Culture  Art&Culture
Leon Wieseltier fears for Israel's future
Associated Press
Published: 12.06.13, 07:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Wow,you can blame these "intellectuals" for many things, but
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.12.13)
but not for being un-predictable! But of course he "fears", he wouldn't be a fellow traveler with the manically suicidal Left.Then he'd have to fear for his reputation and disownment by the educated idiots. I have something that could occupy his spare time and cause great concern: worrying about future self destruction of our Sun.Then, by default, our Zionist Enterprise will go "puff".....
2. who cares about the opinion of this old idiot ?
(06.12.13)
3. palestinian state = terrorist islamist state
(06.12.13)
4. The Left can fear for Israel's future...
frauss ,   Jerusalem   (06.12.13)
The Right will take care of it.
5. #1 Tom great post I almost pissed in my pants
Al   (06.12.13)
good thing I didn't...hilarious To hear these self anointed geniuses Israel should have been history the day she was born. Never mind...he is nothing but a passing fart in the wind.
6. False dilemma, 3rd option: autonomous protectorates
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   netzarim.co.il   (06.12.13)
I've been telling you for decades. It's inevitable: a concurrent village network (of autonomous protectorates).
7. Laugh Out Loud!
Johannes ,   Norway   (06.12.13)
8. You want to make G-d laugh, than predict the future!
tiki ,   belgium   (06.12.13)
But for righteous leftist intellectuals there of course is no G-d, so they take it upon themselves to predict what will be the future.....without any doubt of course!
9. territories
Alexander D. ,   Mosocw, Russia   (06.12.13)
"...if it doesn't withdraw from the Palestinian territories..." -- *What* territories he's talking about??
10. another intellectual elite who is empty headed, wrong and on
ralph   (06.12.13)
only able to spew leftist tripe. he should be confronted as empty headed not awarded. i have no respect for his kind nor for papers which wrongly praise useful idiots like him.
11. Another intellectual
Get Real ,   UK   (06.12.13)
The wrong solution to the Palestine-Israel conflict will also ensure that there will not be a Jewish state for very long. Yet another one with advice on this matter: He should trust that Israel knows best on how to secure its own future, but at least he also recognises the shortcomings of the Palestinians.
12. The Man Is Spelling It Out In Black And White
World Citizen ,   the world   (06.12.13)
Either a Palestinian state comprised of the whole West Bank and East Jerusalem or one secular state with rights for all. Keep your Jewish identity in a smaller state or lose it trying to hold on to the Occupied Territories. It's as simple as that.
13. #6 Fourth option - United States of Jordan
JustMe ,   Israel   (06.12.13)
Jordan takes over responsiblity and the Palestinian entity becomes a federated state within the Jordanian country. It would be called the United (Two) States of Jordan.
14. First of all....
dr harry ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.12.13)
with the million bucks, take a haircut. Yes, what you should be worried about is the State of Israel's future. I agree. Everyday another peg in the coffin. The Jewish people on the other hand will survive and we don't need your unasked input. This so called conflict was self afflicted by the State. "There may not be a Jewish STATE for very long", but the Nation of Israel will survive as it has done for 3325 years. What a waste of a million $$$$$.
15. Peace
mike ,   usa   (06.12.13)
Wieseltier is of course not an idiot as some of these misguided commenters claim. Nor is he some extreme left-winger. His mistake is equating the need for peace, which is real, with the ability to make peace, which right now is lacking. As long as violent extremists control the Palestinian agenda, as well as at least part of its territory, talking about major territorial concessions by Israel is ridiculous.
16. Jihadi Califate and Fatah Ba'ath No vote
Zechariah   (06.12.13)
There will be no vote for Jihadis and Fatah Ba'ath .There is already a Palestinian State under Israeli Secutity Surveillance and This won't change any time soon.
17. a million dollars for this arrogant
pinchas ,   boston   (06.13.13)
blowhard and poseur-- what a waste of money!
18. Professional Worrying
Bill ,   New York, USA   (06.13.13)
Leon Wieseltier has been doing this for years, worrying because that seems "deep". Then engaging in firm finger-wagging at those who do not display the requisite level of "seriousness". The problem with this is that serious people are people who have actual responsibility to "do stuff". Israelis who do stuff have to figure out what will work and what will not. And they usually stop doing things that do not work. Simply because, no matter what the worries are, that is what should be done.
19. #15:Sorry, anyone that has a picture like that taken is one!
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.13.13)
I might add: a "pompous airbag" as well...
20. Wieseltier
h.s.cohen ,   n.y.c. usa   (06.13.13)
Leave "The New Republic" it's turned into a New York Times magazine clone.By the way get a haircut.
21. # 4 frauss, jerusalem with the help of G-d.
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.13.13)
He's always right.....
22. # 8 Tiki Man plans G-d laughs
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.13.13)
It's a good thing G-d loves Israel and is Jewish!!!!
23. "pal terrortories'
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.13.13)
are located near 'atlantis' between there and Sodom and Gomorra.
24. # 13 ONLY Legal option
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.13.13)
unless the pals want to locate in Gaza, the off target rocket field and official war zone of Hamas.
25. # 1 tom interesting isn't it
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.13.13)
that so many non residents of Israel are so 'expert' on her future? Why, if I'd known it was that easy, I'd have fashioned myself a 'professional worrier and expert on the subject myself.. or so could any of us here.. What a loon he is although, he's making a living off this shit.
26. TNR.com - the greatest magazin on earth.
TNR Reader   (06.13.13)
Many articles of Wieseltier explained the ineptness of the American, Israeli, Palestinian, Arab and Muslim Leaders. It is a general problem. Change it and we will be able to compromise.
27. Read the PEACE-Solution-for-Middle-East-by-
Ailiyahu ,   USA   (06.13.13)
Read the " PEACE-Solution-for-Middle-East-by-Ailiyahu-Hanavi " on Facebook and you will see the future of Israel. If you need the link, just email me.
Back to article