Jewish Scene
US shul revitalized by $1M recruitment
Associated Press
Published: 23.11.13, 08:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
10 Talkbacks for this article
1. From paying to get in to paying to come in
Thinking Jew ,   Israel   (11.23.13)
Neither Dark Ages religion nor eliminating religion works. Meanwhile, moderate Tora lovers are gaining traction.
2. moving to the South
iselin ,   Oslo, Norway   (11.23.13)
This is an artificial situation. As soon as these folks' kids are 18 or so, if not before (I doubt that they checked the SAT scores for Alabama), they will leave Dothan for a "big smoke" and never return. I grew up in a tiny town in the deep South, so I know the all about this sort of thing. No rabbi after 1950. By 1970, fewer than 10 adult men, merged with synagogue in small city 15 miles away. By 1980, that synagogue merged with the other one in there. Pretty soon, it won't have enough members either and whoever is left will have to drive around 80 miles to a fairly big city with plural congregations. The seniors go to Florida and the young just get the hell out (as I did). This is happening all over the rural US. Look at the small towns of Minnesota and Iowa and you will see the same thing. The man who is sponsoring the moves to Dothan is just postponing the inevitable.
3. 2 comments. First; this was printed months ago..
Shadoil79 ,   Jerusalem   (11.23.13)
And you are so bereft of news that you had to dig this out? 2. Pathetic Reform Judaism now BUYS people to attend their meaningless selfserving congregations? PATHETIC!
4. a woman CANT BE A RABBI!!!
ari   (11.24.13)
i am not even religious but this is going too far. pathetic
5. #2 Shadoil, why the hatred?
Debbie ,   Rehovot, ISR   (11.24.13)
Why the hatred for a fellow jew? So they have a different understanding and worship in away that is menaingful to them. Why judge everyone based on your own beliefs? You clearly demonstrate that Jewdism is a religion of intollerence and hatred and you wonder why people are turning away from religion? It seems you are the one with the problem my friend.
6. They should move to the real Dothan instead
Avi   (11.24.13)
The one mentioned in yesterday's parsha- in the Shomron.
7. #3 Meaningless selfserving congregations?
Ezra ,   San Diego   (11.24.13)
Not quite. In fact, judging fellow Jews is none of your business since it only divides the Jewish Nation. Your business is to support other Jews because YOU are NOT the center of the universe, HaShem is. My personal opinion of the situation is that it's transitory, and a good reason to relocate to Israel; there's a time for every purpose under heaven.
8. This is very sad
GT ,   Israel   (11.24.13)
Israel needs more Jews and people should make aliyah, not move to some tiny community where their children will either totally assimilate or leave the place anyway.
9. 4 - Devorah ha-Shophetet
Non-KoolAid Drinker ,   DrinkyurownKoolAid   (11.24.13)
You need to learn Torah instead of rabbinics
10. addition to #2
iselin ,   oslo   (11.24.13)
Not just Jews are leaving small towns in the US. "Everyone" is leaving. Once a mall comes, people no longer shop near home and the small local businesses go bust. When the factories shut down, there are no jobs left, so the working class people leave in the wake of those who could afford to leave earlier, when they went away to go to university. It's a pattern all over the US.
Back to article