News
Israeli committee: Al-Dura alive at end of video
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 20.05.13, 00:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
31. #24 alsky
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A   (05.19.13)
Read post number 29 fool...
32. #16 Really? You obviously don't know arabs!
A ,   Belgium   (05.19.13)
33. Frustrated Lunatic Mark Wilson
Leon ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.19.13)
By making statements like "you people" and "zionists are low" this lunatic Mark Wilson shows what he is about. I am glad that Wilson is so frustrated by the report's conclusions. Means the investigation was done right.
34. Mark Wilson # 18 etc.
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.19.13)
And you are so dumb you can't get any dumber. If these people were legitimate they wouldn't need to keep making lies but when you are a fake people you have to lie. Arafat was an Egyptian and most of these Fake-astinians didn't show up or complain until the Jews improved the land. They certainly didn't complain when much of the land was controlled by Egypt and Jordan. No, they only complain because like you they are full of hate for Jews and that is the ONLY reason they complain. If they didn't have the Jews to hate they would be killing each other (more than they already do now) because it's their nature and because of their religion.
35. #24
Rachel   (05.19.13)
He's not naive. He's evil, just like all antisemites. If he was naive,there would be an excuse for him,but there can be no excuse for someone when the PROOF is right in front of their eyes. Like the other antisemites he will say anything to try and make Israel look bad. He said in his one post he doesn't "blame" the Palestinians for anything they do. I guess that means he doesn't "blame" them for mass murdering Israeli children and infants like they have in the past. Jewhaters are such evil hypocrites.
36. #1 Well spoken, Mark Wilson
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (05.20.13)
"Shameless" is the right word, Mark. Jamal al-Dura's wounds were operated on by a surgical team in a hospital in Amman. The Israeli surgeon, who once operated on an orthopaedic injury in Jamal al-Dura, was in no position to claim that his injuries were faked. He never even examin al-Dura! To claim that there were no bullits hitting is ludicrous, when one looks at the footage. After the hail of bullits that throws up a dust cloud, you can clearly see the bloodstains in the boy's abdominal area. The cameraman was not correct when he shouted that the boy had already died. He was still moving. People who are exsanguinating can do that until they have died. Jamal al-Dura has offered to let DNA samples being taken from the boy in his grave. But nothing rational will shut the conspiracy loonies up. The claim that the death of Mohammed al-Dura was a fake is not only stupid, but dangerous as well. It is the same kind of thing as Holocaust denial! And now
37. To: No. 21
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.20.13)
Are you serious? The Saudis held telethons to raise money, and Saddam Hussein paid each family a bounty of ten thousand dollars for every child offered up for martyrdom. Sadly, there were far too many takers. This is old news. If you don't know that this is precisely what the ersatz "Palestinians" do, then you must have been living under a rock. As to your silly comment about blaming me for the problems in the Middle East -- am I responsible for the persecution of Coptic Christians in Egypt? Am I responsible for ongoing Shia/Alawi/Sunni violence in Syria? Am I responsible for the persecution of Zoroastrians and Bahai'i in Iran? Am I responsible for the murder of the United States ambassador to Libya in Benghazi? You are a moron.
38. #20,23: What is a "self-hating" Jew?
shrinkDave ,   Miami United States   (05.20.13)
I never really bought into the idea of a self-hating Jew; it always sounded like dumb rhetoric to me. So thank you Avi, for clearing it all up for me.
39. 16 dummy,,
(05.20.13)
Number 16 Read the article again,,,,,, Father injuries were caused by Hamas, not Israel.
40. Sara Blowhard, #3...
Makina ,   New York, USA   (05.20.13)
So. you think it's the father lying? So what about the Jewish soldiers CAUSING the firefight in the first place? This you can't see, from your frum-blinded eyes? And you talk about "bringing children" into a dangerous area. yet you say nothing about brain-dead "settlers" dragging their children to LIVE in a war zone, on stolen land that they know the owners have a complete right to fight to get it back? What kind of meshuggah world do you inhabit, Sara Blowahard? Oh yes, you are in Miami. Apparently the sun has baked what little brains you have left. Feh....!!!
41. If he is alive
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (05.19.13)
Then where is he? The only way to counter this video is to show him in front of the television cameras
42. it doesnt matter
zionist forever   (05.19.13)
He could be the most famous person in the world and richest but the Israel bashers and muslims would still say Israeli soldiers murdered him so who cares about him.
43. Obsessive Israel-bashers like Mark Wilson prove that hatred
Marwan Khoury مروان ,   Montreal, QC   (05.20.13)
of Israel is a pathology. Apparently, the idiot cannot even read where it says that the father's scars were inflicted by Hamas and that he was saved by Israeli doctors. The men willfully lied and misrepresented his scars to get on the good side with Hamas terrorists and because he can "sell" his son's victim status to brainwashed anti-Israel drones and the Arab media. Once again, facts speak for themselves.
44. 22
Rachel   (05.19.13)
They will never find him. He could be anywhere,or hiding out. He doesn't have to come out in public and announce himself to the world. What Israel needs to do is to try and exhume the grave. If there is a body there,they need to get his DNA,and find out that is how they can prove to the world their side of the story. If the family,is telling the truth,and have nothing to hide they should not fear this.
