News
What will happen when a Palestinian state is established?
Elior Levy
Published: 10.10.13, 15:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. Without Hamas agreement Pals will have excuses to attack
Sam ,   Canada   (10.10.13)
An agreement without Hamas signing on is naive. Palestinians want the West Bank and Jerusalem now and the rest later. Palestinians will always be in a position to blame Hamas for any attacks on Israel. Also, Hamas could well take over the West Bank because Palestinians simply want a change in government.. There is no room for Israel to be naive just because the US and EU are pressing for an agreement at any cost. It's Israel that bears the consequences of a foolish agreement.
2. Please ignore leftist utopia dreams
Rachel ,   US   (10.10.13)
These are the same people who said Oslo and the Gaza disengagement would bring peace.
3. What a load of BS
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (10.10.13)
There have been a lot of claims of Hamas "moderation" over the years. I remember the claims if they were elected they would 'moderate'. So what happened - we got to see if Fatah members could fly without airplanes. This 'study' is yet another in a long series of total bullshit
4. dreamers
aaron ,   toronto,canada   (10.10.13)
A bunch of dreamers sitting around a table and drinking tea with biscuits. Until the world recognizes that the arabs just want to kill the jews or each other there won't be any peace. STOP supporting them and send them all to Jordan that's where they belong.
5. Totally delusional leftist B.S.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.10.13)
What rational basis is there for the results of this so-called "study"? Every single Israeli retreat leads to unmitigated disaster. This study brings to mind the parade of leftist dolts predicting all would be wonderful once Israel left Gaza. You can still see them on video mouthing this idiocy. Israel must claim and annex all of Liberated Judea and Samaria. This tiny land is ours now and forever!
6. Without Hamas agreement Pals will have excuses to attack
Sam ,   Canada   (10.10.13)
An agreement without Hamas signing on is naive. Palestinians want the West Bank and Jerusalem now and the rest later. Palestinians will always be in a position to blame Hamas for any attacks on Israel. Also, Hamas could well take over the West Bank because Palestinians simply want a change in government.. There is no room for Israel to be naive just because the US and EU are pressing for an agreement at any cost. It's Israel that bears the consequences of a foolish agreement.
7. Has Vehalila
(10.10.13)
8. Good !
cfspirit ,   fr and dz   (10.10.13)
I hope for this !
9. like gaza
milson   (10.10.13)
full of crap.
10. dont forget an end to global poverty
zionist forever   (10.10.13)
Hamas are not going to become moderate, they are a branch of the Muslim Brotherhood they have an ideal and thats liberate all Palestine not just 2 states. They have said in the past create a palestinians state they will agree to a 10 year hudna (ceasefire ) but not peace or the fight for all palestine. Israel & the palestinians creating a mini NATO, where members go to help each other when their security is threatened please. The Arab League do not even have any NATO principle security alliances and they are made up of arab states. If the Arab League won't do anything like that why would the palestinians & Israel? TRANSPORT OF NATURAL GAS FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE ENTIRE REGION. So now in the name of peace Israel is going to share its gas reserves with anybody in the region who wants some of it. I would love to know how transporting natural gas through a palestinians state will lead to a huge drop in Israeli energy prices... prices might go up as they always do but not down. Which far left academic dreamed up this utopia world?
11. Rubbish....
jo   (10.10.13)
Hamas wants first world money but lives and acts like a third world nepotistic despotic theocracy. That is not likely to change. With all the billions donated so far the PA and Hamas have become like most backward states.....money goes into pockets...welfare for the poor non existant, infrastructure, medical, all access for those who have the connections........pipe dream on international study. Now if they have to pay for everything them selves they are going to make utopia? NA
12. Who took this poll, the IMF and people who will continue....
Just the opposite ,   will happen!!!!!!!!!   (10.10.13)
to rake in billions because the price of housing will not only skyrocket in Israel, also in then in "Palistine".... and the world bankers will get triple digit interest on the money they loan to everyone to develop all this. Not everyone is stupid enough to believe this!!!!!!!!!!
13. To Chaim.
David Clarke ,   Liverpool, England   (10.10.13)
Chaim what's more delusional?, an international study backed up by clear economic, social and political evidence?, or how about you constantly referring to the State of Israel as being a 9 mile concentration concentration camp?. The last time I checked a concentration camp doesn't have the the highest standard of living in the middle east, and the inmates certainly don't have Nuclear weapons and the best trained and best equipped military in the world. You know as well as I do that the IDF, who participated in this study (part of a radical leftist conspiracy), could defend Israel within its legal borders which sadly for you don't include the biblical messianic Kahanist dream of an Israel stretching from the Nile to the Euphrates that is completely Arab free. Perhaps you should emerge from what ever hate rock you live under and experience the outside world a bit more instead of living in constant fear of anyone who is a bit different from you?.
