News
Palestinian aide: Abbas demands two-state map from Netanyahu
AFP
Published: 05.04.13, 20:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
1. Abbas demands '48 armistice lines as starting point
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (04.05.13)
Abbas has yet again placed a new precondition on returning to the negotiation table he left when Olmert made his last offer 4.5 years ago. An offer that Olmert is trying to convince us he could have gotten signed by Abbas, but which Abbas never responded to.
2. I demand...without preconditions
Carl ,   USA   (04.05.13)
I demand Netanyahu produce a map and agree to the 1967 "borders" [and accept the "right of return" and pay restitution and remove all Jews from Jerusalem and the west bank...] before I will even CONSIDER negotiating his terms of dhimitude under Muslim rule. Oh, and these aren't preconditions, just our basic starting point for negotiations.
3. 1967
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (04.05.13)
Why is it that the armistice line prior to 1967 is being held as sacred? What about the lines defining Jordan as a separate country in 1922? Or the the borders known to Jordan in 1946? Jordan attacked the new State of Israel to conquer and occupy the West Bank from the outset of Israel's existence. Abbas wants a map? Then we should draw one that reflects this reality.
4. here we go again....:))
les ,   canada   (04.05.13)
even before any talk can start, our fair, reasonable, peace loving "negotiating partner" puts down the gauntlet. you fulfill ALL MY DEMANDS, then we can start "negotiating". lets hope hussein will not force bb in to an other turkey like "solution" for the sake of "peace".
5. Abbas needs to listen to what Obama said - no preconditions
Scott ,   Ramat Gan,Israel   (04.05.13)
6. I knew it was crap
Lee ,   NY, US   (04.06.13)
I knew Abbas would only try to get more and more. But I figured he would PRETEND to show good faith. My expectations were unrealistically high.
7. GO GO ABBAS GO GO GO GO
A Palestinian Observ ,   East Jerusalem   (04.06.13)
Abbas, as a Palestinian, I tell you go home and cut the BS, it better for us if Israel takes ALL... and offers the 2.5 million Palestinian in the west bank free health care, jobs and Education.
8. map of borders
arne ,   chicago usa   (04.05.13)
let abass present his map. I don't think he has one that's going to sit well with israel--back to square one--kerry might not unpack his bags.
9. Abbas should be grateful Israel will give him anything
Sam ,   Canada   (04.05.13)
Enough of this Palestinians demanding this and that. It's with a heavy heart that Israel should be giving Palestinians any part of the Jewish homeland. Peace depends on Palestinians accepting a Jewish majority Israel and compromising. If Palestinians can't commit to that most basic element then Israel should not enter negotiations and give away their positions under any circumstance.
10. Abbas puts the cart before the horse.
Alan ,   SA   (04.05.13)
11. "Israel must agree to all our demands before we negotiate.."
Naor ,   USA   (04.05.13)
12. I have such a map
steve from raleigh   (04.06.13)
A map of Antarctica.
13. Israel will "eat the pizza before splitting it", steal land
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.06.13)
14. Abbas Demands a Map from Israel
Jon from the NIles ,   Niles USA   (04.06.13)
Abbas is in his early 70's and has not accomplished anything substanative towards a genuine peace. His legacy will be unremarkable unless he changes course and works with Israel. If Abbas wants to die with a record of non-accomplishment, so be it.
15. im confused, didnt abbas say
the mad zionist ,   san francisco   (04.06.13)
Yesterday that he will not make any demands anymore to get the peace process started? Now its time for kerryto publicly chide abbas for his blatant lie. News flash for abbas, israel has her country, the losers dont make demands. Netanyahu needs to say that publicly because abbas' ego is and is constantly putting up hurdles for peace. We all know abbas & co dont want peace, they want all of israel, its about time people start calling them out
16. A map of Jordan is available on line
Steven ,   San Francisco   (04.06.13)
This is the only map this hateful rogue should even be given.
17. Hey!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.06.13)
Did not Israel win the War of Independence (started by the Arabs)? Did not Israel win the Six Day War (started by the Arabs)? So why is Abbas issuing demands? Israel should just tell him to take a hike. A loooooong hike -- all the way back to the Hejaz in the Western Arabian desert, where he comes from. 'Bye!
