News
Netanyahu: Conflict over recognition, not territory
Associated Press
Published: 01.05.13, 17:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
1. Yeah
Giora Me'ir ,   USA   (05.01.13)
He wants the Palestinians to recognize that Israel owns all the territory.
2. To the editors of Yediot
Ralph Lowenstein ,   Gainesville, FL USA   (05.01.13)
It is depressing to see the word "seize" in a story written by Yediot Acharanot. This is a pejorative word, and implies that Israel grabbed something by force without provocation. US forces did not "seize" French or German territory in WWII. They "captured" it. Israel "captured" the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem in 1967 after its territory was blockaded and war was thrust upon it. Ralph Lowenstein USA
3. Define "Israel" Bibi
(05.01.13)
What is Israel?
4. Dancing around the golden calf
tiki ,   belgium   (05.01.13)
Before getting to excited, just remember, it's just a golden calf and golden calves don't exist.
5. goodby Greater Israel nonsense
Avramele   (05.01.13)
Bibi is about to cross the Rubicon toward a posture of sanity and pragmatism. The settlers are not rioting against a despicable terrorist murderer - they are rioting against the death of their messianic dream that has become a nightmare for 6.5 million other Israelis and the Palestinians of the West bank.
6. That´s right
albert snow ,   sweden   (05.01.13)
Netanyahu is 100% right. The problem is the muslims never will recognize Israel as a jewish state. Because for them jews are to be dominated by islam or killed, never equal.
7. this idiot and all.zionista
holy warrior ,   uk   (05.01.13)
Zionist administrations look for excusesnot to make peace. They are theroot of the problem as is zionism.
8. bibi just get on with it.
Eddy ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.01.13)
Abu Marzen already recognised Israel as a state. Surely you are confident enough to get on with making an agreement without all this non stop foot dragging. We all know the excuse behind your ploy, you must wake up to the fact that you can have a democratic state but a democratic jewish state is a contradiction in itself. Get on with it already.
9. The Arab league proposal will only help START talks
Jake ,   USA   (05.01.13)
It will never lead to a conclusion of talks, because the Arabs think they can flood Israel with 3.5 million hostiles, and that the Temple Mount is their property, The Arabs will never relinquish their unjust claims to Jerusalem, the eternal capital of Israel and the Jewish people. The Arabs will never EVER have a 3rd state in former Palestine. Jordan and Gaza is all they will ever have. I for one, think thats quite enough.
10. #5. "Greater Israel" is an idiotic leftist concept.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.01.13)
"Greater Israel". Yeah sounds like the British Empire. Except we are talking about the sole tiny Homeland of the Jewish people. A land that a healthy teenager could bicycle across in two to three hours. How does a person of presumably normal intelligence come to accept such clearly lunatic concepts as "Greater Israel"? No wonder letism is increasingly diagnosed as a mental disease.
11. Abe Lincoln..."A house divided against itself cannot stand."
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.01.13)
"I believe this government cannot endure, permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved -- I do not expect the house to fall -- but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing or all the other."
12. did any state recognise israel as jewish state ?
X   (05.01.13)
How can a democratic state recognise a jewish state ? The us will not do taht nor Canada or Micronesia.
13. "Land for peace" is historically unprecedented idiocy.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.01.13)
It is no accident that no other nation, in all of human history, has ever accepted "land for peace". It is idiocy. It insults human intelligence. After all, once you give away your land, it is gone forever. "Peace" can change any minute... Moreover, Judea and Samaria rightfully and legally belong to Israel. "Land for peace" is a sick and very dumb scam.
14. #7
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.01.13)
You should have taken the offer of having a state when it was offered to you (several times). Your own stupidity (and Islam) are the problem. You people can't even maintain peace among yourselves. Start taking responsibility for your own poor choices and actions instead of blaming Zionists for your self inflicted wounds.
15. #2
Airborne ,   Jerusalem   (05.01.13)
Read the article. It is from the AP.
16. To: No. 7
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.01.13)
Excuse me, but .... 1. The Arabs did not want peace in 1947. They wanted war. They went to war. They lost. 2. The Arabs did not want peace in 1956. They wanted war. They went to war. They lost. 3. The Arabs did not want peace in 1967. They wanted war. They went to war. They lost. Three more times, too, the Arabs opted against peace and in favor of war. They lost all three times -- yet again. Q.E.D., the problem is the Arabs. How dare you blame the State of Israel -- or Zionism -- for Arab belligerence, Arab violence and Arab terror? Are you ignorant, or just plain stupid?
