News
Israeli committee: Al-Dura alive at end of video
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 20.05.13, 00:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
1. You people are shameless...
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
The best witness to that terrible crime is the father who confirms that the killers were IDF murderers...
2. #1 .. dad lied ...
D   (05.19.13)
need more to disregard is testimony?
3. To: No. 1
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.19.13)
The camera does not lie. On the other hand, the father does. He tried to pass off old surgical scars (his life was saved by Jewish doctors) as having been current wounds. So, his word is worthless -- at least to anyone with half a brain. That would appear to exclude you. You just have a great deal of empty space. Try harder next time. Keep in mind that you are trying to defend people who have routinely sold their children to be suicide bombers. And who in their right mind (not that you would know anything about that) would deliberately bring their twelve year old child to an armed conflict? Oh, of course! Silly question. The ersatz "Palestinians," of course!
4. Why on earth do we have to bother....
shevet menashee ,   sderot   (05.19.13)
on Al dura incident when in Syria there are massacre going on LIVE? The world tries to find guilt on Israel on providing proof of what they actually did. Frence2, BBC etc. etc all craps. Jews have witness this type of blood libel for centuries and we are used to it and we have our own way of finding the Truth Out, they will now find another ways to libel. When the world wrongly accused us..they say OOOOOOOOOOOO... when we found the truth behind. they say Oh...!
5. Hey Wilson...
rob ,   Orangevale USA   (05.19.13)
You were much smarter as a volleyball in "castaway". You weren't there, you love the filthy Pals and don't even want the truth just so you can spew out your antisemitic filth. Go hug a Hamas murderer, you know the ones that steal into a child's bedroom while she's sleeping and cuts her throat. Yeah, you have a real high moral standard. STFU clown. shalom Israel, Rob
6. #1 No sir -YOU people are shameless in your bigoted hate
GZLives   (05.19.13)
7. #1 Ignorant Mark
Howard ,   Seattle USA   (05.19.13)
Shameless???How about the recently PHOTOSHOPPED picture of a baby supposedly killed by IDF fire that won a international photojournalism award or the picture of the dead Palestinian child in his father arms at the Gaza hospital who was supposedly killed by IDF fire but was ACTUALLY killed by a HAMAS rocket that fell short.The list goes on and on but you have your preconcieved bias and hatred of Isreal which blinds you to the truth.
8. No. 1....did you read the article?
GR ,   London   (05.19.13)
There is 'no ballistic possibility' that the bullets came from the IDF position. This young boy was killed by Palestinian fire. It is horrible and tragic. Charles Enderlin, however, had blood on his hands and is truly disgusting.
9. Yet Israel's govt. showers these creaps with support!
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.19.13)
"Palestinians" circle the globe spreading modern blood libels against Jews. They do all they can to prepare to mass murder us all, which is their dearest wish. Yet the lunatic Israeli government keeps showering these creaps with support. Israel's government keeps the food, money, materials and electricity flowing to our would be mass murderers. Disgusting!
10. If I were
daniela   (05.19.13)
the Israeli government I would sue Channel 2 of France for falsehood, and not let them enter Israel to cover any story. I think also a PR campaign should widely publicize that fact in order to show the truth.
11. The Dreyfus Affair
Al ,   canada   (05.19.13)
Part Deux
12. Sounds like Holocaust denial
Murray   (05.19.13)
The same selection bias and false logic used by Holocaust deniers can be seen in the Steinitz-Ya'alon committee report. Zionists sinking lower and lower.
13. after all the damage has been done...
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (05.19.13)
so you have finally seen fit to announce that the whole thing is a lie. Hip hip horray for gornisht! The damage was done many years ago and only now the experts are saying it is a lie? All of the people who moved to the side of condemning Israel are still on that side. So what now is accomplished? The Arabs are experts in lying; the Israelis take for ever to figure out the truth. Bottom line: the liars seem to have won out long long ago.
14. #1 you are brainwashed
Madeleine ,   Israel   (05.19.13)
Of course, Palestinians never lie. Dead bodies don't fall off stretchers and then get up and get back on the stretcher. palis ahve been proven over and over and over again to lie to whatever purpose they see fit, to stage "events" for the camera and to start provocations only when they see a cameraman close by. "You people" - i.e. americans - are pathetic in your naivete,
15. al-Dura picture
Green Baron ,   Bethesda, MD USA   (05.19.13)
When I was a kid, we used to have a saying: "Pictures don't lie, but liars can take pictures."
