Jewish Scene
Ukraine divided over WWII legacy
Associated Press
Published: 29.08.13, 08:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. Doesn't matter which uniform they wore
Israel Tachlis ,   Jerusalem   (08.29.13)
Pro-soviet? Pro-nazi? Does it really matter? I'm sure both sides murdered Jews just as happily as the other did
2. Nobody's business ,...
split ,   US   (08.29.13)
Only an ignorants unfamiliar with Soviet ruthless brutality can blame them for siding with Nazis - 8 million starved to death Ukrainians during one winter 32/33, victims of artificially created famine called Holodomor in the attempt to eliminate a whole segment of society (that's Holocaust) on the way to implement communism induced by Soviets (not to mention other atrocities) gives them 8 million excuses to do so.
3. The Ukraine managed to somehow survive Stalinist Terror
(08.29.13)
But would the Ukraine have somehow survived a Nazi victory? The answer is NO, In the event of their victory, the Nazis planned to enslave the Ukrainans as their lands would have been stolen by Germanization
4. split: are these 'excuses' sufficient to kill children ?
jdc ,   New York, US   (08.29.13)
These folks have not only fought the Red army, they also killed kids. Oops, to you that may be a plus not a minus. You may have noticed they also killed Poles. Perhaps you are willing to overlook a few excesses, as long as they killed Jews.
5. We're talking about 14th Waffen SS division, right?
Juha Teuvonnen ,   Boston,MA   (08.30.13)
The ukrainian troops in question served in 14th Waffen SS division. It was called Galizien by the Germans in an attempt to somehow classify these guys in a category different from "untermenschen" ((subhumans) which Ukrainians and Slavs in general belonged to, according to the Nazi theory. In fact, in the beginning it was strictly forbidden to refer to the division as Ukrainian. Needless to say, this division was staffed with true Ukrainian patriots. Up until 1943 their partiotic duty, for the most part, consisted of helping Nazis ethnically cleanse Ukraine from Jews and Poles. After stalingrad the Nazis needed all the cannon fodder they could get, so they thre the 14th Waffen SS division into action. Fighting the Soviet Army turned out to be quite a bit more challenging than massacring civilians, and the division was practically obliterated in short order. Germans put together the pathetic leftovers, re-staffed with Nazi sympathizers from all over Europe and used them against partisans in Slovakia and Slovenia. It goes without saying that it was the duty of every self-respecting Ukrainian patriot to help Hitler fight Slovakian and Slovenian partisan. Then their patriotic duty morphed into fighting against soviet army in Austria, with ultimately predictable result. It saddens me greatly that people don't know the history of World War II ...
6. #2-show an example
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.30.13)
Start with yourself. if it is nobody's business then don't read Ynet, don't post your full of hate disgusting statements, don't react on the Jewish matters. Only very miserable production of the dysfunctional family can blame the Jews in all the evils.
7. 4 - No attempt to overlook, just consistent with my beliefs.
split ,   US   (08.31.13)
You can spare me your lecture althought my family was not directly harmed by Ukrainians they witnessed their atrocities. Yes they murdered Poles too but didn't do it on Polish soil, my homies invaded them, stole their land and occupied for centuries. It was a payback. Your homies living already there stabbed them in the back siding with Poles during Polish occupation as well stabbed Poles and them again and again when Russians an Austrians and the Bolsheviks took over ,... "Yevhen Kutsik, 86, was a 16-year-old boy when he took up arms and joined the SS Galician division after seeing mountains of corpses of innocent tortured men, women and even children" left by the Soviets". Read more carefuly, in this particular article the Ukrainian women and children are the ones that got butchered not to mention those millions starved to death by Yagoda and Kaganowich goons during Holodomor.
8. And that's probably why my grandmother's kin did not make it
Moshe ,   Usa   (08.31.13)
out of Galicia in WWII.
