News
37%: Mentally disabled should not vote
Omri Efraim
Published: 02.01.13, 13:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. Must be talking about Shas voters
Yoni ,   Herzaliya   (01.02.13)
2. Alarming Schmalarming. Depends on How Question was Asked
EGGM ,   Petah Tikva, Israel   (01.02.13)
There are many types of mentally disabled people. Some of them can operate normally like most people in many/most cases and/or with the help of medicine. Yet others are completely crazy and cannot be allowed anywhere near civilized society. So the findings don't mean anything until the methods are revealed. What questions were asked of the poll participants? How were they asked?
3. What is meant by "mentally disabled?"
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.02.13)
That's a broad category. There are people who are hampered by low IQ (mentally retarded; Down's Syndrome) and there are people who are hampered by mental illness. The study is fraudulent on its face if it did not distinguish between an individual who is retarded and an individual who has, say, paranoid schizophrenia. People are incapable of full integration into society for a variety of reasons. To slap such an overreaching category as "mentally disabled" upon all of them is quite unfair. The lovely young woman who makes my coffee every morning at Starbuck's is mentally retarded. The unwashed and quite intimidating man who hangs around outside Starbuck's, yelling at people who are not there is, I believe, schizophrenic. What a world of difference.
4. This would exclude most of the Knesset Members
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (01.02.13)
5. Unbelieveable
shmuel ,   au   (01.02.13)
maybe a large percentage of Israelis would like to see mercy kiling of the mentally retarded. Now where did I hear about this before?
6. #5: I would have said it by some at YN doesn't like me!
Dee Bee ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
Maybe some in Lik-Bet will qualify? You know, the ones who are economically challenged caused by a greed but do not have the ability to ask why.
7. get the doctors to decide at election time
zionist forever   (01.02.13)
This guy sounds like he has his head screwed on properly so let him vote. I have a neighbor he has a 40 year old daughter becauase of complictions at birth she is mentally handicaped and her problems are so severe she shouldn't vote. A possible solution could be when elections are announced any handicapped people who want to vote must go see a doctor who will decide if they are compitent. Not wanting to live next to a mentally handicapped person understandable. Partly its not undersanding the problem just seeing the symptoms but they can also be annoying. This daughter of my neighbor drives me mad, if I hve to go round there for something. She is like an excited dog because she is so pleased to see me and goes shouts out that I have come. I was at lunch once on Shabbat and her father asked if I had a girlfriend I told him no then jokingly says you got to get one you should be married by now. His daughter then asked if she could marry me. I didn't knwo what to say because how do you say no to somebody who doesn't understand? So for sure lots of people wjll not feel comfortable living next to sometbody like that.
8. No.5, why would you even mention
On my behalf   (01.02.13)
anything like this? Can you really speak on behalf of "a large percentage of Israelis"? You should definitely be ashamed of yourself and next time think before you scribble.
9. #8: So where were you when Michaeli called .....
David ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
the Black "illegals" a cancer and that Gays commit suicide at 40? Where was the "large percentage" when it came to the gross negligence by Ministers Steinitz and Yishai when 44 Israelis, including a 16 year old kid who was a volunteer figh fighter, were burnt to death in the Carmel Fire Disaster? The vast majority did seem to raise a finger and we will see how the "large percentage" vote on 22 January. Scribbling is part of Freedom of Expression but it seem that in Israel we have Freedom to Hate everything that is not Right-wing!
10. Let them vote.They will vote...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (01.02.13)
what their caregivers advise them. Caregivers deserve double votes.
11. But they HAVE too vote.....
William ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
otherwise the Israeli Left would not be represented at all in govt. ;-)
12. Then my vote is it!
Last Sane Voter ,   AndNotSureBoutMe   (01.02.13)
13. Ethics & Virtue
robert jackson ,   New Castle Delaware   (01.02.13)
I do not believe Humans know how to be Ethical towards their fellow man.
14. #6 - intellectually dishonest
William ,   Israel   (01.02.13)
come, now. You know as well as I do that the Israeli Left is full of greedy people and captains of industry, and did nothing for social justice while in power. Your agenda blinds you to the common thread of money and power among all politicians, in order to paint the Right as heartless racist parasites who create all of the country's ills. Where have I heard that before?
15. I'm more afraid of mentally disabled politicians
observer ,   jerusalem   (01.02.13)
those still supporting Oslo and not seeing the street of blood, those supporting Jew free areas in Israel, those seeing corruption and doing nothing
16. Why?
DSV ,   Holland   (01.02.13)
Why would someone with the mental capacity of a 12-year old be allowed to vote, when 12-year olds aren't?
Back to article