Opinion
Separate buses just a symptom
Maskit Bendel
Published: 16.03.13, 14:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. Larry #25
Robert Haymond ,   Tequoa, Israel   (03.16.13)
Thanks for clarifying, Larry. Why not put your address in Israel under your comments as opposed to LA? That would stop the do-gooders like Elsie who, obviously, knows little to nothing about the reality of living here.
32. Right wing racist Jews steal land, hanging themselves, again
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.16.13)
33. Okay, solution:
Alex   (03.17.13)
Ban all palestinian workers to Israel, no need for special buses. I mean on what world does the authour live? Israel gives work for palestinians, and when special buses for palestinians to get to their jobs are established some leftist gets the idea to spew some bullshit about segregation. God damn, pathetic. Ban all palestinians from entering Israel and there wont be any problems...
34. Discrimination.
Nathan Rai ,   Bangalore   (03.17.13)
Protection may be seen as discrimination - between those who seek to destroy us and those who whom we seek to protect. I think Israel needs think deeply whether separation of those people who think that destruction of the Jews is their religous duty from those who beleive in the preservation / continuation of the Jewish way of life is negative discrimination or positiive discrimination. Note : Lets try not to use UN Human Rights logic wherein the right to kill Jews is a UN guaranteed / protected / implicitly promoted basic right.
35. Buses for Palestians only
Al ,   USA   (03.17.13)
This is a well written description from someone who sees it on a daily basis. The proof is that all the usual subjects attack the motives of the writer no one disputed the facts. As for Larry from LA, your racist remarks about riding with Arabs are no different than what they used to say about Jews in Europe.
36. #32- speaking of a Leftist shill reading from a script
William ,   Israel   (03.17.13)
37. So ACRI thinks its racist....but Pallys do not
William ,   Israel   (03.17.13)
So, does that mean ACRI is finally showing an agenda? PRI's The World went to the region and interviewed people about the new bus service. They found "Palestinians" actually welcomed it and found it beneficial to them. "36-year-old construction worker named Muhannad said, “this new bus is good. It’s only a $1.35 each way. It beats getting ripped off by gypsy van operators.” "“Twenty-five shekels.” Azzaem said. “That’s what we’ve been getting charged. It’s criminal. That’s five times the cost of this bus trip by the way.” Azzem said he would like to thank the Israeli company for providing a new service for Palestinian workers. " www(dot)theworld(dot)org/2013/03/new-israeli-bus-lines-for-palestinian-workers-bring-both-resentment-and-relief/
38. #8
Haredi ,   Hebron   (03.17.13)
How come the most vehement posts are from people living in the diaspora. How about coming here to serve in the army, pay income taxes and then give an opinion ????
39. #6 The palestinians you mean then, right?
Alex   (03.17.13)
Since they're the colonizers, Jews are the natives. And no, I'm not gonna quote some bible verse about God giving the land to Jews, bla bla bla. But genetic studies supports this claim aswell.
40. To No: 30
Mike   (03.17.13)
Your post comes across tinged with jealousy Robert, is it because that Ben is a real doctor (ie: hands-on healing people rather than a 'doctor' who has never treated a physical ailment) that you stoop to attempted petty character assassination?
41. Steve Benassi - fact shows YOU are the one on stolen land
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (03.17.13)
Typical pea-brained response from an American whitie sitting in his home on stolen native American lands, with his economy built by slavery. Benassi - you're a fraud and an obvious racist - unless, of course, your next talkback says that you are giving your house to the rightful native owners and going back to Europe where you came from. We Jews come from Palestine.
42. it's an opinion piece
Deborah ,   Wichita, USA   (03.17.13)
Maskit Bendel's piece is labeled "opinion," not news. Please learn to read.