9. # 8 ,...
split ,   US   (09.01.13)
I don't condone atrocities or any violence but if there's any nation in Europe that have a neighbors like Ukraine it earned a right to be pissed off big time - I don't blame any nation that was invaded and subdued by Soviets and took a chance siding with Nazis ,... A few of them like Crimean Tatars or Cossacks if it wasn't for WWII they would be a history today ,... At the time of payback usually those that didn't participate in Holodomor or other atrocities have paid the price for what their homies did as foundin fathers of this blody system and Stalin's goons. Mass murderers like Kaganowich died of old age and never paid the price for what he did
10. #2 Tells The Truth
World Citizen ,   the world   (09.01.13)
And guess who was instrumental in carrying out the crimes that caused the Ukrainian famine? Bolshevik Jews.
11. Charedim not Commisars
Zechariah   (09.01.13)
Ukranians Nazis killed a lot of Religious Jews and Women and Children and Bundists and Zionists who were not Communist Commisars.the hate came from a savage disposition even to their own people their own women and children were often brutally heated by their husbands.Alcholism was rife and still is.the church was anti Jewish to an extreme and supported the Czarist Regime and an impoverished peasant class As throughout time The Jews were blamed.
12. split: nonsense on every front
jdc ,   New York, US   (09.01.13)
You need some lecturing badly. you are badly wrong on 2 accounts: being pretty selective with attribution of guilt: Ukrainian websites put top responsibility on: Stalin, Molotov, Kaganovich, Posthaste, Kosior, Chubar, Chatayevich,Yevdokimov, Balytsky, Yezhov, Yagoda. 3 were Jews, 8 were not. You picked Jews, not Russians, Georgians or Ukrainians. Nice. More importantly, when someone does something bad enough, it is understandable to pursue those responsible not some random people you perceive as his kin. 'Payback' by killing kids, really ? Since Cheka was established by a Pole, do you have any plans to do the honorable thing ? The concept of 'homies' you seem to be fond of, has no place as an argument. If you do not get that, arguments are futile, since you lack minimal ethical background.
13. 11. Charedim not Commisars ,...
split ,   US   (09.01.13)
But they had a hundred other ways to bread hate to them - They're not exactly the most loved bunch in Israel either, are they? ,...
14. # 12 ,...
split ,   US   (09.01.13)
"Since Cheka was established by a Pole" - Dzierzhynky died in 1926, 7 years prior to Holodomor, his name is not a proof that he was a Pole. During the partician of Poland thousands upon thosusands of Jews bought or received real estates left by resisting Poles sent to Siberia for snitching in many cases includimg names of the owners. I don't have a time to go over your list but no matter how do you twist it still a less than one percent of population makes 30% on your list. Holodomor was Kaganowich and Yagoda's 'baby' those two conceived and implemented this genocide so save your breath ,...
15. split: Dzierzhynky was a Polish nobleman
jdc ,   New York, US   (09.02.13)
The main point remains: going after innocents in no way addresses injustice. Now Felix was the one who created the brutal police tactics. His successor was also a Pole. Jews, while over-represented among Reds, are far from synonymous with them. Reds went hard against the Jewish religion and Zionism. They were a disaster for Jews. You will not find many Jews today cheering Kaganovich and Co: he is universally despised. The same obviously cannot be said of the various SS collaborators who apparently are viewed as heroes. Georgians are also over-represented. It was the evil nature of the police state that people have snitched on each other for spite and profit. Plenty of Jews were brought down that way too. The Reds in no way have favored Jews. Now as for delivering people to death and taking their stuff, surely you know what happened to the real estate of MILLIONS of Jews in Poland (and elsewhere) ? And no, that stuff was earned through industry not pilfered.
16. Eastern European WWII nationalist groups
SLR ,   Detroit, MI USA   (09.22.13)
They, along with many other nationalistic eastern European groups were xenophobic racist haters who were motivated by hatred of "the other" and used the Nazi Soviet war as cover for their crimes. It is truly unfortunate that many more of the members of these groups were not tried, convicted and punished.
Back to article