17. yup, it' really simple
the mad zionist ,   san francisco   (05.01.13)
Netanyahu is right. it's very easy, all the Palestinians need to agree to is that once they get their first state, they must agree that theconflict is over, and that they will acknowledge Israel as a Jewish state. just as the Palestinians say they want their Arab state. you see if peace was achieved, the only major difference between Israel and Palestine would be that Israel has Muslims in their state, and the Palestinians have said numerous times that they are going to have a 100% Jewish free state. but of course their isn't going to be peace because the Arabs do not want ANY JEWS IN ISRAEL. They want all theland minus the Jews. I mean if Israel was running around yelling they want a 100% Muslim free state, the world would be going crazy, but when the Palestinians say it, it's like nothing was said at all. truly theirs more to the issue regarding the Israel Palestinian conflict. it's the progressives and Arab apologists that enable the conflict. it's the west never calling out the Palestinians for their lies and deceit. and while the Palestinians indoctrinate their children, and their enabled at it, peace is still a couple of generations away. unless a leader like Martin Luther king arises for the Palestinians. Israel has shown its willing to make peace, it's already done so with their only neighbors that had been willing to. Israel has uprooted its citizens striving for peace.what have the Palestinians done in the last 10 years to show they truly want peace? absolutely nada
18. to 14 and 16
holy warrior ,   uk   (05.01.13)
Dont try to distort facts, zionism is an ideology who's foundation is based on expansion of the state of israel even on stolen land so when you state that peace was offered, it was offered to the palestianians at a cost that even a dog wouldnt accept. Dont try to.influence the.readers on barefaced lies. But I guess thats what israel iwas founded on
19. Yank the other one, Booby
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (05.01.13)
The P.A. has recognized Israel. Netanyahu's arguments don't hold water. He'll either have to stop stalling and finding increasingly thin excuses, or we ARE going to end up in a single, binational state, which truly WILL be the end of Israel as the Jewish homeland.
20. Jewish state
albert snow ,   sweden   (05.01.13)
Israel is already a jewish state. The UN partiton plan from 1947 divided the palestinian mandate, after creating Transjordan, in a JEWISH and an ARAB state. So having Israel recognized as a jewish state of the arabs is to have them recognize what they already should have recognized 1947. That recognitian would in fact be the criteria for peace. But I don´t think the arabs will do it. The reason is that they haven´t given up their dream to make Israel an muslim arab state.
21. #19. We are going to end up with "Palestinian" departure.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.01.13)
There is only one reason large numbers of "Palestinian" poseurs reside in Judea and Samaria. Vast amounts of Israeli aid in the form of food, materials, money, electricity etc. Aid Israel's government lavishes on our genocidal "Palestinian" enemies. The moment Israel has a gusty government, that aid is gone. All "Palestinian" pretensions blow sky high. We are going to end up with massive "Palestinian" departure from our land.
22. Oh its over territory Baby/Bibi
Michael, R. ,   Denver, Colo.   (05.01.13)
Its definetely over territory, and Bibi your math skills are no better than Hareidi, ,,,,,,,Math Law,,,, "2 objects cannot OCCUPY the same space at the same time",,, RECOGNITION,,,, yes I recognize that many and most in Israel are Euro-American some descendants of converted Jews from the 9th century A.D. with no ancestral ties to Jacob/Israel, this land whatsoever mixed in with a few Mediteranean Mullato faith flip, flopping conversoes thru the ages. Its really about Peace, honesty wantig a neighbor to love as thyself and just peace, Israel. do you people know a big earthquake is headed your way, I would try to do the right thing and chalk up some good brownie(stop being so racist) points.
23. Soon coming Messiah
(05.01.13)
“Conflict not over territory” then Bibi can confess that Jesus Christ is Messiah and then Arabs can confess that too.
24. Two state solution is a recognition of Israel...
Mike Van Harris ,   Belgium   (05.01.13)
Recognizing Israel as a Jewish state is another story. You people think that you are smart, but guess what? Right of return for Palestinian refugees is a given that is non negotiable...
25. the conflict was never over territory per se
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (05.01.13)
the muslim arabs are among the greatest conquerers and colonisers in recorded human history. they conquered land masses on three continents in imperial wars that lasted a thousand years. they cannot accept that their imperial colonial days have been stopped. they cannot accept a sovereign jewish presence on land that jews had ruled two thousand years before islam appeared in the arabian desert.
26. #16 Sarah B
Mike Van Harris ,   Belgium   (05.01.13)
Educate yourself by reading "The fateful triangle" by Jewish author Noam Chomsky to know who the real terrorists are...
27. #7 holy warrior
Sarah B ,   U.S.A./ Israel   (05.01.13)
Just wait. If and when I become Prime Minister of Israel, I will give you the peace you deserve by turning your Arab lands into glowing cinder. Jews should never fear, for Sarah B is here...
28. If it weren't so sad, it would be funny.
Ed ,   USA   (05.01.13)
If it weren't so sad, it would be funny. This would be funny if having such people in charge in Israel didn't diminish the credibility of the entire Jewish people. Please ... get on with the only purpose of this coalition. Draft the Haredi, make them earn a living, teach them math. Then once that's done get on with dissolving this ridiculous government and try again.
29. #16 & #17 - You are right.
Pedro ,   Brazil   (05.01.13)
30. #18
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.01.13)
Distort facts? You keep wanting war, you keep losing them when you start them, and you have the nerve to cry about it and blame Israel. Islam is an ideology too whose foundation is based on the teachings of a pedophile. You may not like hearing the truth but #16 hit the nail on the head. I'm going to answer her question to you. You qualify on both counts.
Next talkbacks
Back to article