News
High Court: Infiltrators cannot be held for 3 years
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 16.09.13, 17:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. Very bad
Lou ,   Rishon   (09.16.13)
This is a disgusting decision by the High Court. Maybe these African infiltrators can go and live with all the High Court Judges together with their families and also with the Arab Members of the Israeli Parliament.
32. #27
Lois ,   Ramat Gan   (09.16.13)
Gabe - I like you, you seem to have more sense than the High Court Judges. Stay and enjoy Israel, better still, come and live here.
33. Ynet please address or clarify
Ofra ,   Holon, Israel   (09.16.13)
Will the infiltrators be released and immediately deported or will they be released into the streets of Israel with an appointment date for Ministry of Interior? As some are saying, you previously reported that they will be deported after high holidays. Will they be deported or not?
34. I will build for them.
michael Pielet ,   israel   (09.16.13)
I am going to build two apartment buildings, one in Rehavia, the second in Ramat Aviv Gimmel. all the tenants will poor displaced african migrants. I will even subsidize their rent.
35. Enough! Deport them!!!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (09.16.13)
This is not their country! They have no rights here but the right to go! No one in Israel wants these African pests here. They are destroying our country! This is the land of the Jews! Not Africa!
36. Michael @34 - didnt work
Gal   (09.16.13)
One of the ministers from Shas bought about 200 tickets to a fitness club in Ramat Aviv and gave them all to African infiltrators. When they all showed up at the swimming pool the residents and members just picked up their designer handbags and children and left. They are and will be righteous a*holes who will defend them even when their homes and cars get broken into.
37. all infiltrators broke the law entering Israel illegally.
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (09.16.13)
This makes them criminals - and many have committed much more crimes. What do you do with criminals? You put them in jail. All those in detention can leave & return to their home countries any time they want. They do not have the right to live in Tel Aviv or anywhere else in Israel. Regardig the law being "unconstitutional". This is a joke, Israel has no constitution, but if there were, holding infiltrators for a MAXIMUM of 3 years until a way could be found to deport them would not violate the constitution of most western countries such as France, which have detention centers.
38. "Not constitutional"???
Zev ,   Israel   (09.16.13)
What constitution? Israel does not have a constitution. Is Israel's Supreme Court judges so powerful that they can overturn Israeli laws based on their own opinions? Can someone explain? Is this democratic?
39. Israel = Africa
(09.16.13)
Israel is more like an African country than Morocco, Libya and Eqypt and these countries are actually a part of the African continent. Whoever allowed this to happen needs to be prosecuted and imprisoned for a very long time, or better yet sent to live in captivity in Sudan or Eritrea.
40. An African told me...
Phoenix ,   Israel   (09.17.13)
An African from 5 Africans that work in cleaning at the place I too work told me: south tel aviv is ours (Africans he ment) soon we will start attacking any white entering our place, even the whites police. (Israeli police)
41. Deport the Judges and the Africans
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.17.13)
Both are criminals and hate Israel.
42. Good!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.17.13)
Deport them immediately. Where's the problem? How many more innocent Israeli women and female tourists need to be raped and murdered before the government does something?
43. those (insult,insult) judges are right.
les ,   canada   (09.17.13)
all those wonderful people should be let out of detention, and resettle them in those court houses, and the homes of judges made the decision.
44. Well,let‘s see, our Torah says
Rich ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.17.13)
in Deuteronomy 23:16, that if a slave (or someone fleeing another country for their lives) makes it to Israel, you are not suppose to send them back to the slave master. You are not suppose to mistreat them and they are free to live anywhere in Eretz Israel. The Rambam states that the slave is completely free if he makes it to the Holy Land. In Deuteronomy 5:15, it says: ‘‘Remember you were once slaves in the Land of Egypt.‘‘ The rule of thumb is, if you treat people with love, they will treat you with love. Who knows, maybe some these people will convert to Judaism and become better Jews and even better Rabbis than we have today.
45. In civilized countries these people are called refugees!
Peter Griffin ,   Quahog   (09.17.13)
Just for the record....
46. Only fair. Police barely spend 3 minutes on actual criminals
Taxpayer ,   Israel   (09.17.13)
When the real day-to-day dangers to the citizens are pursued and punished, then they can focus on other problems.
47. get the police to stop playing with tazers and arrest africa
zionist forever   (09.17.13)
The police are useless If the police were to pick these people up and they cant show they are here legally there must be something the police can actually charge them with then they are not being hld without charge they are being held for an offence. If the police need help get the Magav or the army to help them ut just don't turn a blind eye because it will only get worse because more will come and the ones here will have children so their numbers will grow. Government also needs to try reword that bill find a way to pass it because things cannot continue as they are. If nothing is done give it 10 years they will make up a major part of the countries demographics and the kids will grow up become Israeli citizens, they are a ticking time bomb.
48. Is there a 'higher' court?
(09.17.13)
Can this appeal be appealed? Who holds the 'power' over High Court?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article