News
PA to Obama: Complete settlement freeze essential
Associated Press
Published: 17.03.13, 22:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Arab Palestinians are always demanding more
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (03.18.13)
the arab palestinians have refused to negotiate with israel for the last five years. now they want obama to give them a state on a silver platter.
2. Sounds like the Pals have an excellent understanding
spyguy ,   seattle, usa   (03.18.13)
of how this entire trip is just a series of photo-ops for the president and he will do exactly ZERO for peace. The US has a well earned reputation for being owned by Israel and the POTUS being a subservient to Israel.
3. #1 No, they want something simple for a start....
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (03.18.13)
that Israel stops building illegal colonies in occupied Palestinian territory. Indefinitely.. until peace negotiations have been completed. The Palestinians have enough of Israel's trickery and chickanery: endless peace talks that lead nowhere, whilst at the same time Israel continues to create facts on the ground, like it has done for the past 45 years. The time for hacking through several Gordian knots is long overdue. Two states or one state: that is the question.
4. Arab misunderstanding of negotiating with the Jews
GZLives   (03.18.13)
is the Jews must completely surrender and give in to all Arab demands.
5. Build Build
Brod ,   USA   (03.18.13)
Israel should continue building on its Land of Israel. The PA is not god or king of Israel. They are Islamist-Jihadist usurpers, squatters and terrorists. They have no right intruding in Israel's internal affairs.
6. "two states in the 1967 borders"
Alex   (03.18.13)
Delusional Erekat hasn't understand that neither any Israelis or Obama has said this to be the goal, rather equal to the 1967 borders (with land swaps) is a possibility that the spoiled pallies need to accept if THEY want peace.
7. Never Accept Indefensible 1967 Borders
(03.18.13)
Annex Judea And Samaria And All Of Jerusalem. Dismiss the warq And Restore The Custodial Duties To The True Caretakers of the Temple Mount.
8. what the Arabs really do want is
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (03.18.13)
what the Arabs really do want is to regain all of what they perceive as their land. According to the Koran, the world is divided into two parts: Dir al Islam = land that is under Islam Dir al Charav = land which must be conquered for Islam, meaning the rest of the world. Since Israel was under Turkish rule, that is Islamic rule, Israel is considered dir al Islam and it is imperative that it be returned back to Islamic rule. Every moment that it remains under infidel (read Jewish) rule, it is an insult to all of Islam. Since according t the Koran, one is permitted to lie to achieve one's goal, they can slowly try to get us out of piece by piece of Jewish control until they finally achieve their goal of Islamic control over what they perceive as their lands. I urge everyone to read the Koran to understand exactly what Islam is about. With out reading the Koran, people have only opinions that vary from left to right.
9. Demand unlimited Judea/Samaria building NOW!
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.18.13)
The time is long overdue for Israel to stop pretending we accept the evil abomination of the Two State Final Solution. Judea and Samaria legally belong to Israel and are necessary for Israel's survival; as any literate school child can verify by looking at a map. Let every patriotic Israeli, and friend of Israel, rise up and demand UNLIMITED Jewish building in all of Judea and Samaria NOW!
10. So Called Settlements Have Nothing to Do with Peace
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (03.18.13)
The big lie of the Mid East is that there is a correlation between "settlements" and the peace process. Anyone who examines history and realizes that the PLO was formed in 1964 understands that the war against Israel has NOT one thing to do with "settlements" or the so called "occupation". These canards have cleverly fooled the masses in to believing otherwise. Israel should not freeze anything except the OSLO agreements which is a bogus and a means for the PLO to destroy Israel and nothing else.
11. 2 it is the arab palestinians who want a state
(03.18.13)
it is in their interest to negotiate.
12. no peace
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (03.18.13)
I fear that there will be no meaningful peaceprocess for the forseeable future. Both sides have completely cornered themselves with their own arguments...There's no partner for peace and settlements are not an obstacle on the Israeli side and the demand for an end to settlementactivity before talks start on the Palestinian side. Add to that the complete lack of trust and empathy for the other side on both sides and I think I will live to see another 40 years of conflict.....
13. "Illegal settlements", Ben?
Robert Haymond ,   Teqoa, Israel   (03.18.13)
As per usual, you come out with cliches and exhibit little to zero historical understanding. The land on which our Yishuveem were, and are, being built, is the land where our ancient founders and prophets dwelt. As to legalities, all English and former UN treaties and statements gave us much more land, then cut the amounts down but we still accepted it. Finally, the Red Cross, as a body of the Fourth Geneva Convention, made a declaration that these lands were "illegally occupied". Given your lack of astuteness in these matters, Ben, and your need to propagandize for your beloved "Palestinians", you should be aware that the basis for the Red Cross declarations has never, not ever, been opened to ascertaining how they came to its conclusions. In other words, it's accepted by Israel demonizers such as you but there is no legal basis upon which this decision could be examined. But people like you also like it this way. Finally, we live here in Yehuda and Shomrun (Judea and Samaria) and we are not leaving, not for you nor anyone else. Never again will we allow ourselves to be threatened without adequate defence.
14. Israel won the war against Jordan
Zev ,   Israel   (03.18.13)
but the Palestinian Arabs want the spoils.
15. To date, symbolically and otherwise, it has been Mr. Obama
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (03.18.13)
who has denied 4,000 years of continuous of Hebrew/Israeli/Jewish presence in Eretz Israel (Land of Israel). Let him first tell us, with his own words, that he was wrong. As a result of this denying, it was Mr. Obama who justified in his Cairo 2009 speech Israel's right to exist on the Jewish Holocaust in Europe, an event of only the 20th century; and than, cruelly, implied that the situation in Gaza was akin to the Shoah. It was on this basis that Mr. Obama, insultingly, demanded that Jews, only because they are Jewish - an act of anti-Jewish racism in the first place!! - refrain from dwelling in villages, towns and even neighborhoods of the Jewish people's capital city of the past more than 3,000 years, Jerusalem. Refusing to acknowledge the historic, ethical and LEGAL right of Jews to dwell anywhere within western Eretz Israel (Land of Israel). Indeed, it was Mr. Obama who viewed us, Jews, as strictly a community of faith rather than a people. How else to understand the fact that for years he spoke about "two-state solution", always refusing to refer to Israel as the nation-state of a people, of the Jewish people, thus "two-states for two-peoples" as the leadership of Israel utter the concept? I hope, before talking to us, Jews, the President of the most powerful nation on earth today will have the intellectual honesty to state to us: I erred in treating you and dealing with you in the way I have. I apologize for my wrong act of the past four years. But, will he...??
16. What really to be freezed
Istvan ,   BUDAPEST HUNGARY   (03.18.13)
is Abbas's abnormal brain activity.
17. # 9 Chaim YES!
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (03.18.13)
ISRAEL KEEP BUILDING FOR TOMORROW.
18. # 5 Brod AMEN BUDDY AMEN!!!!
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (03.18.13)
Betcha Israel issues thousands of new tenders for thousands of new homes. We American 'settlers' did pretty well when there were no 'talks' building committees, or government intervention. Israel has wasted valuable time in the pa road to nowhere.. Time to build the future of Israel. BUILD BABY BUILD !!!
19. Peace process
Get Real ,   UK   (03.18.13)
Commitment is also required from the Palestinians to return to the negotiating table primarily without demands and pre-conditions.
Back to article