News
Bill Clinton: No alternative to Palestinian state
Neri Brenner
Published: 17.06.13, 21:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. Oh yeah? Yaaaaaaawwwwwwwn.....
(06.17.13)
2. HAPPY BIRTHDAY SHIMON...
Esther ,   Selkirk Canada   (06.17.13)
3. Who and How much?
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.17.13)
"Clinton,...told the..directors he would donate the money from the lecture..." So who is paying him and how much?!?
4. Wish you had regional peace agreements for your birthday.
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.17.13)
Happy birthday v'ad mea v'esrim, Mr. President. The occasion would be so much more happier and more poignant if there was peace with Israeli neighbors to toast. There is absolutely nothing more meaningful to Israeli survival than peace. Without peace everything is hypothetical, Mr. President.
5. Serial 2-state demands = Genocide.
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (06.17.13)
6. The Jewish people are a GROWING MAJORITY from river to sea!
Jake ,   USA   (06.17.13)
Arab birthrates are nearly identical to Jewish birthrates, and in the West Bank it is much lower than Jewish birthrates. Jews also have a thing called Aliyah. Clinton is a liar who should never be welcomed in Israel. He is perpetuating the BIG LIE that Israel can be lost through demographics. If that were true, Abbas wouldn't be running to the UN to create his state, he would be sitting on his ass waiting for the Arabs to outbreed the Jews. Pay no attention to BJ Clinton, the Jewish people are a GROWING MAJORITY in the land of Israel.
7. #4, you are wishing for peace agreements, not peace
Jake ,   USA   (06.17.13)
8. guess Clinton didn't get paid.
usa   (06.17.13)
9. 2 of a kind!
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (06.17.13)
One who charges 500K to come to a "friend's" birthday and the other who is not ashamed in a moment of high poverty to pay for people to come and toast him! Shame on them both!!!
10. #6
Jeff ,   USA   (06.17.13)
Then just get it over with already... if the West Bank supposedly belongs to Israel and you're not worried about demographic issues, then just annex it and give all the residents citizenship like the democracy that Israel (supposedly) is... put up or shut up.
11. A Palestinian Arab state exists, on 77% of Palestine: It is
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.17.13)
called Jordan, situated on 77% of Palestine.
12. Billy Boy
gregg bowman ,   Parksville, Canada   (06.17.13)
Bill, please do us all a big favor and just be quiet and go away.....thank you, warm regards, Gregg Bowman
13. Peres & Clinton are the ones who let the murderous thugs in
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (06.17.13)
14. Former President Clinton said at 90th birthday
What does he know?   (06.17.13)
of President Peres "..the reality swirling around Israel is reflective of the challenges facing the world. . while the country exists in relative peace, people should try to remain logical, and be prepared for the worst. " This chap is a well-informed source...
15. # 4 Israel HAS Peace
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (06.17.13)
the Muslims are a riot!!! welcome to Syria, 'it's a blast.' Thankfully, the muslims are thinning their own herd.
16. All those who say Israel MUST make a deal are idiots
Sam ,   Canada   (06.17.13)
Israel can't make a deal with the Palestinians if Palestinian demands on refugees (in particular), Jerusalem,borders and security are totally unacceptable to Israel. So, all those people who think it's up to Israel to make a deal lack understanding of the situation. To begin with, Palestinians reject living next to a Jewish majority Israel and that makes any deal impossible.
17. Jordan is the magical word ..........
trump   (06.17.13)
18. alternatives always exist
C   (06.17.13)
you just need a strategic thinker. the un, the british, the french, and successive american administrations have messed up the region, tried to impose their will on israel, and have been slaves to the oil reach muslims. the arabs, the west and all those with interests in the region would gladly sacrifice the jewish state in the false belief that they would have peace.
19. Status quo infinitely better than 2 State Final Solution.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.18.13)
Israel has far better alternatives than the monstrous, suicidal Two State Final Solution. Even the status quo is infinitely better than a "solution" which would turn Israel into a 9 mile wide concentration camp. The real solution is to end all Israeli support for Fictional Palestine and assist "Palestinian" poseurs to do one thing only; leave our land forever.
