News
Dozens attack haredi soldier in Jerusalem
Noam (Dabul) Dvir
Published: 09.07.13, 23:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
83 Talkbacks for this article
1. They don't deserve a Teudat Zehut.Deny them citizenship NOW!
Michael ,   California, USA   (07.09.13)
2. Why Are They Ultra Orthodox
menachem ,   jewish world   (07.09.13)
I'm ultra orthodox and I'm completely embarrassed by these hoodlums. We are not part of the same religion. The intolerance that they espouse would render our religion obsolete if everyone displayed that towards us. Live and let live.
3. Soldiers passing just to incite got what they deserved
Pinny   (07.09.13)
These soldiers should move to Tel Aviv with their families or else remove their uniform before passing charedi neighborhoods and defiling holy neighborhoods with their tamei uniforms.
4. Those attackers are also "learning" gemara
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.09.13)
we see their "sharp mind" . Where are their so called "rabbis" to condemn those hateful acts ?
5. shows respect
iechezkel ,   Chile   (07.09.13)
Those soldiers who wear their "tamei" uniform are willing to give their lifes to save a Jewish soul like you. They safeguard the security of the Jewish nation, shows more respect.
6. hardi riots
benfivel ,   Jerusalem Israel   (07.09.13)
Have they no shame.
7. Deport The Rioters To Gaza
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (07.09.13)
These maggots aren't any use to Israel or anywhere else for that matter. They will not be missed.
8. Next Time He Should Call Me And Other Orthodox Jews
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (07.09.13)
Who proudly served in the IDF and the reserves as combat soldiers, and it will not happen again after that- ever.
9. Shoot to kill? Stone terror attacks? Only for Arabs...
Mark ,   Vancouver, Canada   (07.09.13)
Whenever Palestinians throw stones, the talkbacks are filled with "shoot to kill" the stone throwers, and "stones are terror attacks", seems like those calls are silent now, i guess these people support "shoot to kill" when its only at Arabs...
10. I hope
Paul ,   Jerusalem   (07.09.13)
most rational people in Israel know that Chabad and Breslov Chasidim have nothing to do with these social, political, and spiritually corrupt extremists.
11. This must be stopped now!
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.09.13)
The shame of the people! They want to live in Israel, let them act like Israelis. They want to behave like wild, undisciplined people let them leave. Cut their subsidies now. They don't deserve to be protected by the IDF. #3 - GET OUT!
12. Also "sharp minded" attackers ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.09.13)
Those attackers were also learning "guemara" . We see the results !!! And where are their "rabbis" to condemn this behaviour ?
13. Lapid and Peri are anxious for civil war
(07.09.13)
As long as Arabs and secular draft dodgers are not included in this equal burden, they'll get nothing but civil war.
14. Lets wait for details
Sane   (07.09.13)
The whole thing smells.
15. The ultra-orthodox are quite powerful and courageous.
Anny   (07.09.13)
Start up with them and you wouldn't dare start up with them again. Why can't Israeli leaders have the power and courage these ultra-orthodox have? Maybe they should become leaders of Israel and make Israel into a strong state.
16. Haredim should live in Brooklyn, not in Israel
Anat   (07.09.13)
Haredim Jews respect the laws of every country they live in OUTSIDE of Israel. The modern, liberal Israeli Jew (this includes moderate religious people) has NOTHING in common with the Haredim Jews. In fact, it is doubtful they are even Jewish at all! Jews are known to be liberal, modern, respectful of the law and to contribute GREATLY to any country they live in. The Haredim Jews exhibit nothing but extremism, backwardness, aggression and segregation. They contribute nothing to Israel and fight any change.
17. Is There Anything In Torah, Talmud Or Midrash
(07.09.13)
That States Jewish Men Should NOT Serve In The Military? And Why Is ANY IDF Soldier Less Jewish Than Hasidm? My Relationship With Ha Shem Is Between Us!!! Like Menachem Said Live And Let Live
18. What are you talking about Pinny #3?
Proud soldier ,   Israel   (07.09.13)
Your comments wouldn't make any sense even if you tried! How can an army uniform be tamei? Believe you me it's people like you who will be begging for help, defense and protection from the wonderful people wearing these "tamei" uniforms, if anything ever threatened the Jewish state, never mind your precious neighbourhood! And in regards to neighbourhoods, should we now tell all the charedim to keep out of Tel Aviv or any other chiloni area, due to possible incitement! Congratulations on spouting out some of the biggest load of rubbish I have heard in a long time! People like you give an awful name to wonderful charedim (and there are a lot of them), who are decent human beings and do actually care about their country and also have some grey matter upstairs! I think you need to do a lot of introspection before you come back on here!