43. #35, Al , USA
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (03.17.13)
Why don't you come here and ride a bus with only our lovely Palestinians partners for peace and then comment? FYI, I have worked with and have had friends who are Arabs, but this was before the first intifada. All has changed now. It is difficult to maintain friendships with Arabs today. But come here, you who call me a racist, and prove to me that I am a liar by just riding once on an only Arab bus...
44. Separate buses just a symptom.#25, #31.
Elsie. ,   Gush Halav.   (03.17.13)
#25, #31, Larry what was so unpleasant for you to ride a bus with Arabs?? did they insult you?shout at you?or in the worse case tried to order you off the bus?? reality check, Larry they are human beings just like you, and I am sure you wouldn't dare make these comments in Los Angeles, but you feel free to fling your comments around here, I wonder why!!
45. funny and sad
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (03.17.13)
One talkbacker wrote the reason that Palestinians can't take buses that are over the green line is because they aren't Israeli. Fine...than how come jewish settlers who live over the green line have no problem coming around the whole of the Westbank? That my friend, is the essence of the apartheidsystem that the writer so eloquently talks about. And it will get worse, much worse under the new government.
46. How is a honour crime punished
Raphael ,   Netanya   (03.17.13)
by a palestinian court compared with an israeli court?
47. #4. Daniel, this is not the Palestinian homeland
5th generation ,   Israel   (03.17.13)
The original Palestinians came here from the Aegean Sea area to conquer territory, and the rest poured in from surrounding countries (Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt) when the Jews created economic opportunities. They cleared out when Egypt said they wanted to cleanse the land of Jews, and for the Muslims to lay low until the work was done. Any Palestinians with true connections are those who were forced to convert to Islam from Judaism, and so were swept along with the rest.
48. To No. 43
Bertram ,   London, UK   (03.17.13)
Time for everyone to get off their high horses and stop being precious. We all sit on stolen lands. Every state that has ever existed has been established on the basis of violence and expulsion. The difficult but necessary question is: how to ensure life is reasonably tolerable, fair and just for all who live under a state's jurisdiction.
49. #47, Philistines were, and still are, Israel's worst enemies
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.17.13)
50. That is unfair.
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (03.17.13)
The refered discrimination is much unfair, opposed to Democracy and Humanism; Israeli values that her friends, like me, do admire. It looks like American South before Civil Rights'Law. All men and women must be allowed to get any buses; of course, without bombs or guns. Jewish State, never weaken your moral principles.
51. Funny and Sad #45
Robert Haymond ,   Teqoa, Israel   (03.17.13)
Jews aren't allowed in Arab areas of the Westbank. If they sneak in, they go at their own peril. We also don't go into Arab villages, those of us residing east of the Green Line. You have a very unfactual basis for calling it "apartheid" here in Israel. You might wish to actually visit Israel, particularly Haifa and Jerusalem, to see how mixed the cities really are. At least if you're going to demonize Israel, do it on an intelligent and factual basis. Your ignorance, however, is very common.
52. Mike #40
Robert Haymond ,   Teqoa, Israel   (03.17.13)
Your pop psychology is showing, Mike. Save your energy for something you actually know about.
53. Little Big Horn
Rolly ,   Tampa, US   (03.17.13)
Bibi, does the name George Armstrong Custer mean anything to you?
54. #50 Luis - Read my post #29
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (03.18.13)
it will be expalined to you
55. Re No 48
Bertram ,   London, UK   (03.18.13)
It should have referred to No. 41 not 43. Apologies.
56. To N 54
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (03.18.13)
Thank you, Ben Jabo. You have explained very well.
57. No one stops arabs taking any bus they want
Mordechai   (03.19.13)
Arabs can and do take the same buses as Jews. Its Jews who are barred from taking the Arab only buses. Just like Arabs can pray wherever they want and Jews are barred from praying on the temple mount. Its illegal to ban an Arab from living in the Jewish quarter of the old city. However if a Jew tries to buy a home in Hebron the ACRI will be first in line suing demanding the Jew be banned from buying "muslim" land.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article