Jewish Scene
Indians exposed to Holocaust studies
Itamar Eichner
Published: 24.01.13, 13:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. The brain wash continues
Chutia ,   New Delhi, India   (01.24.13)
As long as every white gentile can be made to feel personally guilty for the Holocaust, Israel will get away with its illegal occupation of Palestine. Interesting that new targets are being sought for the brain wash campaign
2. Like they really care ;) ,...
split ,   US   (01.24.13)
If it wasn't pay for and a chance to see another country - A force fed duck farm comes to my mind ,...
3. Chutia
Gupta ,   Los Angeles, USA   (01.24.13)
Chutia you need to educate yourself. You are typical of the 3rd world leftists who try to exagerate and distort Israels position in order to deflect injustice in their own back yard. We have far too much inequality and injustice in India. Let's begin at home.
4. Japan, China, India
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (01.24.13)
Japan, China and India have no tradition of anti-Semitism, BUT where did they get the impression that Hitler was a 'hero'? In WWII India fought alongside the other British Empire forces, but mainly in Asia, so they did not face the Germans. Even that doesn't explain their positive impression of Hitler.
5. 1 , a new antisemite barker !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.24.13)
No brain washing , no illegal occupation . Look at the hatred between hindus and moslims in your country before you invent some stories
6. #Gupta
Chutia ,   New Delhi, India   (01.25.13)
I never knew that "I was trying to deflect injustice in my backyard". You are actually making me sound like a politician. maybe i should run for public office :) you can come back to india and help manage my campaign :)
7. #5, there you go again
chutia ,   new delhi, india   (01.25.13)
Don't you get tired of the word anti-semite?
8. 5 - Compiling a black list ? ,...
split ,   US   (01.25.13)
9. #1 chutia
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.25.13)
There is no ‘occupation’. The territoriesa are disputed. Before Israel, arabs in the area insisted they not be called “Palestinian”: they wanted to be called Egyptian, Syrian, etc. (the lands from whence they came). When you said Palestinian in 1948, you meant the Jews. Read some history. And some law; the real stuff. It will put the lie to your mindless mantras.
10. “Backwards swastika”
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.25.13)
FYI: There is an Indian good luck symbol in the form of a swastika, but ‘going in the other direction.’ It has been in use for centuries.
11. Why don't toy read Benny Moris and the new Historians
# 9   (01.25.13)
and learn of the 500 plus village"s the new State of Israel wiped of the face of the map , but thanks for the revisionest history
12. # 1 Also Israel's denial of the Armenian genocide
ben   (01.25.13)
Israel survives on PR. Notice they never released the video on the attack of the Turkish ship. 2010 there must have been hundreds of cell phone footage. If Israel wanted too they could show exactly what happened. Israel confiscated everything on that ship. But they didn't release the video only what they wanted the world to see Wonder why. I believe solders are taut to execute someone with two shots to the back of the head. Just like Hope kindergaden. brainwash them early
13. The swastica dates back to ancient
ben   (01.25.13)
civillizations like The Indus Valley civillization. Hitler took the symbol and perverted it. But it is an ancient symbol dating back to 3300 BC . Hitler used it for evil.
14. #10, Solomon
Chutia ,   New Delhi, India   (01.25.13)
Swastikas have been around since ages in India. Do you now expect people to stop referring to them? Or, will you call them...anti-semites? And, what's real histroy and real law by your definition? Is it something that goes along with what Israel would like people to believe?
15. 11
actually, benny morris wrote his recent book refuting your comments. upon further research in his field, professor morris changed a of his previous findings. READ HIS LAST BOOK, 1948.
16. split the Polish Catholic spin goon in USA
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.25.13)
If you want to have an audience to listen to your insane rantings I suggest you do that at your local mental hospital. There you will find an audience willing to listen to your lies, racism, hatred, falsification of history, facts and law, your twisted and warped world view and your relentless sickening racist hatred for Jews. Only nutcases would buy your crap LOL!
17. Who is Number 1?
American Hindu ,   USA   (01.26.13)
The No. 1 posted his name as Chutiya (it is a cuss word in Hindi and Urdu). In my opinion he is anti Israeli and likely not a Hindu or Sikh. Indians are about the most pro Israeli people on the planet, largely because we face a common enemy. Talking about read more of the Hindu Holocaust. For the last 1000 years Hindus have been killed in the name of "Allah the merciful".
18. #14 chutia
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.26.13)
I never said any such thing. (Note that the Indian 'swastikas' are a mirror image of the Nazis') Real history and real law is what I wrote in my post #9. Interesting that you don't dispute it. It you who are twisting history and law to what you would like to believe. Doesn't work that way. Sorry.
19. #8 split - yes, and you're on it...
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.26.13)
aren't you proud?
20. #8 That would be a long list, split
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.26.13)
With your multiple talkback names including chutia. Better yet, Ynet should ban you. That would be the proper response to your racism, anti-semitic, anti-Israel sentiment, lies, distortions. No one would miss you or care.
21. You either Cynthia
- ,   -   (01.26.13)
How bout that
22. # 15 thankyou for your comment I believe you will find
ben   (01.27.13)
that Benny Morris is an admited Zionist, he believes in ethnic cleansing and has stated that he believes Ben Gurion did not go far enough and should have ethnicly cleansed the whole area specifily the West Bank. As you said read his latest book As Zionist as he is and says he is it is not unthikable to consider they got to him. There are others who say what he says about the founding fathers of Israel [ terrorism massacres atrocoties] Namley Albert Einstien. Read what he said especialy when Begin came to America to campagn. Enstien compared Begin and other Israele's to the Natzis
23. #17, keep the investigation going :)
Chutiya ,   New Delhi, India   (01.27.13)
Gupta might be able to help you!
24. 13 & 14 . Nobody in Europe would have talked about a swastik
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.27.13)
if not the [mis]use the nazis made of it . For Europeans it's the [mis]use that counts .
Back to article