Opinion
Righting the wrong
Yigal Sarna
Published: 14.08.13, 09:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
1. Indeed: Inequality in the Israeli Justice System
y-man ,   budapest   (08.14.13)
Palestinian murderers are set free, Jewish murderers stay in prison.
2. Yigal just justified murder one of Israeli civilians
ghostq   (08.14.13)
due to political reasons. this is one disturbed Israeli, he needs psychiatric help, next Yigal will claim that nazi prisoners should be releast due to jewish economic policy in the 30's.
3. What Drivel
Ron ,   oc us   (08.14.13)
There is no excuse for this article as there is no excuse for letting these Arab animals out of prison before there sentences are up. No good will become of it. The article is sickening and that is the best thing that I can say about it.
4. Nigel Kennedy and Mehdi Hassan
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (08.14.13)
What have they in common? It riles me when I listen to these TV commentators or 'celebs' who love to caricature West Bank Palestinians as victimised and downtrodden and are completely ambivalent to talking up OUR SUCCESSES and PROGRESS - BECAUSE IT MAKES BETTER NEWS as in the case of Mehdis famous 'Café Interview' in Ramallah on Al Jazeera OR in the case of Nigel Kennedy better PR for HIS performance with the Palestinian Youth Orchestra PYO Nigel Kennedy milks on the fact that this all about HIS altruism and charity and goodwill and......rather than ONCE ADMITTING its because the PYO ARE GOOD AT WHAT THEY DO Are they just misguided or using the Palestinian Cause to further their own agendas?
5. The devil is the in the details
Jacob ,   Ramat Gan   (08.14.13)
It is very nice to write about oppression and such, but these are cold-blooded murderers: Salah Ibrahim Ahmed Mugdad beat 72-year-old Israel Tenenbaum to death with an iron bar at a hotel in Netanya and then stole a television set. Atiyeh Salem Musa axed to death 67-year-old Isaac Rotenberg as Rotenberg was bent over fixing a floor on Passover. Ali Ibrahim al-Rai attacked 79 year old Moris Eisenstatt in a similar manner in 1994, while EIsenstatt sat on a park bench in Kfar Saba. Yusef Abdel Hamid Irshaid and Samir Hussein Murtaj tortured and killed other Palestinians who they claimed were “collaborators.” Burhan Subaih also set out to kill “collaborators,” one of whom was a woman named Aisha Abdullah Haradin. Would the author consider these acts to be ones of desparation? Or just the acts of psychotic killers. The author is not treating these people like human beings by making them incapable of being responsible for their actions. No, the average person does not act like this, even if they live under foreign rule. Did we ever see Jews acting this way when they suffered far harsher oppression. By "allowing" acts like these, the author is actually saying that these people, perhaps because of the color of their skin, are not responsible for their actions. This is casual left-wing racism. When a white man commits such acts of barbarity they are correctly condemned, but when a person of color commits such acts, it is because of some oppression. All should be treated equally. When someone axes another to death, they should receive the fullest punishment with no possibility of reprieve, regardless of the context. Articles like this feed into this casual racism and the non-accountability for brutal murders.
6. An insensitive fool
Shalom Freedman ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.14.13)
This particular babbler is an insensitive fool He has no thought or consideration for the families of the victims of these horrendous crimes.
7. Your wrong
(08.14.13)
You support freeing the unrepentant murderer of Holocaust survivors. You support freeing people who deliberately burned small Jewish children to death. You support freeing people who raped and murdered Jewish children. I am sure you will support the murderers of the Fogel family coming home soon to a big heroes welcome as well in the next prison release in the next decade or even less. All because of your insane political viewpoints about how Israel is to blame for everything, and the Arabs who openly admit they do not recognize Israel's right to exist on even one inch are totally guiltfree and innocent as a lamb. The same lovely people who fired off guns and welcomed as heroes people who murdered an elderly Holocaust survivor with an picaxe. Don't insult anyone's intelligence you don't have one ounce of sympathy for the victim's families. You sir have no heart and no soul. I would say shame on you,but then again I think you have no shame.
8. Peace Now
Sam Krow ,   Seatle   (08.14.13)
A Peace Now founder bashing and slandering Israel. Surprise, surprise.
