News
Ex-Shin Bet chief warns of 'next Yigal Amir'
Published: 15.09.13, 13:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Carmi is absolutely right......
(09.15.13)
these groups are very dangerous. There behaviour is an embarassment to the Jewish people and they are basically doing terrorist acts. The acts of desecration that they do make us look very bad....the government must make more efforts to stop & punish them, and punish any Rabbis who incite this.
2. Vandelisem/graffiti = terrorist acts. How??
Yaniv ,   UK   (09.15.13)
Can you please explain how this equals to terrorist acts?? I suggest you look at the definition first before you quote such absurd things. Next you will say that a thief is a KILLER even though he just stole a tv because some theives have also killed. I myself don't agree with price tags whether it comes for Jews or Arabs but you certainly can't lebel them terrorist.
3. It's dangerous when men start to compare vandals w/murderers
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (09.15.13)
Livni describes them as terrorists. The left defame & label anyone who disagrees with them extremists. What serious crime have the price tag vandals committed? Spraying paint on the wall? Slashing tires? This is to be equated with blowing up a cafe full of people or murder. The demonization by the left of right-wing activists is what is truly dangerous. Once they are labelled extremists, than all gloves are off when it comes to eliminating them.
4. Beware of the Next Udi Adiv and Tali Fahima from the Left
Shut up Carmi ,   Haifa   (09.15.13)
5. Gillon you should be ashamed and keep quiet.
Zev ,   Israel   (09.15.13)
6. Graffiti Terrorism? Stifle Descent?
Bill Stein ,   USA   (09.15.13)
Let me get this right if the right does graffiti that is terrorism ? If the left stifles descent and gets paid off by other countries that's democracy? Sounds like he supports a dictatorship to me.
7. "Peace talks progress" mean 9 mile wide Israel..
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.15.13)
" Progress in peace talks" with the P.A. means ceding Israel's more than 3,500 year old ancestral heartland and turning Israel into a 9 mile wide concentration camp. Gillon's so-called warning is politically motivated and intended to justify cracking down on patriotic Jews determined to save Israel.
8. Ex Shin Bet ...another Yigal Amir
rebaaron ,   Jerusalem   (09.15.13)
Another bitterly Left old man dreaming of Oslo to come.
9. Gillon is a far Leftist personnality. Old story.
(09.15.13)
10. How did so many anti-Israel leftists climb to the top of the
Unbelievable! ,   Israel   (09.15.13)
ranks in the Shin Bet and other Israeli government post? They are the real danger to Israel. What is wrong with these people?
11. Talks to create an arab terrorist state.
michael Pielet ,   israel   (09.15.13)
These are talks to establish an arab terrorist state in Judea and Samaria aligned with the terrorist islamic state of Iran, at the gates of Gush Dan and Jerusalem.
12. The threat.
michael Pielet ,   israel   (09.15.13)
The threat of the left to destroy the state of Israel. It is a serious threat that has to be constantly monitored. This is the true existential threat.
13. Civil War is coming and the Oslo Terrorist Leftists
Warrior   (09.15.13)
will be dealt with one by one!
14. Carmi was Avishai Raviv's boss
Israel   (09.15.13)
So when he sent Raviv to taunt Amir that he didn't have the balls to act what was he trying to accomplish?
15. The Radical Left is an existential threat to Jews!
Joe   (09.15.13)
They must be eradicated!
16. YES vandalism is terrorim, when
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.15.13)
the objective is to frighten people into leaving an area or to do/no do something then it is terrorism. Terrorism is causing a behaviour or stopping a behaviour through fear. The price tag vandals objectives are to frighten people, therefore they are terrorists and should be treated as such.
17. Yigal Amir's main crime(beside homicide) was robbing Israel
tom ,   tel aviv   (09.15.13)
of possibility of putting Yitzhak Rabin on trial for the Oslo crime. Whom am I kidding: his partner in crime is today's President of our unfortunate nation.
18. Gillon snt Raviv to encourage ppl to attck politicians
(09.15.13)
19. #16. Are you serious? An absurd comparison!
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.15.13)
To compare scrawling graffiti with murder is beyond absurdity. When I read comments like yours, I wish the author was joking. Utterly mind numbing!
20. These self-serving leftists are destroying Israel.........
Sachi ,   Jerusalem   (09.15.13)
21. 16 = ignorance at its best
Yaniv ,   London   (09.15.13)
So by your definition that means any crime that carries fear = terrorist.. What a stupid person you are. What kind of democracy do you represent! More like dictatorship. To achieve something you will make you will make anything lawful, sounds like you should be living side by side with Assad. What a pathetic extremist person you are.
22. Carmi is trying to incite violence by the left
Mordechai   (09.15.13)
Clearly Carmi is trying to incite left wing terrorists to attack and kill their political opponents in the name of the peace process. He should be immediately arrested under anti incitement laws. The incitement to violence by the left must not be allowed to continue
23. a slippery slope
On the Balcony ,   Akko/NY/Kyiv   (09.16.13)
Physical attacks on property is but a step away from physical attacks on people. The comments here calling for the "eradication" of "leftists" aptly demonstrates Gillon's point. Call it vandalism, call it it patriotism, call it whatever you will, the simple truth is that "price tag" actions are seriously wrong and should be treated seriously, regardless of whether one agrees or disagrees with the purported motivations of those who commit such acts.
Back to article