45. #27 Al Crum - Laugth this away
BEN JABO (MACHALpo) ,   iISRAEL   (05.20.13)
NO BULLET HOLES OR POCK MARKS WHERE THEY WERE ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN I guess that the photographer didn't have any paint & brush in his kit to paint them in
46. #29 RD - As hard as i tried
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.20.13)
I wasn't able to find bullet marks on the walls in back of them
47. Hot Zone
Zechariah   (05.20.13)
The Holy Land is a catastrophic Danger Zone and everyone ought be released to other lands so that it may be Preserved as a Garden of Eden till Humankind evolves Messianically .
48. All this discussion is irrelevant and useless, the version..
Flavio ,   Sao Paulo, Brazil   (05.20.13)
...matters more than the truth!
49.  # 10 Mark Al Dura Alive at the end of Vedeo
AL ,   US   (05.20.13)
Mark - you are being too kind. These people are part of this murderous regime. They have been cheering Israel offensive forces while killing, turturing, displacing and distroying the life generations of Palestinian. Thisis just a cowardly PR campain to ease the conceous of donner counries who paid Israel in access of it took to rebuild Europe after the war, over 130 billion from the US alone..
50. #1 - how could the father be a witness....
William ,   Israel   (05.20.13)
when he was in the middle of a fire fight between two sides, he was crunched down behind a barrier, and hid his head most of the time? If that is admissible evidence against one side in the death of someone, then any passer-by is when witnessing such an event, right? You're shameless to accept the father's testimony as full evidence to blame of one side when infact he saw nothing. Even worse, he later lied about the bullet in his arm which he said came from the IDF that day but turned out to be from years before. Shame on you for joining a blood libel solely on the basis of your own hate agenda.
51. #12 - In Holocaust denial, one ignores Nazi records
William ,   Israel   (05.20.13)
in denying the Al-Dura murder, one ACCEPTS the ballistics tests and forensic evidence. Are you stating that one must ignore very glaring evidence, one that has been uncovered by several external parties to date, because of the party they wish to lay guilt on? Actually, sir, your acceptance of the IDF as guilty is more analogous to Holocaust Denial because you are led by your agenda, not by facts at hand.
52. i think
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (05.20.13)
it would be better to finally give this case a rest. It's tasteless to say the least....
53. Mark Wilson
Miriam ,   Miami, USA   (05.20.13)
You are so naive, wake up. Father would lie no matter what. He is afraid of Hamas. They will kill him and the rest of his family if he did not lie. You just don't get it. the Arabs are afraid of their own people. They will do anything and say anything, to protect themselves and their families. Look at what is happening in Syria, they are killing each other 80,000 now killed and the world is not saying a thing. Dura needs to do what he needs to do to protect himself and the rest of his family. Israelis know that, what don't you learn that.
54. #16 - then you don't know Pallywood
William ,   Israel   (05.20.13)
Ballistics tests show that the IDF could not have hit him and his boy. They were at a 30-degree angle from their position, diagnally across the intersection, and Al-Dura was behind a concrete barrier and drum which blocked them completely. However, the "Palestinians" were located at the 3 other corners of the intersection, firing on the IDF position. The bullet holes in the wall resemble shots taken perpendicular to the wall - that is, directly across the street from Al-Dura, and were by a sniper not rapid fire gun in a fire fight. There was no protection on that side of the Al-Dura. Guess who's position that was.... It was the "Palestinian" terrorists....not the IDF. By the way, the scars Al-Dura's father passed off as recent were infact from an incident years prior. Why would he do that? Why would Pallys pass off people deceased from natural causes as "killed by IDF"? Why would the Pallys hold fake funerals for foreign media? Why would they claim massacres in the hundreds when there was less than 30? Why would they use ambulances and hospitals to launch attacks? Why would Gazans claim kids killed by qassams that fall short were actually "killed by IDF"? Why? They will tell you why.....it's all for the "Palestinian cause".
55. hahaha really ?? too late .
Salma ,   State of Palestine   (05.20.13)
"Israel's reputation" damaged and could not be repaired. It is well known that "Israeli" gunfire killed the boy, no one will bye your hasbara. boker tov Falsteen <3
56. Thank you Philippe Karsenty.
PaulfromParis ,   Paris, France   (05.20.13)
For many years, P. Karsenty has been demonstrating this report is a hoax. Israel acts too late... And France television and most of French journalists know it and have better to support one of them by corporatism.
57. Shame on French 2 Television and French Journalists
PaulfromParis ,   Paris, France   (05.20.13)
Let's think of Daniel Pearl, Yosef Avrahami et Vadim Norzhich. Because of this hoax...
58. AND NOW ???
FO ,   Belgium   (05.20.13)
Charles Enderlin, responsible for broadcasting world-wide the Al-Dura video, threatened to bring to court anybody who would pretend his video is a fake. If Enderlin wants to be consistent with himself, he should bring the Israeli government to court. Or isn't it rather the Israeli government that should put Enderlin on trial for having brought about so many deaths,and having ruined Israel's image world-wide?
59. the fact is he was killed by IDF
Megan ,   NYC,NY   (05.20.13)
twisting the truth but why
60. 569 Megan
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (05.20.13)
If you claim that it's a fact, then explain why there are no bullet pockmarks in the background, nor even a smidgeon of blood splatter?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article