News
Report: Hawking pulls out of Jerusalem conference in protest
Ynet
Published: 08.05.13, 08:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
204 Talkbacks for this article
1. Hawking besmirching his legacy
Roberta Seid ,   Self   (05.08.13)
If this report is true, what a shame. Clear evidence that being good at physics on whatever level does not translate into morality and common sense. What a shame that Hawkings has chosen to besmirch is reputation this way. It won't be forgotten.
2. different approach
Alon ,   TA   (05.08.13)
This is the result of our not claiming our homeland and instead fighting a sectorial war of religious-secular and reform-orthodox. We have to change the principals and staff of our universities base our approach to the conflict and foreign policy based on our just claim to our homeland and prepare for whatever consequences.
3. All the Respect for this Guy
TUTU ,   East Jerusalem   (05.08.13)
4. Hawking boycotts Israel, Heisenberg supported the Nazis
Mlladen Andrijasevic ,   Be'er Sheva, Israel   (05.08.13)
With all their brilliance in physics, physicists can be ignoramuses and worse when it comes to ethics and politics. Niels Bohr never forgave Heisenberg for continuing to support Hitler’s efforts to build the atom bomb. I wonder if Stephen Hawking ever read Article 7 of the Hamas Charter, which reads: http://www.memri.org/report/en/0/0/0/0/0/0/1609.htm "The hour of judgment shall not come until the Muslims fight the Jews and kill them, so that the Jews hide behind trees and stones, and each tree and stone will say: 'Oh Muslim, oh servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him,' except for the Gharqad tree, for it is the tree of the Jews." Article 7 is taken from Hadith Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 177 and quotes the Prophet Muhammad: http://www.hadithcollection.com/sahihbukhari/85/3715-sahih-bukhari-volume-004-book-052-hadith-number-177.html Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him." Stephen Hawking apparently has no clue whom he is supporting or could not care less what they stand for. Which is it?
5. He may know a lot of things
Bob ,   Usa   (05.08.13)
He does not understand anything about middle east.
6. coward - falling to the antisemites
uli ,   jerusalem   (05.08.13)
7. Shameless manipulation of a mentally incapacitated person
Expat ,   Adelaide   (05.08.13)
The Palestinian lobby cynically manipulates a famous person who is clearly disfunctional in his senses and mental capacities, into serving as a mouthpiece for their Israel-bashing propaganda. Shame on them.
8. Let's try to keep this civil people
Vlad   (05.08.13)
I get it, we're all upset, but let's not degrade Israel's image further by making jabs at him (still one of the most brilliant minds alive, even if he is misguided here), or even worse, resorting to crude wheelchair jokes.
9. Now he's not getting a Nobel! Physics is a Jewish community
Ed ,   Canada   (05.08.13)
Too bad .. He actually had some good ideas. But this just makes him look dumb.
10. Hawking
gregg bowman ,   Parksville, Canada   (05.08.13)
Hawking may have a high IQ but he certainly isn't an intelligent and informed man. Warm regards, Gregg Bowman
11. shame on him
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (05.08.13)
a man like hawking should stay out of politics of which he knows nothing. he should continue to pursue science of which he knows a lot.
12. Professor Hawking, weak & intimidated
Cynthia ,   USA   (05.08.13)
He sacrificed his professional judgement to appease apologists for terror. The conference will go on without him and he'll be left out. The professor believes it's OK for Palestinians to fire 85 kassam rockets per day at Israeli civilians but when Israel fired back because the Palestinians refused to stop terror, that's out of proportion.
13. We have our own geniuses.No need for brabbling quadriplegic
Tevye ,   Chelm   (05.08.13)
14. too bad for Hawking
jochair ,   kfar Saba, Israel   (05.08.13)
The religeos hatred of the Arabs for Israel is the real disproportionate action in the ME. stephen will miss out on important discussions with Israeli scientists. Can Islamic scientists compensate for that?
