Opinion
Outcome the ultimate test
Shimon Shiffer
Published: 15.01.13, 00:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Outcome
nadya ,   California, USA   (01.15.13)
Since it seems that Netanyahu and the far-right government will win Israeli elections, I think it will really be tough going between the U.S. and Israel. I think Israel will be in for a really hard time in many areas.
2. Actually, Sara didn't spend enough from 11B anti-Iran budget
Michael ,   California, USA   (01.15.13)
3. Table is set for imposition of '67 borders, Palestine Israel
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (01.15.13)
4. The article is rubbish but we need to destroy Iran's nukes.
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.15.13)
The author is an absolute hypocrite because he would never have supported Israel in attacking Iran's nukes. The author's pro-Obama bias is also nauseating as is his entreaty to cede Israeli land to the terrorist P.A. However, we do need to destroy Iran's nukes NOW!
5. Israel needs NATO to assault Iran
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (01.15.13)
Israel does not have the means to successfully attack Iran. This is not like bombing Osiriak, Iraq. We need tens of thousands of bombing sorties to successfully stop Iran's nuclear Jihad ambitions. This will happen. The US will intervene as the US and Europe realizes that Iran poses a threat to all of humanity.
6. Old newspaper.
Michael Pielet ,   Raanana, Israel   (01.15.13)
The Prime Minister has and will continue to handle the Iranian issue, in a manner that secures israel. Olmert and all others would have totally failed. Olmert is simply jealous. Olmert is an old newspaper that nobody reads anymore.
7. Cool it Shimon! Israel is just begining to re- discover her
tom ,   tel aviv   (01.15.13)
private parts (so called "balls"), that have been hidden for so many years! Give us another term, with the Lunatic Left out of the picture, thanks.
8. King BB = FAILURE
Haim ,   TA   (01.15.13)
9. He reached everything promised in 2009.
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (01.15.13)
Relatively good security, economics, demography what do you want more ? A miracle, that in such a hostile environment Israel exists. Netanyahu is the best political leader of all times in the jewish state. Vote for him !
10. NUCLEAR IRAN
JOHN TRAIN ,   WASHINGTON DC USA   (01.15.13)
This is an infuriating article. Netanyahu had to fight an IDF and intelligence “leadership” who refused to attempt to prepare plans. In United States we call this insubordination bordering on treason. He faced a US president who went out of his way to enable the Iranians to proceed. He had a Hillary Clinton and a Martin Dempsey to announce that the US had no red lines and no timetables. Now he has a Brezinski who urged that the US shoot down any attacking Israeli aircraft and a Hagel who made it very clear he opposed any attack or even preparation for attack on Iran. He faced American Jewish liberals who branded him a warmonger. Jay Street and Americans for peace now mobilized a violence assault on his character. The American reform movement has become a prisoner of saving the world at the expense of Israel. He faced in Israeli media with reporters distorting the facts and attempting to alienate the public and sow discord. He faced Livini,Peres ,Olmert and other self-serving politicians who still undercut him abroad and in Israel on this problem. He did not fail. It is newspapers like this one and writers like this one who are failing the Israeli public and endangering the survival of Israel.
11. #1 outcome
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (01.15.13)
In 1992, life was good: secondary boycott ended, negotiations for Arab autonomy, PLO non-existent, Russian-Jews integrating, Israel enjoying unprecedented legitimacy. Then the Leftists seized power, and Israel has been in for a real hard time. First Oslo War under the Rabin/Peres regime, stopped by Netanyahu. Second Olso War under the Barak regime, stopped by Right-wing Sharon. During Left-wing Sharon and Kadima Junta, Hamas takes Gaza, two lost wars, Shalit incident and unprecedented police violence against Jews with increasing anarchy in Arab sector. Netanyahu came and stabilized the situation despite the Israel-hating Obama and his support of the Brotherhood. I'd love to support the Left and have peace, but reality is different. Spin it as you like, every time the Left seizes power Israel is hurt, and the Zionists barely manage to save us.
12. #10 & #11- I entirely agree with both of you
Enzo Nahum ,   Rome & Tel Aviv,   (01.15.13)
You both make very good points. Netanyahu is a very good patriot and politician. He had to operate in a very hostile environment both at home and abroad. It is very distressing to witness the blind hostility to the welfare and security of Israel by the leftist Israelis and the foolish and ignorant attitude toward the elected government of Israel of the American Jews. This article by Shimon Shiffer is incompetent and unwarranted.
13. Professor Lielenbloom poll
(01.15.13)
Bibi-Bennet 44:15 Yahimovich - Barak 13:1 Livni-Meretz 5:4 Lapid - Mofaz 9:2
14. #11, Who has the "Power" in times of war?
Michael ,   California, USA   (01.15.13)
When wars break out, brave and pragmatic have the power. The military wins in the fields, not the politicians. Turn on the light bulb in your brain: Israeli Left won all the wars since 1948 -- yes, the workers, the kibbutzniks, the common man.
15. 14 Michael, California, USA
(01.16.13)
Abraham Lincoln was a Republican. Does that make G.W. Bush a great president? There is no connection between the Left until 1973 and the Left since 1982.
16. #14 response
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (01.16.13)
Please respond to the facts. First Olso War started by Arafat under Rabin, Peres failed to stop it, Netanyahu did. Second Oslo War started by Arafat under Barak, Sharon's Right-wing government stopped it. Only results of Sharon's Left wing and later Olmerd's Kadima government are two lost wars, Shalit, Hamas in Gaza, and Grads on Rishon. Tell me: with a record like that, why should we vote Yehimovitch, Zippy or Lapid and not Likud?
17. If the red line is breached
Zechariah   (01.16.13)
If the red line is breached all current policies of restraint are finished.Feral and Extreme reactions will occur that will sweep many along.
18. Bibi and Bennet might be good team
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (01.16.13)
19. JOHN TRAIN, 10, very well said
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (01.16.13)
Back to article