News
Murder victim's family: Detectives mocked him because he's Arab
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 14.10.13, 10:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
29 Talkbacks for this article
1. Shameful Behavior
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (10.14.13)
Where are these police recruits coming from? Training should also require them to learn how to deal with the public, especially in situations like this. Those who did this should be fired.
2. the victim was familiar face to the police
lili   (10.14.13)
he was active in the crime world, when criminal dies as result of his or her activity people usually say good ridence, in no place in the text massage, the word arab or muslim was even mentioned. but now every one in and outside Israel knows Hindi was a trouble maker and his family faces.
3. Thanks to Zoabi and the others
italian ,   italy   (10.14.13)
When your community cheer hezbollah, hamas and the terrorists, when it acts as a fifth column, you can't expect that people pay you so great importance. Thank your Mks, dear mrs Hindi, and stop to babble nonsenses.The only preaching separation are israeli arabs. Reap what you seed.
4. Detectives Mocked
Nili ,   Jerusalem   (10.14.13)
If the murderer is in Ramallah, you need to go through Abbas. If Israeli police tried to enter Ramallah they would be lynched. That being said, our police treat Jewish victims just as shamefully, it is a disease in this country
5. Nili's more or less right
grp ,   tel aviv   (10.14.13)
There is a disease that makes people in a position of power treat people shamefully and this is no exception. Jews are equally as contemptuously treated by a poorly trained, poorly educated police force. It needs to just be added that that this kind of treatment isn't just an Israeli disease but one prevalent throughout the wild Middle East.
6. those cops are low lifes ... they dont represent me
naftules ,   jerusalem   (10.14.13)
As a jew im disgusted with their lack of concern for life. As a torah jew I know that all life is precious to the creator. Laughing at the murder of anyone is sick and these cops are simple low lifes ... they dont get good pay and they probably like pushing people around. Glad to hear they will be prosecuted.
7. Italian to another Italian
Italian in Israel   (10.14.13)
meglio di pulire la tua casa prima!
8. If your an Arab and want "proper" treatment
Mike ,   Israel   (10.14.13)
I strongly suggest you move to either Syria, Egypt, Iran, Lebanon, LIBYA just mention a few of the countries who pride themselves in treating the dead properly. Get over it, or leave!
9. Disgracefull behaviour.
David Clarke ,   Liverpool, England   (10.14.13)
These officers behaved disgracefully and it is right that justice is being done for the pain they caused the Hindi family of Ramle. Police officers serve the entirity of The State of Israel and all of its Citizens, regardless of whether they are Jewish, Arab Christians and Muslims, Druze, Circassians or Maronites. The vast majority of police in Israel serve all citizens with pride and distinction and they have been undermined by these mindless morons. It is clear from this incident that some people still need to learn that being Israeli isn't the sole privilege of the Jewish community and some people in Israel, especially the officers who behaved so disgracefully, still need to learn a lesson about human decency and community relations.
10. Comments on WhatsApp
Ros ,   Tel Aviv   (10.14.13)
What a disgrace! Have the police nothing else to do but to use WhatsApp - and to discuss a case like that! Maybe someone should look into decreasing the manpower in the police force, obviously they have too much time on their hands!!!
11. to #9 really?
ghostq   (10.14.13)
you made a mistake, Ramla is not Ramalla, Ramla is in Israel. Ramalla is in the WB. this guy tried to smugle stuff to the WB, and the deal went sour, the murderer run to the WB and Israel can't do a thing. if you call human decency than ask the palestinians y they kill other Arabs in Israel in the first place.
12. To Mike, Israel.
David Clarke ,   Liverpool, England   (10.14.13)
Mike it doesn't matter how they treat the dead in Arab Countries, we are talking about Israel and the Hindi family are Israeli Citizens and shouldn't expect to be treated like dirt by a minority of ignorant and foolish police officers who are supposed to help them but instead mocked them simply because they are Arabs. Being Jewish in Israel doesn't give a privilege to a minority of ignorant racist Jews to be able to treat non-Jewish Israeli citizens like the dirt beneath their feet. Every Israeli Citizen is Equal under the law whether they are Jewish or not and should expect the same treatment as everyone else, minorities are not going to just pack up and leave because ignorant racists like you want them to.
13. # 9 David Clarke, Have you ever lived in Israel?
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.14.13)
From news reports of a British off duty officer being hacked to death and beheaded by one of your Muslim population, I'm sure you know more about that than Israel as you live in Liverpool. Physician heal thyself.
14. #7 pathetic arab fake
italian ,   italy   (10.14.13)
Sapessi scrivere in italiano, faresti miglior figura. Anyway, none believes the whining of racism, since this community loves to support palestinian terrorism. Arabs who don't like Israel, like this Hindi, can move out to Syria, where they could taste their brethrens' laws.
15. to #10 you also have spar time,
ghostq   (10.14.13)
instead working you TB. tisk tisk tisk.
