Report on death of 'Prisoner X' may be released soon
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 16.02.13, 21:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. Prisoner X
Fran Avishay ,   USA   (02.16.13)
Ynet, thank you so much for shedding the necessary light on this disaster. I have been sick at heart over the treatment of this Jewish son.
2. 1 regarding disaster
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (02.16.13)
the disaster in this story is that an israeli citizen who swore loyalty to the state, and swore to keep its secrets, in fact betrayed the state and caused incalculable damage to israel's national security.
3. Talkback
Fran Avishay ,   USA   (02.16.13)
You don't know that. For all you know he left a folder on a bus, or got drunk and said too much. You know absolutely nothing and yet you are so sure this boy was so terrible he had to be put in a dungeon until he despaired and killed himself. No more will I work for Israel. No more donations.
5. Maybe,
Fred ,   Midwest, USA   (02.17.13)
Maybe this man is not dead at all. Maybe he just disappeared...
6.  =)
Tom ,   Vancouver   (02.17.13)
Maybe he died by mistake during an intense bout of interrogation....?
7. 3 for all i know
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (02.17.13)
you are assuming that israel is a fascist state which incarcerates people for forgetting a file on a bus. your assumption is based on sheer ignorance. first, you need to understand that this man was arrested based on a warrant issued by a court; he was given lawyers, including a civil rights lawyer, to defend him; the justice ministry was informed of his case; his family was informed of his arrest; the australian embassy in tel aviv was informed of his arrest; the man himself was informed of the charges against him which he discussed with avigdor feldman, his civil rights lawyer; the man apparently rejected a plea offer. general ayalon, has just issued a statement that this man was kept under a pseudonym because he posed an existential threat to israel. this means that he had deep and intimate knowledge of facts that if revealed, could have caused deaths and loss of hugely important networks. by the way, israel does not need "friends" like you. give your money to the palestinians.
8. ben zygier
jews wide world domand transparentcy
9. aussies are not friers
no aliyah,no donations,no yom atzmaot, no chayalim bodadim from chol.
10. Prisoner X
Mickey ,   SYdney Australia   (02.17.13)
I think everyone needs to calm down. We really don't know the facts yet. Stop the speculation and rantings until the report is available
11. Wrong!
12. Zygier
Nick ,   Australia   (02.17.13)
Ah, so Israel is NOT a fascist state, where people mysteriously disappear or commit suicide in custody? Well, I must have been mistaken then like the rest of the world.
13. Only independent inquiry by non goveremntl
Eitan ,   Rannana   (02.17.13)
body has a chance of reveling the truth and publisize it. The security apparatece in Israel is most powerful and influential even the courts and MK's are afraid confronting it.
14. Do suicides have set apart Jewish burial laws
Roland Seener ,   London England   (02.17.13)
15. Could we start from 1948 again?
Michael ,   California, USA   (02.17.13)
16. PTSD linked report
tal ,   none   (02.17.13)
I am afraid to make any comment. Don't be shy as I am. prisoner X has many friends which were killed by order of my prime minister.
Back to article