News
Watch: IDF soldier lashes out at activists
Elior Levy
Published: 27.04.13, 21:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
31. Promote him to General!
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (04.28.13)
Love this guy!!!
32. Good! He is correct! Send them to live in Gaza
John ,   Houston   (04.28.13)
The soldier is right. Good for him.
33.  FOUR QUESTIONS
David ,   New York, NY   (04.28.13)
(1) Is there a party in the soldier's honor?(2) If so, how can I attend? 3) Where does he like to vacation?(4) If not free to take a vacation, which make of car would he like?
34. Bravo to Soldier
Bill Stein ,   USA   (04.28.13)
Bravo he should be decorated not punished.
35. Enough is enough
Sam1am ,   FCC, Calif   (04.28.13)
Good for him, I would have kicked this activist in the spot that hurts MOST.
36. Harrassment
SD Charger ,   San Diego   (04.28.13)
How much does one have to take before they snap? I'm sure he has to deal with people harassing him on a daily basis while he keeps the peace. So he yelled at someone, so what?
37. Well done, boy!
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.28.13)
38. Good for the soldier ! If he is a "threat"
DT ,   TA Israel   (04.28.13)
someone better look at the meaning of threat. I blame those who allow those activists to provoke. Question the soldier ? What are they doing about the activists ? Nothing . Typical
39. At least someone
PaulD ,   Jerusalem   (04.28.13)
is expressing what we all feel. Defending Arabs, empowering Islam to achieve their goals of a Jew-Free Middle East, and to have a government that allows Jews to commit the crime of supporting the enemy. is not free speech. It is freedom to cause harm to the state, and its people. Another hero defamed by the media.
40. his frustration is understandable
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israe   (04.28.13)
The far-left morons put the lives of soldiers in Jews in danger by interfering with defense operations. Most countries would not tolerate these foreign antagonists for even 1 min. These racist hypocrites think they have the right to tell people where to live. It's time to deport all of them.
41. Give him a medal
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (04.28.13)
42. Kol Hakavod!!
Avi ,   NY and Israel   (04.28.13)
We need more like him. Our enemy is even MORE passionate about eviscerating us. Its nice too see this soldiers "fire" which is laden in love for his fellow Jew and the land as well as contempt and hate for our enemies.
43. "Activists" = Narcissistic pest
Henry Hershkowitz ,   Ann Arbor.   (04.28.13)
Looking for attention. Noting more, nothing less. I would like see such "activists" harassing troops in Arabs country. In Iran, they would be hanged. In Saudi Arabia...probably loose a limb. In Israel, they managed to get publicity. I agree with this fine soldier: These are enemies of Israel.
44. colonisation
sam ,   montreal   (04.28.13)
when somone colonise your land AND your country he can do everything
45. bravo for the soldier, these activists are in LALA land!!
rachel ,   usa   (04.28.13)
when you let injustice rule you are certainly not a "peace activist"
46. this incident
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (04.28.13)
etcetera, standard apology...there's just a little too many incidents that point to the fact that it HAS become the spirit of the IDF......that's what decades old occupation of another people will inevitably do.
47. Occupation corrupts
Ethan Schwartz ,   Eilat   (04.28.13)
We have to get out for our own good. We are becoming the enemy.
48. Unbelievable
Harri ,   EU   (04.28.13)
Most of you seem to support suicidal action on the diplomatic front. That soldier is stupid enough to tarnish Israel, because he know that you like it and he doesn't understand what he's action does for the credibility of Israel. You don't survive if you don't get smarter.
49. Well said soldier.
Ben ,   UK   (04.28.13)
50. Love u soldier!!!
Gill ,   Modiin   (04.28.13)
Make him prime minister.
51. Lack of discipline
Susan ,   Manchester   (04.28.13)
Soldiers are supposed to be disciplined its not like the activists were violent. He obviously can't control his emotions and would be better taken off the front line.
52. Unbelievable
Avi ,   Earth   (04.28.13)
Right Israel doesn't exist for itself it only exist to impress idiots like you. Go worry about a real occupation and like Kurdistan or Chechnya, Leave Israel to it's own devices.
53. I agree with every word this soldier said.
MR   (04.28.13)
Bravo!
54. Unhappily (& Ethan Schwarz #47)
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.28.13)
Sadly most of the comments here are made on an emotional level and not on a thoughtful one. As #47 Ethan Schwartz wrote, this is not acceptable behaviour. The soldier approached the group of Arab shepherds; they did not provoke...except for the fact of their existence. We will never have peace if we cannot accept their right to exist along side of us.
55. Oh, my goodness! He yelled at them!!!
Lee Kaplan ,   Berkeley, USA   (04.28.13)
This obviously is cause for an investigation by the UN and the soldier should go to the brig for five years. In addition, reparations should be paid to the family of the Ta'ayush activist and Israel but force the IDF soldier to go through a second bris. Leave our soldiers alone. YNET tell me your nonsense against the IDF when three's really something to write about. Just remember, when the Arabs overrun Israel your newspaper will go away just like the Jewish homeland for the jihadi skunks. Somebody should give the soldier a medal, not discipline him. Israel has lost all respect for its soldiers.
56. Kol Hakavod
Phil ,   Amsterdam, Holland   (04.28.13)
I'm only hoping that you are flooded with support there in Israel. So many times I want to scream the same thing to these activists - the real enemies of Eretz Israel - so stay strong and true.
57. #54 get real
Lee Kaplan ,   Berkeley, USA   (04.28.13)
The Arabs keep saying they will destroy all of Israel and they want an apartheid state with no Jews in Judea and Sameria. Israel has bent over backwards 20 years to give the Arabs a state and make peace and it they who refuse. The Arabs are the ones who refuse to say Israel has a right to exist. Stop the lying.
58. As a peace locving saecular Jew
e xUK ,   TEl Aviv   (04.28.13)
could anyone explain,without prejudice against the Arab population,what this argument was about.As I see it on the video,there is an unarmed shepherd Arab guy with sheep minding his business being harrassed by a young soldier.There are peacewful peace activists trying to stop the soldier shouting at the shepherd.Although I recognbize that our young soldiers are torn in two directions ,this one could not handle it and lost his temper...OR maybe he is blatantly ant Arab or pro settlers,or is letting his personal prejudices impede his job.It is probably a good thing that I dont know much Of what happens across the line,because if I did,my stress levels,blood pressure and worry would increase even more.If I could speak Ivrit and Arabic and was prepared to have a tear gas canister fired into my face,maybe I too would be a "peaceful" demonstrator?
59. Amazing! There is at least one other
exUK ,   Tel Aviv   (04.28.13)
person in Israel who has the decency to speak up when a defenceless unarmed shepherd is minding his flock and his business.The other writers are just tarring all Arabs with the same brush and not thinking of them as individuals.I concede that the soldier is doing a difficult job.So if we had no settlements there he would not have to do it.
60. Truth to Power
Mike Nobel ,   Mesa, Arizona, USA   (04.28.13)
This soldier speaks the obvious truth to these Leftist organizers who seek to demoralize the brave soldiers of the IDF. These lavishly funded Leftist agents have joined the deadly enemies of Israel whether in the USA, Europe, or Israel. These same privileged Leftist elitists are the first to hide behind the soldiers of the IDF whenever an attack is launched by their admired terrorist allies and demand protection like the disgusting ungreatful spoiled brats that they are.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article