Opinion  Smadar Perry
The president is in love
Smadar Perry
Published: 28.10.13, 10:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
32 Talkbacks for this article
1. Palestine: Information with Provenance
michael redbourn ,   Lisbon Portugal   (10.28.13)
Just did a search for who has previously published articles by Smardar Peri. Palestine: Information with Provenance And she was privy to all these top secret meetings. Yeah, right!
2. Israel can act like in 1967 or in 1973...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (10.28.13)
The second option would be LETHAL this time...Bibi knows it, I know it and the rest of the world knows it...
3. The're not in love, the're 'scheissers!
tiki ,   belgium   (10.28.13)
Big talkers who have been called their bluff by Syria first & Iran second!
4. Israel CAN attack Iran in front of the whole
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (10.28.13)
world...because the rest of the world is ABSOLUTELY unwilling to do ANYTHING against the Iranian nuclear Holocaust project and because the whole world simply doesn't care... The US in particular has ceased to be a major power in the Mid East...the weaklings Kerry and Obama have become irrelevant laughingstocks and they certainly CANNOT force Israel to commit national SUICIDE !
5. Israel can attack without Obama's permission!
michael redbourn ,   Lisbon Portugal   (10.28.13)
If Israel sees no alternative then it will go it alone and it doesn't need Obama's permission. The writer makes a simple assumption sound like a fact.
6. Shame or War
michael Pielet ,   israel   (10.28.13)
Obama has to choose between shame and war. Obama has chosen shame, appeasement and now Israel will surely have war.
7. Hussein Obama is a LAME DUCK...he can
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (10.28.13)
NOT dictate Israels national self defense ! A quick Israeli strike will CHANGE the whole logic of Mid East politics in it's FAVOUR !
8. In summary
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.28.13)
Israel alone took out both Syria and Iraq's nuclear facilities, why not Iran? If any one thinks that due to obama's eunuch reputation and laziness that Israel wont attack Iran without the eunuch's okay, they should rethink this through..... Israel has everything to lose, oybama, nothing.... Has any other US President ever bowed to any Saudi King except for obama? NO! JUST KEEP ON BUILDING BABE!!!!!
9. Iran already has the nuclear capabilities it needs
Shachar ,   Eilat   (10.28.13)
Now Iran is lowering the price for their nuclear project. One day this is all going to get very very messy and all because no0one had the guts to stop them when it was much,much easier.
10. Israel can and must destroy Iran's nukes!
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.28.13)
Many times Israel has acted with supreme courage without U.S. approval. This must be one of those times. Israel can and must destroy Iran's nukes. Israel was no reborn, after 2,000 years, to be endangered by the most hostile and incompetent U.S. President in history.
11. If 1 F16 takes off from IL,Obama will call his Iranian frien
Alan ,   SA   (10.28.13)
12. Smadar, honey....
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.28.13)
..... the Iranians are not Arabs. They are thus NOT part of the "Arab world." That's where I stopped reading your editorial. If you are so pitifully uneducated that you do not know that Iranians are not Arabs, there is nothing you have to say of any worth. And no reason for anyone to pay attention to your silly, uneducated blather.
13. Boker Tov! Of course Hussein is
ASTRONAUT ,   SC, USA   (10.28.13)
in love! The voters in Los Estados Unidos knew that from Day 1: a dude named Hussein emerges out of "left field" [literally] and sweeps the demigod worshippers off their feet; gets elected and 4 years later gets [oh my God no!] RE-ELECTED while the jihad marches merrily on.
14. where did this expert peri come from
milson   (10.28.13)
peri suddently is some kind of expert?? who the hell is he? Of course obama will not attack iran. But more than that, bibi won't attack iran because he has zero confidence in himself, he flails around to barak or now yaalon and lapid, you decide for me, I am uncetain and lack confidence. i tell iran, you have nothing to worry about. With guys like lapid, peri, german, bibi and livni, there is zero chance israel would attack you. Go ahead, keep running your centrifuges. The past 5 years where bibi has been sounding the alarm, have betrayed his lack of resolve and shown that he is man with no confidence what soever. He is afraid of his bloody shadow.
15. #12 Sarah on Smadar
Maurice ,   Montreal   (10.28.13)
Sarah you are so right! Aside from what you have pointed out, Smadar Peri is a terrible commentator whose analyses of world politics are not worth much. She is the one who had said that Mubarak will never be overthrown when the anti-Mubarak protests started in Egypt in 2011. Just read this Ynet article she wrote to see why her articles should simply be dismissed: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4019482,00.html
16. Arab experts???
Waleed ,   Amman - Jordan   (10.28.13)
Can the author please tell us who those PROMINENT Arab experts are? And stop calling us Arabs by Sunnis and Shiites. Religious belief has nothing to do with turmoil in our region.
17. Israel has no options
spyguy ,   seattle   (10.28.13)
Regardless of all the big talk from the Ynet armchair generals, the real IDF generals know that an Israeli attack on Iran would be extremely costly to Israel and would not accomplish much more than making Iranians very angry at Israel and the US. Once the dust settled, Iran would probably go to the UN and get massive sanctions against Israel. Sure the US might try to protect Israel, but in the end the US will be forced to let some sanctions through, causing the Israeli economy to collapse. That is, Iran will defeat Israel without firing a shot. At that point, most of the sanctions on Iran will be gone and the US will have even less power than it does now. So if Israelis want to lose badly, go for it. Israel can NOT win, but only lose badly.