20. Peres: Prince of the Erev Rav?
Perachel ,   Tiberias   (06.18.13)
There is a (hopefully) lunatic fringe who claim that Shimon Peres, who was the force behind Oslo and all of its disastrous sequellae, is actually the Prince of the Mixed Multitude,that Peres pronounces the Ineffable Tetragrammaton (as the antinomian Shabbateans & Frankists used to do), that he was raised and trained in a Jesuit school in Poland, that he is in cahoots with the Vatican to divvy up Jerusalem, that he is a key operative of the European Faction of the New World Order, that his name 'Peres' means 'vulture' in Hebrew, that its gematria (numerical value) is 340 - the same as that of Armalgus - a variant of "Armilus" - the Anti-Messiah and leader of the Mixed Multitude of Jewish Apocalyptic tradition, that the name "Peres" is found in the computer Torah codes in particularly ominous verses, that he is implicated in the Rabin assassination conspiracy etc etc! Way back in 1957 Israeli Prime Minister Moshe Sharett's did write: "I have stated that I totally and utterly reject Shimon Peres, and consider his rise to prominence a malignant, immoral disgrace. I will rend my clothes in mourning for the State if I see him become a minister in the Israeli government!"
21. Celebrate Peres birthday with huge class action Oslo lawsuit
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.18.13)
Urgent appeal to all patriotic lawyers in Israel. Well over 1,000 Israelis have been murdered and more than 14,000 maimed as a direct result of the criminal negligence of Peres and Labor during the Oslo Disaster. Now is the time to bring Peres and Labor to justice. Now is the time to bring some relief to Oslo victims and their families. I urge all patriotic Israeli lawyers to PLEASE assist and empower Oslo victims to launch a huge class action lawsuit against Peres and Labor. We must not hear the cries of Oslo victims and make the guilty pay!
22. #10, why should Israel do the PA such favors?
Jake ,   USA   (06.18.13)
If Israel annexed there would be a 2:1 Jewish majority, which is by no means a death threat to Israel. But why should Israel voluntarily diminish its Jewish majority? If the PA dismantles itself, then Israel will annex the West Bank. But they are far too interested in holding onto power, even if its within the confines of Area A. I sure hope they call Israel's bluff and dismantle, it would be a great day in Jewish history.
23. Who's paying for this Farse?
Bill Stein ,   USA   (06.18.13)
I want to know who is paying for this big party for Peres who has done more harm to Israel than any other man.
24. Didn't Clinton support the Oslo autonomy accord
History   (06.18.13)
Oslo did not give the Palestinians a state but the right to their own autonomy. Does Clinton not remember what was signed in the US back then? So there are other options.
25. Eretz Yisrael HaShlaima Baby...Take that Billy Boy
Paul Saul   (06.18.13)
26. Two godless FOOLS!!!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (06.18.13)
27. Coming from a man......
Dan M ,   USA   (06.18.13)
who, along with his wife, collects millions of dollars from Arab leaders. But America's Jews, who are liberals first and Jews second will vote for Hillary when she runs in 2016.
28. Who paid for Billy's speech?
Joe Mevorah ,   Lincoln, USA   (06.18.13)
What did Billy do, take a discount in usual 500k fee because Peres is such a fine individual? Go home Clinton, go charge some other group your astronomical fees, and stop bothering Israel.
29. Yes there is billy boy
Maurice ,   Los Angeles, USA   (06.18.13)
The Arabs need to go home and that is East. The whole land of Israel belongs to the Jews and no wife cheater like you can change that.
30. This putz boasted peace with Assad would take "20 minutes"
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (06.18.13)
3 years ago, the endlessly dishonest Clinton claimed that he could do a peace deal with Assad's Syria that would guarantee Israel's security "in 20 minutes". Had it been up to Clinton, Assad and his butchers would today be raining nerve gas onto Israel's Galillee towns from the Golan - while Obama layed out more "red lines" and demanded more "proof". There is a reason Clinton is viewed with scorn in the US, where he is ridiculed as "Slick Willie". The only future Clinton cares about is between Monica's legs. That and his $20 million Saudi consulting contracts.
Next talkbacks
Back to article