18. Right Wing Jews will try to steal all West Bank, expel Arabs
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.06.13)
19. Netanyahus map for the State of Palestine
Harold ,   USA   (04.06.13)
An excellent demand by Abbas because he does not want to have another 20 years of fruitless negotiations and he wants to know what what will be the real borders of the State of Palestine
20. Abbas the Knife ...
Mack the Knife   (04.06.13)
in the back! Send this silly old trottle home with a skelp on the bum!
21. Abbas and his two-state Fantasy
Brod ,   USA   (04.06.13)
Abbas and his wolves do not deserve any State by usurping the Land of Israel. These idiots simply don't get it. Judea and Samaria-the Land of Israel belong to Israel since ancient time. They have fooled the Hitlerite world with their crap. But they can't fool people who know the Bible and the GOD of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. GOD gave and restored the Land of Israel to the Children of Israel from Diaspora. It is time for Abbas to read the Bible and to stop dreaming of usurping the Land of Israel. As Ben Gurion says, it does not matter what the world says. What matters is Israel's security and existence. The world of dark forces can cry and dream and pressure. Israel can say NO to them. Period.
22. abbas
kwame oha ,   london uk   (04.06.13)
I said in the past, and I am repeating today that Arabs have no clue how to gain concession from Europeans in negotiation. by the very creed and nature of their religion, they seek to challenge the marvels of Jesus Christ, the son of God. inferiority complex compels them to resort to what they know best, threat, insane preconditions etc. Abass will rot in hell with his Raballah bigots. a state called Palistine is an illusion. Please, can someone help me here. Jerusalem and Palistine does not sound Arabic to me
23. Israel "must?"
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.06.13)
Abbas is delusional. He appears to quite have forgotten that the Arabs LOST the War of Independence. He appears to quite have forgotten that the Arabs LOST the Six-Day War. Demands? Oh, yeah. Not in this -- or any other -- lifetime. Send that terrorist hyena packing. He is truly out of his mind -- rabies, perhaps? Or divinely empowered? I'm a tell you what. When he resurrects the children who perished at Ma'alot because of him, I'll listen. Unless and until -- Abbas can retire his terrorist self to the sidelines and accept the fact that he represents a vanquished people. Vanquished people do not issue "demands." You can put a pig in a dress, apply lipstick, and polish upon its trotters. It doesn't change the fact that it is a PIG. Just like Abbas.
24. 9 Jewish homeland only within 1948 borders
lydia ,   Brisbane   (04.06.13)
Enshrined in UN181. Nothing outside said borders belongs to Israel. So Israel can't give Abbas anything it doesn't own.
25. Negotiations
LJ ,   Canada   (04.06.13)
Maybe someone should explain to Mr Abbas what the word "negotiate" means. What it does not mean is you demand an end result before you begin.
26. A line in the sand -- border suggestion
Ezekiel Glockenspiel ,   Jew City, Antarctica   (04.06.13)
Israel gives up Nazareth. Palestinians give up all land west of highway 60/95 (Nablus-Ramallah highway). Israel keeps Ma'ale Adummim as part of Jerusalem. Israel keeps only military bases in the Jordan River valley.
27. Abbas' Directive to Netanyahu
ltrail ,   United States   (04.06.13)
Abbas has denial issues. The Arabs lost all six wars against Israel. Netanyahu doesn't need to agree to any crazy border scheme.
28. Why would anyone be stupid enough to do this.
leo ,   usa   (04.06.13)
29. We the People know there will be no "Palestine", politicians
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.06.13)
on the other hand, must generate "business" in order to occupy themselves with "meaningful" tasks, hence the never ending Peace Process. In light of the Arab Spring developments (that only are the tip of the iceberg) one would have to be strongly suicidal to give up on land or give up on ANYTHING to murderous Arab usurpers! But yes, we must prop up Adolf Abu Mazen just enough, so he can fulfill his sorry-ass role in History.
30. Mr Abbase's Demands!
Son Of Cyrus   (04.06.13)
Whatever Next1 A Kiss & A Cuddle from Mr Netanyahu!!!
Next talkbacks
Back to article