14. # 45 AMEN! American's support this too!
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.10.13)
ANNEX Move all embassies to jerusalem or, out they go. BUILD JEWISH HOMES NOW!!!!
15. Yall got about 30some days, mark my word
Yeshua ,   Wahington D.C.   (10.10.13)
Yeshua,,,,,,,,,, it just don't get no better than this,,, being in the TRUTH, REALITY AND PROPHECY. You can play with it if you want,,,,,,, but I am coming, an EARTHQUAKE will precede me. We are on the clock, been on the clock,,,,,,,,,, but it is the HOUR.
16. Jabberwocky
Steven ,   San Francisco   (10.10.13)
Should there be a competition for most ridiculously themed creative writing, I would without hesitation urge the writer to enter this article.
17. 5
zionist forever   (10.10.13)
There was an article on Haaretz website the other day about how the Zochrot idiots making their plans for a right of return. They were holding a conference in Tel Aviv to discuss the ROR how it was all going to be arranged and what style the rebuild ciliates would be in, traditional or apartments etc. Despite the fact they have no political influence of any kind they are so convinced there is going to be ROR they hold these little conferences to plan for the day. Here we have some academics talking about NATO principles between Israel & arabs. Israel sharing its gas and best of all gas prices in Israel dropping by a quarter - third all because we created this palestinians state. Some people just do not want to live in the real world, its to painful so better to live in a fantasy utopian dream.
18. Wow....sounds sort of like more.....
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (10.10.13)
hope and change. Some people will swallow anything that's fed to them.
19. # 45 AMEN! American's support this too!
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.10.13)
ANNEX Move all embassies to jerusalem or, out they go. BUILD JEWISH HOMES NOW!!!!
20. # 13 Hey how about London take in all the pals?
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.10.13)
Israel doesn't want them neither do any of the Muslim states who, currently, are busy massacring one another. London, yep, perfect for your 'Brothers' to join you and have a Muslim Queen on the throne. One note of warning, all off duty UK soldiers, carry loaded weapons, pals will behead you and hack you to death right in daylight, right in front of women and kids and POLICE! Ah, those 'peaceful' Muslims.... LOL
21. #13. Judea/Samaria belong to Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.10.13)
#13. I don't hate anyone. Hate doesn't enter the equation. Truth does. Judea and Samaria legally belong to Israel. This is such an air tight fact that nobody (including the P.A.) will publicly debate it. MK Danny Ayalon challenged them to do so. Moreover, it is obvious to any literate child, who can read a map, that Judea and Samaria make Israel viable. Judea and Samaria ARE Israel! This ridiculous study is just like all the ridiculous leftist studies and arguments which have all been proven dangerously wrong. I suggest everyone watch the long line of leftist idiots on video telling Israel what a great idea it is to flee Gaza. A mere six months ago, leftist fools urged Israel to cede the Golan!! Leftists have been wrong about every major issue since Israel was founded. That is just a fact.
22. Plain wishful thinking.That's all.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (10.10.13)
23. Ah, peace at last!
Larry ,   Northridge, usa   (10.10.13)
I dont know why you people are so cynical and skeptical. Look how the peace treaty with egypt has brought such mutual prosperity and uh, never mind.
24. #13 People do not debate the legitmacy
#21 ,   Akko/NY/Kyiv   (10.10.13)
of the Palestinians right to the West Bank because there is nothing to debate. The settlement policy is illegal under international law. Case closed. I wonder what you will do if /when Israel recognises the State of Palestine and surrenders its claims to Judea and Samaria....We shall just have to wait and see....
25. Hamas will radicalize Palestinians
Dan   (10.11.13)
In the lead up to the 1988 elections in Israel, when the possibility of giving Arafat a state was debated, it was claimed the responsibility of governing would soften him, force him to be moderate. Instead he used his position to support terror and refused all peace offers. Only in democracies does power bring moderation. In authoritarian regimes such as Hamas would impose, power unleashes ideology and kills moderation – and moderates.
26. the researchers
benateed@gmail.com ,   galil   (10.12.13)
The researchers predict that there will appear a rainbow over Jerusalem under which a gigantic pot of gold will be found. And all the leprechauns will convert and make aliyah.
Back to article