9. Yigal Sarna has been granted...
Beary White ,   Norway   (08.14.13)
.. citizenship of the strip by hamas. Give him some new underware and money for a free trip to his terror-friends.
10. There are fools & there are idiots
tiki ,   belgium   (08.14.13)
The writer is both!
11. they want our, death, not our land....their words not mine.
joshua ,   cancun   (08.14.13)
12. Misguided
Steve ,   Canada   (08.14.13)
The author believes that killing innocent women and children is a justified response to an alleged occupation. Typical peace now garbage. Am Israel chai
13. inherent contradiction
Itiel   (08.14.13)
What does it mean to have your "heart go out to the victims" if you are unwilling to see the perpetrators of the horrible crimes that made them victims be punished? These murderers are in prison because they are not fit to return to human society. Releasing them is an affront to justice to all sane individuals. Something that seemingly excludes Sarna.
14. is it useful to release israelis back to world again ?
atilla karagözoğlu   (08.14.13)
15. violent occupation
Zev ,   Israel   (08.14.13)
Who makes the occupation violent? Ask any Palestinian (when no one is listening) whether he would rather live in Israel or in the new state that will be called Palestine.
16. A peak into the sick, self destructive soul of the left..
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.14.13)
This ludicrous article hardly merits a response. There is barely a single word of truth in it. From the denial of Israel's legal ownership of Judea and Samaria to the justification of mass murder. However, this article offers us a peak into the twisted soul of the sick, self destructive Israeli left.
17. #1 Learn your history my friend
Stan ,   Israel   (08.14.13)
Members of the Jewish Terrorist organization which was active against Palestinians over 30 years ago were sentenced for murder and attempted murder to long terms of inprisonment. None of them served more than 8 years. The Palestinians released last night have all been in prison for at least 20 years, and some of them for much longer. (Some were due to be released in the near future.)
18. #4 Sammy
Stan ,   Israel   (08.14.13)
Reading all the talkbacks one gets the the impression that we Jews are "good as gold" and the Arabs are all monsters. Any nation whose land and people have been occupied for 46 years would be expected to try and expel the oppressor.
19. To all of you (who don't like Sarna's view)
Stan ,   Israel   (08.14.13)
Confiscation of property: What I find abominable is that MY PEOPLE are doing to others what the Nazis did to the Jews of Germany. ( See Google ) "AG: Arabs with security records won't get back East J'lem property" See the disgusting example of the family in Abu Dis (outside the J'lem border,) while their hotel only 200 meters from their home, was confiscated by the Custodian of Absentee Property. They are considered "absentees" despite the fact that they have never moved!
20. Worry not. This author just wants attention.Eat an ice cream
Adi ,   Zurich   (08.14.13)
Worry not. This author just wants attention.Eat an ice cream
21. to #19 jews never made sucide bombs against
ghostq   (08.14.13)
chritians in Germany. nor there were violant riots against chritians in Germany. but if you mention Nazism, the Mufti of Jerusalem was one. which means palis has Nazi history.
22. Better to improve Palestinian Conditions
Zechariah   (08.14.13)
Better to improve Palestinian Conditions like water allocation and better Megacities in exchange for banning or condemning Holocust Denial issue antiJudaism is a good start.
23. All Sarna wants is a mail from Chomsky welcoming him into
tom ,   tel aviv   (08.14.13)
the "Club for Useful, Jihadist, Neo Fascists". I'd grant him that on the spot & send them both to Hell, but better yet: Iran or Gaza.
24. #22 zechariah
solomon ,   bklyn   (08.14.13)
They already made promises for Oslo; to stop teaching hatred to their children, to stop using a map of the entire area as their motto (with no room for Israel), etc. They have done none of it. That says a lot. Listen to them; they have already spoken.
