News
Frenchman convicted of defamation in Mideast case
Associated Press
Published: 26.06.13, 17:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. IN FRANCE IT IS A CRIME TO BE ANTI-ARAB BUT OK TO BE ANTIJEW
stude ham   (06.26.13)
the EU has returned to its savage past.
2. this story confusing, not explaining..
bernard ross   (06.26.13)
...how and why the verdict was determined. I saw the full video and it was an obvious fake. this is shoddy journalism reporting on fraudulent journalism
3. french determine facts based on desired outcome
(06.26.13)
hezbullah is not a terrorist org because they may kill french peacekeeping troops if they are designated as such. this verdict makes no sense and the story also. I saw the vidio and it is an obvius fabrication French are lying anti semites. May they roast in their own self created hell
4. Hezbollah killed many French soldiers
Abu Yousuf El- Dugri   (06.26.13)
In Beirut and they have French blood on their dirty hands.France forgot it and they got away with murder and now this fabrication what a shame on France and their system. Kalbs.
5. Mr.Karsenty's fine is a legal error as the french state
Moshe ,   Usa   (06.26.13)
media claimed the killing was done by the IDF when it was likely done "by Palestinian fire" & therefore, the state media who sued Mr. Karsenty of "defamation for accusing" the media of "staging a video" was in error, as it was not proven that the IDF did it [but in fact it was proven that it was likely done by the pals themselves. The state media could have been sued by the IDF & the IDF could have won. Murder is a fun game for pals.
6. Something is rotten with AP!
AVouskila ,   South America   (06.26.13)
This verdict will give Charles Enderlin the 'magnanimous' French reporter, the last hoorah to justify his "gross-unbellievable pension". The thruth is, for quite some years by now, he has not been asked to fill any mediocre or great tasks, as deserving his seniority his reknown...he was looked upon by FTV a 'plague' or something stinky and maladive like that. However, the big rhinoceros missing from the eyes , is the fact that Monsieur Philipe Karsenty is not only pro-Israeli he happens to be a Proud Jew!! AP, as his usual biases (I have many of their reports involving the Jewish State of Israel , whether iwritten n Spanish, French or English ) has not even found a enough good reason to mention that extraordinary fact ,par contre, AP goes out of their way to identify the Muslim in their reporting if she/he been 'wronged' by France or Europe. Mr. Karsenty will have his rightful day in Public Court.
7. France put 190K Jews on the train to Auschwitz.
JMK ,   NYC   (06.26.13)
8. This is an injustice.
Reuven   (06.26.13)
Karsenty is the new Dreyfus.
9. Child killers. You should be ashamed of yourselves...
(06.26.13)
10. Dreyfuss
Sane   (06.26.13)
Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Dreyfuss Ahh the wonders of the French legal system vis-a-vis Jews.
11. #9
Israel Winicki ,   Beer Sheba-Israel   (06.26.13)
Are you talking about the Pals? I ask because you said "child killers". But don´t ask from them that they be ashamed, they don´t know the meaning of shame
12. #2 I think
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (06.26.13)
I am not sure, but I think the issue is as follows. Karsenty proved without a doubt that the A Dura film was faked, his mistake was hinting that Enderlin knew it was faked and presented it as truth. Enderlin said that since he was in Ramallah at the time, he could not have been in on the forgery. In other words, Enderlin admits that he received prizes and fame for putting his name on a story that he was too stupid to realize was false, and that he was defamed for being called evil instead of stupid.
13. Karsenty/Enderlin
basri ,   paris   (06.26.13)
But Enderlin also does not know the meaning of shame.
14. Better still
Larry, M. ,   Pittsburg, Penn.   (06.26.13)
Why don't you fake Jews(no pun) just go back to Europe,,,, non of this never would have happened if hitler hadn't been born. You so-called Jews would have been wealthy, rich, comfortable in Europe your real homeland with your "isms", Communism, Socialism, Marxism, Leninism, and yes Judaism.
15. Israelis have tried this numerous times only
James USA   (06.27.13)
to be shown to be liars. They must live in sick reality where the chosen can do no wrong and goyim will believe anything said by a Jew.
16. #14, 15
R ,   Israel   (06.27.13)
The antisemites have crawled out from under their rock and spend their time on an Israeli news site. Thanks for the laugh!
17. @7 while US and Brits watched
Miron ,   USA   (06.27.13)
and now they are printing these stories... explaining why it was a good work to do in their most favorite of all languages.
Back to article