16. You people are still shameless...
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
Your talk backs reflect how arrogant and stupid you people are. The father was there and he would never ever protect the killers of his son if they were Palestinians just to implicate Jews. No father would ever do that. Sarah B has always been stupid, but in her post here she goes beyond stupidity to being dumb too! She says in her post, (referring to the father): " He tried to pass off old surgical scars (his life was saved by Jewish doctors) as having been current wounds." If Jewish doctors saved his life, it means that his life was in danger due to serious injuries. In that case, why the hell would he need to pass old scars as being current wounds? I repeat: You people are shameless...
17. Pallywood aims achieved
Get Real ,   UK   (05.19.13)
When the truth comes out as to who really was responsible the image has already been created and the world's media very rarely follows up and publishes that truth as it is less newsworthy than the original story. Pallywood has accomplished its aims of showing Israel as responsible for the sad deaths of children. Yet very little emotional mention in the media of the thousands of chilldren who have been killed or wounded in Syria.
18. #12 Murray
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
Zionist are low and have always been so. They are so low that they can't sink any lower...
19. Messing up a good story!
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (05.19.13)
Damn us! We Jews insist on messing up a good story, by throwing out a few facts. We are interfering with the Pals' creative powers.
20. There is no limit to how low Israel goes!
Avi ,   NYC, US   (05.19.13)
He is alive! The whole story is nothing but a "blood libel"! Actually, he is alive and well. Having fun in Disney World...with the holocaust victims. There are rumors that they didn't die as well.
21. #3 Sarah B
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
What kind of attorney are you? You say in your post, referring to Palestinians: "Keep in mind that you are trying to defend people who have routinely sold their children to be suicide bombers." This is a very serious charge that you are attributing to Palestinians. There are many Palestinian Americans who would love to have an idiot like you prove it in a court of law. You are such an idiot. You are full of hate. I do not blame Palestinians for what ever they do. I blame your arrogance and stupidity for the Middle East problems.
22. Find the boy if he is still alive
bob ,   potomac md   (05.19.13)
what happened to the boy if he did not die there?
23. Israel... the HATE society...
Avi ,   NYC, US   (05.19.13)
We Jews are extremely sophisticated: Hating the whole world...with one finger up our nostril.
24. 1 Mark
alsky ,   toronto   (05.19.13)
and your a naive idiot ! Everyone knew long ago...another Pallywood movie
25. Objective Truth - G-d's Spreadsheet
Adam Neira ,   Paris, France   (05.19.13)
"There is only one way to battle lies – by telling the truth,” PM Netanyahu said. Imagine G-d has a spreadsheet. A very big one ! On it is recorded all the merit and demerit points of the dead and the living. i.e. All the good and bad actions that everyone has done. Now G-d is quite clever. He knows how to work out the relevant weightings of all the actions. It would be very interesting for all to see what the objective truth is. i.e. Who did what, when, how, to whom and why ?
26. @14 Larry
Al Quds ,   Al Quds   (05.19.13)
Bibi is the king of truth lol wake up!
27. Hurray Israel...
Al Quds ,   Al Quds   (05.19.13)
You are becoming such a funny state lol
28. Really Wilson Mark?
David ,   Florida   (05.19.13)
This is not my statment not a new thing but since always we know that "“Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.” GM
29. ISRAELI HASBARA (PR) IS A JOKE!
FO ,   Belgium   (05.19.13)
AS said British journalist, Melanie Phillips, interviewed at the Israeli TV: your hasbara is a joke! It had to take more than TWELVE years to publish an official report concluding that the Al-Dura affair is a hoax? In the video aired world -wide not one, NOT ONE bullet hitting the wall can be seen, because there was no shooting at all. Not from the Israeli side, neither from the Palestinian, so there was no injury, no death! This video can't even be called "staged", being of such poor and ridiculous quality. But the IDF spokesman was prompt to admit eventual responsibility for the boy's "death". Even more disturbing is the fact (I suppose unique in journalistic history) that the correspondent of France 2, the Israeli Charles Enderlin, threatened to bring to court whoever would declare his video being a hoax. What he indeed did together with France 2 against Karsenty. The harm this video-spot did to Israel worldwide is beyond repair. This affair should be relegated to the Israeli justice; some till today unknown (to us) forces have been active in this affair.
30. #28 David
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
Read post number 29 fool...
Next talkbacks
Back to article