18. Correcttooo
Ali Hussain ,   Kut,Iraq   (10.28.13)
The writer is correct , Iran blinked Beacuse of the economic situation and the risks to the regime .Rarely does startegic logic coverage with the humane thing to do .Istarel can achieve both by helping the Syrians and bleed Iran by helping the syrian rebels , and there are good ones . Once Assad collapse the Iranian elite will be fighting each other and the economy will be the immediate victim , they will really blink this time for good . The only risk is if The fickless Obama eases the sanctions .Now we have. Proof of what actually works . The other thing to do is to continue to hunt their experts to embarrass them into hard line stands. It is easy .
19. Iran
Michael ,   toronto,canada   (10.28.13)
Iran's Pres. gives BOgus the cover not to strike Iran.BOgus has NEVER intended to strike Iran.!!! It seems Israel has no choice as do it alone.
20. # 16 Waleed, Ammon Jordan
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.28.13)
With all due respect, may I ask, will you please explain to we ignorant Jews, Christians, assorted Muslims, and those of varying faiths, or no faith, what is your analysis of what IS the cause of the turmoil in your region? Also, what are your Muslim friday services like in Ammon? I'd also like t know who those "Arab Experts" are by name, just curious. BUILDING A MIGHTIER ISRAEL !!!!
21. # 13 So did Turkey...Fool me once..
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (10.28.13)
22. Spyguy, Iranians "very angry"
ASTRONAUT ,   SC   (10.28.13)
Iranians can call themselves "persians" or "peacocks" for all it matters: Iran, Iraq, Saudi, Egypt, Lebanon, Paki, Afghani, [in other words, the entire Muslim world] have been "very, VERY angry" at America and Israel since Yom Rishon of Israel's Existence. Sanctions - Schmanctions: give 'em a nuclear enema! Love, Armchair General "Astro".
23. obama's love
tom ,   toronto, canada   (10.28.13)
obama is mostly in love with himself; after all, who else has ever won a nobel prize BEFORE DOING ANYTHING?! if his ego weren't blocking the view, he might see that, after 4 years of his prized strategy of "engagement" with iran, there's nothing good to report. domestically, the islamofascists are still firmly in control, and externally, iran is actively destabilizing all its neighbours. the only good news to report is that tough sanctions, not engagement, have brought about a change in iran's style, if not its substance. but it doesn't take a conference of experts to figure this out. the real question, which this article does not address, is how best to neutralize the threat of iran's nuclear programme, despite obama's "love".
24. Hold the whip
Joe Mevorah ,   Lincoln, USA   (10.28.13)
After all the rhetoric the U.S. will disassociate itself from many Middle Eastern affairs. Oil,which has always been the major draw for the U.S. in this region will not be as big a factor. That's why the Saudis, Egypt, Jordan , and other countries are scrambling. They no longer trust the U.S.Sooner or later, new alliances will be formed. Not formally, but informally, and Israel without daddy's permission will attack Iran.
25. Obama is not king of Israel
Brod ,   USA   (10.28.13)
Obama is NOT king of Israel or America. He is bad for both countries. He is a danger to both America and Israel. Congress supports Israel and this is what counts. Congress is more powerful than Obama because it can impeach the President of America. The American people through Congress support Israel. Under Obama, America has been buried with 17 Trillion Dollars on National Debts, massive unemployment, rising Islamist-Jihadist Terrorism, America's friends and allies are left on the lurch, as Obama extends his hands to the fanatical Islamist-Jihadist Ayatollahists that are feverishly working on their nukes to accomplish their evil intention of wiping Israel off the map of the world, and dominating the region and the world. Congress led by Rand Paul and Ted Cruz should wake up and impeach the Trojan Horse that is endangering America, the West and Israel from existential threat.
26. #13 Obama was brought in to close out the show
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (10.28.13)
Don't pay any attention to all the "Hillary will be the next President" talk.
27. Iran
Yoelarry ,   New York City   (10.29.13)
Why do l feel like I'm watching a psychotic serial axe murderer horror movie in slo-mo? " He's behind the Freakin' door damn it!!! We all know how this pathetic hand wringer ends already. Fire up the IAF Jets Bibi. Enough with the jive and shuffle!
28. #17. Israel can do Iran just like Iraq/Syria.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.29.13)
#17 Wimpguy. Israel can handle Iran just like Israel handled Iraq and Syria. Don't forget Iran never beat Iraq in their war. Your post is dumb, hostile and wrong like always.
29. Bottom realistic line : Obama desparate for
barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (10.29.13)
being the president to bring about peaceful interaction with Iran. He's failed at Obamacare, he's failed with Syria, he's also failed with getting Israel-Palestinian peace. Only thing happen in his tenure is the killing of Bin Ladin (and I'm not sure if that was his doing or left over from lat President). He is ambitious for a successful outcoming.
30. #28 et al - If you know more than the IDF
spyguy ,   seattle   (10.29.13)
generals, then over-ride them and attack Iran all you want, BUT when it all falls apart and you are facing humiliating defeat do NOT cry to the US for help (Americans, not just Obama, will ignore you). Because of extreme HUBRIS, you are ignoring the fact that Iran is modern industrial nation that has been preparing for a US attack for over 35 years - They are armed to the teeth. BTW - Even with all the WMDs provided by the US, Iraq could not defeat Iran and Iran is 100X stronger today. So if you are so sure that you will not get your head handed to you, DO FOR IT - What are you waiting for?
Next talkbacks
Back to article