15. Prof Hawkins and the inverse relationship theory
Tzvi ,   Israel   (05.08.13)
Good, now Hawkins will have time to visit the murdered Syrians instead. Or maybe even take a trip to Darfur or Tibet. Oh, I forgot. Neither Assad nor the Chinese to name just a few are Jewish. It seems, Prof Hawkins, that 'Maths' IQ and Emotional IQ may be inversely related.
16. Hawking is another brainwashed lefty willfully ignors facts
Marwan Khoury مروان ,   Montreal, QC   (05.08.13)
17. the loss of Prof. Hawkin
tiki ,   belgium   (05.08.13)
Not to be able to meet the international group of open, highly educated intellectuals from all over the world to share their different opinions about several subjects. This scientist decided to give in to the dictations of the circle of the closed minds. Sad for him.
18. IDIOTIC atheist !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.08.13)
19. I applaud this man
Ben David Shlomo   (05.08.13)
When a leading scientist has the good sense to boycott Israel because of its policies, the world should take note and applaud him. But to Peres and the majority of Israelis, they won't understand why he is taking this stance.
20. More proof that smart can be embarrassingly ignorant (end)
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.08.13)
21. Who cares
Ryan ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.08.13)
I see Hawking has taken up the anti- semitic cause like so many others. I have never heard of him standing up for the rights of women who are treated worse than animals in many Arab countries nor has Mr Hawking championed the rights of homo sexuals in these countries. Not to worry Steven, Israel hardly needs the likes of you.
22. In the end we all go mad I suppose!!!
Brett L ,   JHB South Africa   (05.08.13)
Especially brilliant minds unfortunately. How can any of these people and so called intellectuals compare an army accross the border from Israel which fire at its civilians and kidnap its soldiers not expect reprisals?? The fact that these cowards put their woman and children infront of their soldiers somehow never finds its way into the news and bizarrely, these philistine sympathisers never believe is possible because we in the "west" cannot fathom a human being could do such unspeakable things. Well, the arabs are not westernised in their thinking and thus happily shield themselves with woman and children. When these "intellectuals" start seeing that then the attitude to the philistines and islamists will change!!
23. Something is amiss?
PaulD ,   Jerusalem   (05.08.13)
Here you have a die-hard atheist, lending support to the most fascist, fundamentalist movement on earth, namely Islam. Who bases their entire justification for violence and hatred on historical lies and fear. Which only proves that academic achievement is not a sign of moral integrity or wisdom. Like the rest of the degenerate in-crowd representing the world today, Hawkins just made himself a new member.
24. Conference
Edouard ,   Montreal Canada   (05.08.13)
His name would not even of been mention fine would of be going to israel Good advertising Cheap strategies
25. Outter Space
Ron ,   oc us   (05.08.13)
He is concerned about the Israelis treat the Pals..Perhaps he can say a few words about how the Arabs treat their fellow Arabs? First Google recognizes Palestine and now Hawking. I am not impressed or moved.
26. Alon TA #2
Robert Haymond ,   Teqo'a, Israel   (05.08.13)
Thanks for that thought. You've capsulized our greatest need in one phrase: "claiming our homeland". We needn't apologize for ourselves any more nor even seek to explain ourselves. The world will come to respect us once again (not "love" us) when we flatly state that we are Jews and that Eretz Yisrael belongs, and has always belonged, to us.
27. Highly Educated Idiot if there ever was one!What a dis-
tom ,   tel aviv   (05.08.13)
appointment, really. Not that it surprises: intellect and wisdom are two apparently unconnected things. I hope his theories turn into fairy tales.javascript: save()
28. That SORRY WIMP knows ***NOTHING*** !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.08.13)
SHAME ON HIM !
29. BRITISH GARBAGE...GO TO HELL !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.08.13)
30. Overrated
D.F. ,   Berlin   (05.08.13)
It is a shame that Hawking falls in the trap of these antisemitic propaganda. However, he is not the big scientist people believe him to be. He is just one of many. His academic achievements are do not match his popularity. Today he is more of a science popstar. Whatever scientists like Hawking believe to achieve - the academic productivity of Israel is outstanding and cannot be boycotted.
Next talkbacks
Back to article