25. There is NO Israeli occupation!
Robert Blum ,   New Albany, U.S.A.   (08.14.13)
There is NO Jewish occupation! There is only a Muslim occupation of Judea & Samaria, which the Muslims cleverly renamed 'The West Bank', in order to de-Judaize the area in the world's collective mind. The Muslims of Jordan (formerly Trans-Jordan, which England created), cleverly re-named themselves "Palestinians" in the 1960's, and revised history in order to gain world sympathy for their cause, which is the annihilation of Israel, and to teach the great lie, which is, that the Jews stole their land from them! Before Jordan started its war against Israel, they told their Muslims brothers in Jerusalem & in Samaria & in Judea to sell the land to the Jews, because they were confident that they & their co-religionist Muslim nations (Syria, Egypt, etc.), would destroy Israel & so they could thereafter keep the land as well. So they sold & fled & waited for the results of the war. Israel won that war. They recaptured the Holy Jewish land; Jerusalem, Samaria & Judea. They rightfully settled it, even though Obama the Muslim, who constantly quotes the Qoran, (NOT the Bible), demands Israel to stop settling Jewish, G-d-given land. Israel, unlike the Jordanians, allowed Christians & Muslims to come & go freely in those areas. The deeds to the land were and are owned by Jews. They allowed the Muslims to continue living in Jewish apartments & homes as long as they continued paying rent to the Jews. Arafat came along & told the Muslims to be arrogant & not pay! They stopped paying and were consequently evicted. Of course Islam, the revisionist liars, tell the world that the Jews are pushing them out of their rightful land! It is NOT Muslim land, regardless of the fact that the Muslims continue to teach and even believe their own lies! UNESCO has always been an Arabist, anti-Jewish body. They supplied, and continue to supply Islam with anti-Jewish text-books, teaching hatred of Jews and of Israel. They wrongly allowed the Jordanian Muslims who labeled Jewish Samaria and Jewish Judea as the "West Bank" of Jordan. They wrongly allowed these same Muslims to perpetuate a status as refugees, in order to gain great financial support for many decades, so that they earn per capita gratis, on U.S. taxpayers backs, more money than do the Egyptians and the Syrians per capita! Moreover, when the Jews whose indigenous countries were Islamic, they were massacred by the Muslims and disenfranchised of their lands and all other valuables. Those Jews, 800,000, who survived were absorbed into Israel. Islam however never paid reparations to those Jews, nor did Islam ever absorb these Jordanians who, in order to gain world sympathy, have revised history to teach the ignorant next generations their perpetual lies about a non-extant "Palestinian" history, calling themselves "Palestinians", the name which was created by ancient Rome to label Israel & the Jews, in an effort to assimilate them.
26. Ignorance or vicious lies?
Maurice ,   Montreal   (08.14.13)
The writer very conveniently ignores the fact that "Palestinians" do not want to accept the existence of Israel! Ignores that their children are brainwashed from very young age to hate Jews. Ignores what happened in Gaza after Israel left! He onviously wants another Gaza in Judea and Samaria a short distance from Tel Aviv and Ben Gurion airport! He is no less than a traitor!
27. It's clear where this man works
Josh Felt   (08.14.13)
that he's long been an ipso facto complete traitor, a spoiled one at that in his comfy house in rich part of TA. Israel must get rid of his subversive self-hating antisemitic ilk. at any price. no nation that wants to survive anywhere can tolerate traitors in its midst. Even more so if they are basically fascists themselves.
28. A Jew supporting the underdog because Jews not perfect
Sam ,   Canada   (08.14.13)
First, it's not an occupation for many Jews. The Palestinians are under Jewish control and it's hard to have a kind control when Palestinians want Israel to disappear and express that in violent ways. Negotiations can't get anywhere when Palestinians reject a Jewish Israel to begin with and prefer terrorism,war and boycott to make Israel disappear. It leaves Israel always on the defense and that's not always going to be as nice as some Jews prefer.
29. A Jew supporting the underdog because Jews not perfect
Sam ,   Canada   (08.14.13)
First, it's not an occupation for many Jews. The Palestinians are under Jewish control and it's hard to have a kind control when Palestinians want Israel to disappear and express that in violent ways. Negotiations can't get anywhere when Palestinians reject a Jewish Israel to begin with and prefer terrorism,war and boycott to make Israel disappear. It leaves Israel always on the defense and that's not always going to be as nice as some Jews prefer.
30. Righting the wrong
Abraham Bruck ,   USA   (08.14.13)
Reality will never rear it's ugly head in a Liberal World ...
Next talkbacks
Back to article