News
IDF officer: Hamas control of Gaza benefits Israel security
AFP
Published: 25.09.13, 01:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. Reverse psychology- very clever :)
(09.25.13)
2. Right.
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.25.13)
Let's be sure to inform the good people of Sderot, Ashdod, Ashqelon and environs. Just wipe Gaza out. Trust me; no one will miss that terrorist haven. Think of it as a much larger Abbottabad compound, and you'll get the idea. Terrorists need to be destroyed wherever they crop up. In this case, Gaza. And any officer -- no matter the rank -- that thinks that Hamas is "good" for Israel should be cashiered. Destroy Gaza. Root and branch. And all its vile inhabitants. We can build something far better in its place. Something that is not dedicated to the destruction of the State of Israel -- a goal which Hamas trumpets at every opportunity. Can't blame Israel for taking them at their word.
3. Short term thinking
Alan ,   Canada   (09.25.13)
Saying that Hamas in power in Gaza is better than more radical groups replacing it is like saying Bashar Assad in power in Syria is better than a jihadist in power. But longer term, Assad has been the surrogate builder of an Iranian financed nuclear plant. And as to Hamas it will long term do its best to derail any attempt to achieve even a temporary peace agreement between Israel & the West Bank an already fleeting proposition to start with. So Hamas may be convenient now but it is not likely to remain so for ever.
4. Does calm mean good?
Dan   (09.25.13)
The mullahs have achieved calm in Iran, too. Is that good for Israel? The low-grade thought bubbles coughed up by freewheeling low-rank Israeli officers as the mood takes them are a source of worry. It isn't the place of public servants to comment on geopolitics – they should leave that to the government.
5. Gen. Sami Turgeman must resign ! he supports de facto Hamas
(09.25.13)
6. Right.
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.25.13)
Let's be sure to inform the good people of Sderot, Ashdod, Ashqelon and environs. Just wipe Gaza out. Trust me; no one will miss that terrorist haven. Think of it as a much larger Abbottabad compound, and you'll get the idea. Terrorists need to be destroyed wherever they crop up. In this case, Gaza. And any officer -- no matter the rank -- that thinks that Hamas is "good" for Israel should be cashiered. Destroy Gaza. Root and branch. And all its vile inhabitants. We can build something far better in its place. Something that is not dedicated to the destruction of the State of Israel -- a goal which Hamas trumpets at every opportunity. Can't blame Israel for taking them at their word.
7. Of course, just like bringing Arafat strengthened our sense
tom ,   tel aviv   (09.25.13)
of security..... Where do we find these Einsteins?
8. Hamas is good, when?
David ,   Miami USA   (09.25.13)
Egypt is strugling with Hamas & Company, and the official says that Hamas is goog for Israel.Remove this Guy or shut up his mouth.
9. Hudna - a temporary fake peace in order to rearm
BH ,   Iowa   (09.25.13)
10. suffering from shell shock: my favorite enemy
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (09.25.13)
11. Gen. Sami Turgeman must resign ! he supports de facto Hamas
(09.25.13)
12. Tugerman : please, shut up your bigmouth !
(09.25.13)
13. Finally: Someone expresses what I think
Israeli 2   (09.25.13)
I agree with you once again Sarah B. Are these commanders Arabs or what? What kind of mentality is that?
14. This line of thought
Yosef ,   Egypt   (09.25.13)
makes Israel sound schizophrenic, and needlessly justifies other people in the region in regarding everything Israel does or doesn't with suspicion. To come out and say that at a time when we in Egypt are getting tough with Hamas is counterproductive to say the least, especially in the long run. Sure this might work in favor of the Egyptian government right now, but at the price of more anti Israel sentiment among Egyptians. Israel needs to start planning further into the future, and make serious efforts to integrate in the region and connect with the PEOPLE of neighboring countries. I think a decent Israeli government owes it to its people to build a better future on a solid foundation for generations to come. May peace and prosperity be with Egypt and Israel.
15. Hamas Extermination and Destruction is far far better !.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (09.25.13)
16. Hamas Extermination and Destruction is far far better !.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (09.25.13)
Back to article