16. Oh!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.14.13)
So the victim's family members want Israel to go charging into Ramallah to arrest a killer. Gosh, that's an endeavor upon which we can embark day in and day out. Lots of murderers have found refuge in Ramallah. With their like-minded brethren. What the hell was their loved one doing that involved either a Ramallah resident or someone who knew they could find safe haven in Ramallah, anyway? Perhaps that is what merits close investigation. But it's nice to hear an ersatz "Palestinian" urging Israel to invade Ramallah. Long overdue, actually.
17. Blood-Lust
Robert Blum ,   New Albany, USA   (10.14.13)
I am not justifying the 2 detectives, however, such cynicism is born out of the countless murders of innocent Jewish children, their parents, and the general population, by Muslim terrorists who enter restaurants, shopping malls, night-clubs, school buses, yeshivahs, and anywhere and everywhere else, murdering randomly, Jewish people, in an insatiable blood-lust. If Jews were as Muslims, which we are not, then Israeli soldiers would have exterminated the self-made, so-called "Palestinians", when they entered Gaza, instead of dropping leaflets in warning of Israel's intervention, and going house by house there, to assure that non-combatants were unharmed.
18. # 5 grp, Abuse of power isn't just a ME problem
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.14.13)
There's a legal case currently in New York of a motor cycle 'Club', "Gang" who is filmed attacking an SUV with a family inside. One of the bikers slowed down in front of the SUV in order to slow traffic so they could use the entire highway and was run over. Several of the ' Club's ' members are cops, one broke the back window of the SUV being filmed after the incident. There's an old saying that applies here, "The only thing standing between a criminal and a cop is a badge." I'm afraid it's a universal trait in all nations.
19. # 9 David Clarke, Have you ever lived in Israel?
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.14.13)
From news reports of a British off duty officer being hacked to death and beheaded by one of your Muslim population, I'm sure you know more about that than Israel as you live in Liverpool. Physician heal thyself.
20. "After YNET Revealed" .? WhoWasHe?
HalfTheTruth&Story ,   Jerusalem Israel   (10.14.13)
YNET reporter who is himself obviously an Arab by his name doesn't "reveal" to us who was this man and why was he possibly killed Ramle is a known criminal hangout so why didn't this reporter "reveal" more of the deceased's details ?!.....hmmm.
21. WhatsApp
Mike ,   Tel Aviv   (10.14.13)
Well, I suppose we should therefore be careful what we write on WhatsApp then. What it doesn't say is how did they find out what they wrote? Obviously it's not secure.
22. To Build Baby Build.
David Clarke ,   Liverpool, England   (10.14.13)
I've been to Israel many times and have been treated hospitably by everyone regardless of ethnicity because, unlike yourself, I don't care what a persons ethnicity or religion is because I am not driven by a racist religious fanaticism. Now let me ask you something Build Baby Build, have you ever been to anywhere outside Israel and the United States?, and what exactly is it you actually do on Ynet apart from say ''Keep Building'' and being president of the I love Sarah B Fan club?.
23. #18 - spot on
grp ,   tel aviv   (10.14.13)
24. # 22 They reap what they seed
italian ,   italy   (10.14.13)
Ramla arab aren't notorious for their attachment to the State. Only when they need of jewish help, do they remember that they are israelis? They should ask directly to PA, since they tend to consider themselves Palestinians.
25. police
natalie ginsburg ,   jerusalem, Israel   (10.14.13)
I can only say to the family of this man that the same police who reacted as they did to his death would probably have done so with anyone with whom they did not agree regardless of race and religion. One would only hope that the police would throw the out of the force
26. Jews 98.2% of Police, but half of population, why? Racism.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (10.14.13)
27. Ah, the poor terrorist family's feelings.....
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.15.13)
so what if the cops made comments? Most cops do when they find a bad guy. Sounds like this criminal is better off dead than to exploit others over and over. Like their feelings are paramount, they aren't.
28. # 22 Since you asked..
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.15.13)
I've traveled extensively, and frankly, I don't care what ethnicity or religion one is IF their intent is to live in peace and allow others, including myself to do the same. I am retired, made a load of money in several fields, and am amused by militant Muslims murdering ( while blaming the Jews ) one another while half wits like you defend them. As for being a fan of Sarah's, damn straight, the lady has wit, style, and other than being angrier than a lot of Jews here, ( with reason, from what I read as her family was exterminated by your former Nazi allies.) is a wonderful example of Jewish female, chutzpah and brains.. unlike yourself or your left over nazi bastards now posing as pals. BTW, Sarah has many fans here as she is appreciated by them for the same reasons I outlined. So, tuck up your tail booby and slither back into that 7th century Liverpool low rent Apt. and feast on crow. Don't mess with the Jews. Much smarter and much stronger. KEEP BUILDING !!!!!!
29. # 23 grp, Thank you, Shalom.
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.15.13)
Back to article