Opinion
Fighting for peace
Ariela Ringel-Hoffman
Published: 01.07.13, 19:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over
Bmos ,   chashmonaim, Israel   (07.02.13)
and over and expecting a different result. We've done this before with always bad results and it has never helped.
32. The WW II Allies showed us the true path to peace.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.02.13)
The WW II Allies showed us the true path to peace. Total resounding victory with no concessons whatsoever. That is precisely the path Israel needs to take regarding the "Palestinian" poseurs. Israel has nothing to talk to "Palestinians" about except their departure from our land.
33. Rubbish ! How about "Talking for Peace" ?
Roland Seener ,   London England   (07.02.13)
34. Look at Peres's face...
Johannes ,   Norway   (07.02.13)
Is this an experience of Heaven for him?
35. I think we should release ALL Arab prisoners
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.02.13)
After walking them up a flight of stairs, place a rope around their necks we should release them 2 meters straight down
36. Quite simple really . .
Mike ,   NZ   (07.02.13)
Swap 20 of theirs for one of ours (Ron Arad) . . . Then we can talk !
37. Man! John Kerry really wants that Nobel Peace Prize.
Daniel ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.02.13)
Mr. John Kerry I am not sure your seeking peace in the middle east for the right reasons.
38. Releasing murderers from jail is "inconvenient"?
mira ,   nyc   (07.02.13)
What a completely idiotic statement. Releasing murderers from jail is a total breach of the rule of law. It creates a real and major threat of future crime, both because those same murderers would be free to murder again, and because society has lost the deterrent effect that law enforcement is supposed to provide.
39. Had to force my self to read this leftist garbage!
Michael Redbourn ,   Arad   (07.02.13)
I saw the headline and knew that the article would be tripe. There is no peace process because neither the PA or Hamas want one! They want the whole of Israel. And why should Israel allow itself to be blackmailed into releasing prisoners early? Israel stopped building for nine months and what did it get in return? Nothing but less buildings! What concessions did the PA make? It's still teaching hatred of Jews in its schools!
40. Stone Throwing is Attempted Murder
Menachem Ben Yakov ,   Yerushalayim Israel   (07.02.13)
The writer seems to be living in a world of whimsy not wisdom.
41. Negotiation
Meir ,   New York, USA   (07.02.13)
Does anybody in the Middle East understand what the word negotiation means? There's no such thing as a precondition to a negotiation. There's only negotiation. Apparently the negotiation at this time is Israel release murderers in exchange for Palestinians to open a dialogue which they are free to close at any time. If, somehow, anybody feels that is a reasonable exchange, you do it. The entire view that Israel refuses to negotiate by not meeting "preconditions" shows a serious lack of understanding of the term. They simply don't like the offer the other side is making. So the Palestinians need to either lower expectations or accept that negotiations are already at an impasse. Successful or not, that IS the current negotiation.
42. move bak to Yeman
David ,   Tel   (07.02.13)
You spread fear and doubts among us when will you stop!! when will start living by principles of decency and fairness . who are you? you really should move back to yeman
43. Peace is a valued concept, enough to negotiate...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (07.02.13)
... Peace for Peace!! Those who are eager to extract more and more concessions from a party, only to come around and sit down and talk peace, probably don't value the concept at all and don't really mean to live in a state of peaceful coexistence.
44. Prisoner release? Are you joking?
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (07.02.13)
What good will it do for Negotiations? Might make good PR but otherwise its a crazy pathetic gesture What we call for is a meaningful JOINT show of cooperation as a MUTUAL show of goodwill That gits rid of any one sided gesture being seen as giving away to preconditions Maybe a Joint Educational or Cultural Institute, Joint Agricultural Research..which gives Palestinians and Israelis a positive message And if prisoners are released they are released quietly - not amid ridiculous Hamas or Hezbollah style Victory Fanfare...
45. you forgot the 1948 partition plan
1948   (07.02.13)
46. The price of arms from Obama!
michael Pielet ,   israel   (07.02.13)
Question, who is Israel making peace with? Peace with Kerry or the arabs? Sign a peace of paper with whom? Security arrangements, who will enforce. Peace with the arabs is a non sequitor. Only the presence of the Israeli security forces in Judea and Samaria can provide security, how does that square with the creation of a second arab terrorist state aligned with the terrorist state of iran in Judea and Samaria. If a second arab terrorist state were created it would only make the conflict worse and result in the deaths and insecurity of more Jews. Is this the price of arms from Obama. Yes, of course.
47. More left-wing idocy
Johnny ,   TA, Israel   (07.02.13)
Surrender for the sake of surrender? Land for Terror? Tough negotiation? they are worse than Dodo's theseleft-wingers
48. People pay for this crud to be written?
Ozraeli ,   Australia   (07.02.13)
The entire basis of Judaism is the strongly held belief in the existence of an abstract, intangible, unprovable, unknowable, omnipotent, omniscent, existence of a single Deity/Creator & his/her/its edicts & actions. While I understand (to a large degree) adherence to the rules promoting constructive society, I also think that it is NO WONDER Jews are such a bunch of self delusionary fools chasing Utopian political concepts & (apparently never ending) self destructive actions. Did this woman graduate high school?
49. to #45 the arabs didn't want the plan.
ghostq   (07.03.13)
too late to bring arabs historical oops, alote of water went under the bridge and that plan is no longer valid.
50. Ariela. this grass is too strong for you.
Ariel ,   Europe   (07.03.13)
51. The author is delusional, to the point
Reuven   (07.03.13)
of being dangerous. Why did Ynet publish this masochistic garbage?
52. Fighting for peace
Phillip Dryer ,   Australia   (07.04.13)
Negotiations are pointless, whilst the PA preaches incitement against Jews in it's schools, thereby ensuring that their insane and illogical hatred continues for generations to come.
53. initial contribution??? What about other prisoner releases?
jrebecca ,   modiin   (07.04.13)
What would Ariela Ringel-Hoffman call all the previous prisoner releases,or building freezes or other give aways we've already given? If this is an initial something, then are talks starting from scratch, in which case the date 67 can also be forgotten and all talks start from NOW, from where we are NOW, with the towns and villages we have built as they stand NOW, and with the borders as they stand NOW.
54. #40 "Stone throwing is attempted murder?"
No brainer ,   Israel   (07.08.13)
Does that also apply to those who throw stones at motorists on Shabbat? Or settlers who throw stones at Palestinians?
55. Pure Nonsense Ariella!
Dina ,   USA   (07.28.13)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article