News
Rabin's grandson to Netanyahu: You owe us peace
Itay Blumenthal
Published: 12.10.13, 19:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. G-d bless Y. Rabin, z"l
Rafi ,   US   (10.12.13)
2. Be careful not to incite hatred...
Spinning Propellar   (10.12.13)
3. On 5 Oct. 1995 Rabin's speech at the Knesset:
Hermon Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.12.13)
1. Jerusalem will remain united under Israel's sovereignty and it will also include the suburbs of Giv'at Zeev and Ma'aleh Adumim 2. All major Jewish settlement blocs will be incorporated into the sovereign state of Israel, including Gush Qatif in Gaza 3. The Jordan Valley ought to be viewed in the widest sense of the term, and it too will remain under full Israeli control 4. The future Palestinian Arab state will not be a regular state in that it will be fully demilitarized, its airspace will be controlled by Israel, as will its boundaries and all of its border passes: land, sea and air Let all of us remember Rabin's view of the future, all of us!!
4. Not an ideal time for nativity
Fred ,   LA,CA   (10.12.13)
First may Hashem bless Yitzchak Robin's soul for all he did for Israel. But we know arabs want us dead. Iran's nuke program is getting close to our neck like a sword. Palestinians murder our Heros like colonel Seraya Ofer and you want peace from BB. LET THE MAN DO HIS JOB.
5. Where are the people, just 35,000 ?
Judd Rusnak ,   Sydney Australia   (10.13.13)
Only 35,000 people in the rally?, I want to see at least 800,000 people (Like in The Maran Ovadia Yosef funeral) only then we will know that the people want peace. Currently, the Arabs are killing us at night, they preach hatred, the want to kill the Jewish dream (Zionism), they only deserve to be transferred to Jordan where the real Palestinian state exists.
6. 35000.....
Mike ,   Edmonton,AB   (10.13.13)
represents only 0.4375% of the population in Israel. 99.56% of the population do not share the views of peace (?) as brought up at this pathetic demonstration.
7. Pro-Peace Movement: A new Messianic cult?
MarkG ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.13.13)
Pleading for an impossible peace vis a vis genocidal enemies may signify none other than advocating surrender and national suicide.
8. but not peace of the grave where you would lead us.
ralph   (10.13.13)
9. #5: Well said Judd. All the rest is merely irritation.
Israeli 2   (10.13.13)
10. Netanyahu you owe us peace
Harold ,   USA   (10.13.13)
The grand son of Mr. Rabin should know that Netanyahu and Sharon were against Oslo Peace agreement and he, Netanyahu, is still against it. Mr. Rabin was assassinated for choosing peace instead of war.
11. Peace is very much desirable and very nice to have.
leo ,   usa   (10.13.13)
However, when it comes to peace it takes two to tango. Perhaps you meant to say that PM owes you safety. If so, then I would agree that it must be demanded.
12. Stop all talks now!
Wise Saba ,   Western Negev   (10.13.13)
Why are we still talking to these murderers & terrorists. I Don't condone the killing of another Jew, but I will not shed a tear for Rabin, his Oslo folly is a death process for us & must end. Thousands of innocent Israelis have for the left's false G-D of "piece", enough!.
13. You owe us peace, how silly!
Sidney ,   USA   (10.13.13)
That is what the peaceniks of the time said to Neville Chamberlain. He brought them a treaty that guaranteed "peace in our time". Hitler had other ideas. I have no idea of "what the sound of one hand clapping sounds like". I do know what happens when one side signs a peace treaty with itself.
14. what Israel should give for peace
Darnell Potts ,   Edgewater, NJ, USA   (10.13.13)
I'd like to see Bibi offer up Tel Aviv to the PA, all its real estate, all property and wealth etc., to the PA in return for "peace". Let's see how many Neville Chamberlain wannabe's at the rally are willing to pay a price personally for peace.
15. WHO OWES WHAT?
Tomi ,   Hungary Budapest   (10.13.13)
" The PM owes us the piece." But the Israeli left does not owe thosands of life of innocent Jewish children and adults after the failure of Oslo? Was there even at one time any apology from their side for misjudging the risks what the Oslo Accord delivered?
16. Let's admit mistakes
Larry ,   LA   (10.13.13)
Yigal Amir's murder of Rabin was a tragedy but that does not justify the tragedy called Oslo. Let us never be so stupid as to ignore our mistakes or be so blind as to think our errors are correct. This was the tragedy of Rabin's legacy: Oslo was a total mistake and we should have the courage to admit it and never fall to prey that we should make hopeful thinking becoming our false reality again.
17. A Memorial for the Victims of Oslo
A Simple Jew ,   Beer Sheva   (10.13.13)
Rabin's was responsible for Oslo, which killed 1500 Jews and wounded and maimed thousands more. The left told us to "take risks for peace". Well, we did, and Jews died in large numbers. Oslo spread suffering and grief throughout the land. It is Rabin's fault, along with the rest of the Oslo criminals.
18. netanyahu doesnt owe
Avi ,   Nyc   (10.13.13)
The wholesale murder of his political opponents on the Tel Aviv beach
19. Tell it to the arabs.
Michael Pielet ,   Israel   (10.13.13)
Stop the incitement. You want peace, grow up and tell it to the arabs. Next year hold your rally in Ramallah.
20. Tell it to Abbas
Rachel ,   US   (10.13.13)
21. Rabin
drdoc online ,   Cape Town.   (10.13.13)
It is not Netanyahu who owes you peace... It is the world who owes us peace.. For the hatred and antisemitism that is past and future. Don't expect it... It isn't coming..
22. @19 why don't you rally in Damascus.
Miron ,   USA   (10.13.13)
23. #3:Whatever Rabin's view of the future was is irrelevant now
tom ,   tel aviv   (10.13.13)
WE are here, we should have clear view of the responsibility we have to our children. Let us not roll the ball into their court: Let us fight the Arab invaders c& impostors NOW, by ourselves, before it's too costly (and may be too late).
24. Sheeple
(10.13.13)
How can so many people be so dumb?
25. The Prime Minister only owes us the guarding over Israel's
Hermon Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.13.13)
national and security interests, and, happily, he has done so.
26. Bibi, YOU owe us peace?
tiki ,   belgium   (10.13.13)
Was this moron living in a cave? It certainly looks like it. To little sun & oxygen probably damaged his brain activity, otherwise he wouldn't make such a stupid comment, although it's a nice & catchy headline. Peace is made between people who want it and Arab Palestinians prove daily they don't. They don't want to live in peace & harmony next to you, they want what's yours & you out....yes, lefties to. When will this ignorant group of people finally understand that it's NOT about what Bibi wants, its about what Arab Palestinians want.
27. Unfortunately these people are in a minority
Susan ,   Manchester   (10.13.13)
Most Israelis back Netanyahu and his hawkish expansionist coalition. I think Israel will always be at war like countries in Africa, it is a sad reality.
28. #24
(10.13.13)
The are Leftists
29.  I Quote -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (10.13.13)
Rabin's grandson, Yonatan Ben Artzi, addressed Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in his speech, saying: "My grandfather was murdered over peace, and you owe us peace" Comment - Only HASHEM can bring Peace and it will come only on HIS condition. The Leftwingpeace will only end in War. Arn.Sweden.
30. scary naive people
jay abouaf ,   jaffa israel   (10.13.13)
Next talkbacks
Back to article