On tape: Settler attacks Palestinian shepherd
Elior Levy
Published: 11.03.13, 19:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. Propaganda
michael Pielet ,   israel   (03.11.13)
Who do you believe. This is a propaganda film, trying to make the giborai Israel look bad.
2. Arab Settlers Trespassing On Jewish Homeland
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (03.11.13)
These provocations by Arab occupiers and foreign provocateurs are what is causing the conflict. The shepherd has no right to graze his flock on Jewish territory and this manipulative editing by Pallywood is not new. What's next CGI?
3. Ofcourse a leftist provacator was there
Dan ,   Tel Aviv   (03.11.13)
4. don't be suckered by the Arab and provocateurs....
r ,   Atlanta   (03.11.13)
if it is going to beron youtube you will be made to look bad...don't be suckered.
5. "Security officer of West Bank outpost"?
What the hell is that? How can an illegal outpost have a "security officer"? Has Israel become a full-blown banana republic?
6. The Video Shows Nothing of the Sort
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (03.11.13)
Amazing, One can see in the video that the Arabs are the aggressors and the security officer is attempting to prevent shepherd from trespassing. The soldier is clearly treating the Arabs gingerly and even the security officer is only trying to prevent the trespassing.
7. jewish settler say it all. Pure jewish racism.
kol nlderi   (03.11.13)
8. Arm the Palestinians
James ,   Canada   (03.11.13)
Palestinians should arm themselves to defend themselves against the Jewish settler terrorists. The IDF isn't going to do it, so it is up to them to defend their lands and livelihood from the Jewish settlers who seek to ethnically cleanse them from the lands.
9. #8 They are already armed
Dan ,   Florida - Tel Aviv   (03.12.13)
Dummy, who do you think have been attacking and killing Israeli's for the past 65 years?
10. #1 - go back to boca raton
Allan ,   Raanana   (03.12.13)
11. Judea/Samaria Jews are residents in their own land.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.12.13)
Judea and Samaria Jews are not "settlers". This is our land. Judea and Samaria Jews are residents in their own land.
12. Old Pink Panther, Stampede Sheep Overrun Jewish Village Ploy
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.12.13)
13. The solutions is for Jews
Clara   (03.12.13)
to be attacked across the globe. Then maybe they will learn their lesson.
14. This thug now represents Israel
Dan   (03.12.13)
It is Israel's support and encouragement of these thugs, under the guidance of Bibi and Shas, that has turned the country into a pariah. We must repudiate the settlers entirely and abandon them to their fate - they certainly don't care about ours.
15. There should be no Arab shepherds on Israeli land!
tom ,   tel aviv   (03.12.13)
16. Criminals Needing Guards
Golden Dome ,   Washington, USA   (03.12.13)
Jewish terror cells living as settlers need both security guards AND the Army to secure their crimes against the Palestinians. And its mostly funded by misplaced sympathy created by the Holocaust Industry.
17. Insufficient evidence
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.12.13)
The video begins with the Shepherd and his sheep away up on the top of a hill. The security officer is running up the hill towards the shepherd and a soldier is following him... What exactly preceded these actions? Why was the settler running towards the shepherd? Why did the soldier find it appropriate to chase after the settler? We can not know from this clip and we cannot judge from insufficient evidence. The soldier must be interviewed for his evidence. Also the other soldiers in the immediate area together with him that did not chase after the settler...
18. Why is this Eurotrash
flameofjudah ,   sacramento ca.   (03.12.13)
allowed to instigate this all the time? they work in collaboration with the arabs. They should be refused entry into Israel.
19. Jealous of the giborai Israel.
michael Pielet ,   israel   (03.12.13)
I was with Sgt. Benjamin Anthony tonight and we both believe Allan should go back where he came from, if they will take him.
20. #2 homeland
Rau   (03.12.13)
Do you have the title deed for this land, stamped by G_d? Or any other documents accepted by modern and civilized world.
21. #9
Rau   (03.12.13)
No Dan, the truth is Palestinians and israelis have been killing each other for the past 65 years. The only different, one is occupier and the other is occupied.
22. Settlers attack a Palestinian shephered
Al ,   US   (03.12.13)
Nothing new. These settlers are savages and cowards. Fully armed attacking a helpless shephered under the watchfull eyes of the security forces. The settlers are loosers in their own countries, they immigrate to israel to settle on stolen land from the Palestinians and subsidised by the Israeli government. World imposed sanctions did wonders to Israel's former best friend, South Africa, and will work on Israel as well.
23. Camera filming
Volvi   (03.12.13)
Why and how do you think this was captured on camera in the first place? Because it was a prepared provocation. They had cameras on hand for this purpose alone. Why arnt western provocateurs immediately arrested and deported? I believe the settler hands down, I know what the local arab intention is.
24. #8 rubbish James
Israeli grandma   (03.12.13)
You are just spewing anti-Israel propaganda. The only ethnic cleansing going on in this region is Mahmood Abbas attempts to keep his PA areas Jew-free. Also, in far away Canada you have no idea how serious the anti Israel anarchists and provocateurs are in their attempts to defame us.
25. @13
Walter ,   Germany   (03.12.13)
And what have German or French Jews to do with Israel? As much as I with the Irish Republican Army - nothing! And why would you like to attack people like Yoav Shamir, Norman Finkelstein or Omar Goldman?
26. Somehow or other a camera was handy
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   OSRAE;   (03.12.13)
ready to film the alleged attack The filml doesn't show what happended before for the camera started to tape
Back to article