leave it go.
2. If she agrees to give up the child to a family that wants
Rivkah   (01.01.13)
to adopt, perhaps that would take away the terrible burden of loss of both her first child and her husband. It would perhaps atone for her removing the first child from this world, thinking he would be better off in HaShem's Kingdom than on Earth where abnormal children are treated unkindly by society and then worse when they are grown, prey for aggressors and sexual perverts. She was wrong and is paying a terrible price, but her broken heart needs healing and the gift of a child to another family might heal a lot of sorrow in them all. For her to keep the child would not be wise, but giving birth as a surrogate mother could help her and another couple.
3. I did not have the "Mommy" gene myself, but my sisters
Rivkah   (01.01.13)
did and one said if she could not find a husband, she would go out into the streets to have a child but she would not be deprived of being a mother. That is how strong the drive to reproduce is in some women. Myself, I could not bring children into such a horrible world but I was not blessed with the "Mommy" gene. She should be allowed to be a surrogate mother. The killer of an Israeli Prime Minister was allowed to father a child he could nor raise. What is fair for males should be fair for females. She should be allowed to be a surrogate mother although the curse of her sins on the child might be a problem since Swedish studies show that an adopted child of a criminal parent is more likely to become a criminal than an adopted child of non-criminal parents.
4. prisoner
joemoer ,   israel   (01.02.13)
she is serving a prison sentence..when she finishes her prison sentence she can go and do what ever she wants ...i dont believe that prisoners should have basic rights...that includes no weekends home(what is that),no special diet,not allowed to vote, etc etc i also think in her case she should not be allowed to breed....
5. Give her a puppy to take care of first.
Ilan   (01.02.13)
I have no problem with IVF in general but the criminally insane are not good candidates.
6. You are going to let a mentally ill woman have a child ?
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (01.02.13)
Is the whole system crazy - she'll just kill this next child, too.
7. She deserves no puppy either
..   (01.02.13)
8. #6 Barbara
Keren ,   IL-BR   (01.02.13)
You are asolutely correct.
9. Is this some kind of sick joke???
Israelit ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
The woman shouldn't be permitted to care for anything more challenging than a pet rock! She murdered her son, for crying out loud!
Back to article