19. 3 Pinny, Your comment is similar to...
Robert ,   Antwerp Belgium   (07.09.13)
that of people who think in Europe that to dress like a Jew allows anti semites to attack them because it's a provocation to dress diferently.
20. Typical Deri doublespeak
Avinoam ,   NYC   (07.09.13)
Deri's 'condemnation' is of 'extremist teens', not, of course, of the hateful mentality that is the problem. Oh, maybe it's because he has a hand in the propagation of that foul mentality...
21. Should be given rubber bullets and open fire on attackers!
avg joe ,   south of tel aviv   (07.09.13)
Haredi soldiers bashed by other Haredim?-open fire with rubber bullets! The leeches are not your brothers! Any haredi perpetrating violence against any soldier should be immediately deported and have their citizenship removed. Their rabbis should be charged with incitement and their rabbinical qualifications should be removed. These people pervert the Torah and are unfit to render halachic rulings!
22. 4 Charles guemarra is not ...
Robert ,   Antwerp Belgium   (07.09.13)
responsible for the stupidity of some rabbis. The guemarra is a fantastic historical religious and cultural frescoe of the Jewish people and you better study it
23. #2 If you were ultra orthodox you would know that
Pinny   (07.09.13)
the ultra orthodox Rabbis said to fight against these soldiers defiling charedi cities in their tamei uniform and scream and yell at them "tzei tame", get out of here, you tame. Yes, that's what OUR GREAT RABBIS declared publicly recently. We will listen to our Rabbis no matter what they say. They are our leaders, not some anti religious shmoe in the government.
24. 4 Charles we should not jump to conclusions
S Judah ,   Jerusalem   (07.09.13)
It is almost certain it will be found when those that were arrested are exposed. That they are from the extremist sects like Nutri Karta, may they be cursed. I truely despise those pigs. They will not be from the main stream Haredi groups such as Beltz, Gur , Viznitz, nor from the Litvat community. Who you may be supprised to know very much respect the army, even though they fight against forced enlistment. It is important that we do not tarnish the main stream Haredim for the vile behaviour of these swines. You are quite right, we need to hear strong condemnation from the main stream Haredi Rabbi's or they willl have shot themselves in the foot by appearing to condone this despicable act.
25. Pinny and the Haredim prove that Moshiach ain't coming soon
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (07.09.13)
Thanks for the reminder, Pinny #3, that sinat hinam is alive and well in Haredi-land. Any excuse and the haredim love to go crack Jewish skulls. I'll be you were hoping they'd kill the shmuck too, huh? Now your black coated buddies can go out tonight and blow off some testosterone, burn city property, maybe even some police cars, and try to hurt some Jewish cops too. Haredim are so full of hate that it's no wonder we're about to mark the destruction of the temple....by people just like Pinny and his hate-filled Haredi cohorts. Mayb Pinny and his family should move to Flatbush and take their sinat hinam with them. Too bad Pinny doesn't think our tax money is "tamei" - he sure loves living off it and paying for tens of thousands of his shlemiel buddies to pretend they're all talmidim chachamim. Right. Chacham enough to try and lynch a Jew.
26. 16 Rioters do not represent neither..
(07.09.13)
Secular nor Haredi society.
27. 15Only united Jews can make Israel..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (07.09.13)
a strong state.
28. #3 and similars
dan ,   DC   (07.09.13)
should those people be entitled to health care and any other benefits of the treif state of israel? i think not
29. Pinny
PaulD ,   Jerusalem   (07.09.13)
Our generation is cursed without real leaders. These Rabbis calling for confrontation are not the Tzaddikim of yesteryear. I doubt anyone of them has attained any level of Ruah Hakodosh. Once you meet a real Tzaddik, you'll see though these Holy imposters, how they have done more to darken than bring light to the Torah and Nation.
30. #8 I rarely agree with you but this time, its Pinchas u & me
Jew with Cojones ,   Israel   (07.10.13)
Kol HaKavod and Respect to the IDF!
Next talkbacks
Back to article