News
MK: Jewish prayer in Temple Mount will lead to Intifada
Kobi Nachshoni
Published: 04.11.13, 15:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why do Arab MKs
Chris L. ,   USA   (11.04.13)
Speak of us, (arabs) and them (israelis) as them? Are you not part of Israel society? Why allow these people a platform within your govts society if they clearly see jews as the core of all their problems. The ones who are fascist and racist are these Arab MKs for not allowing another people worship in their rightful place.
2. There is one obvious solution
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.04.13)
Bar all Muslims from the Temple Mount. If they can't behave as human beings then they must not be allowed to harm others
3. then we must crush it and you, once and for all.
ralph   (11.04.13)
4. Only option is compensated forced
Barney ,   USA   (11.04.13)
Transfer. Any moron can see nothing will ever work with the Arabs. Bite the bullet and round em up and move em out.
5. Bring it on
Ezra ,   San Diego   (11.04.13)
There are many battles being fought by the gentiles all over the world. None are worth getting involved with on this level. It's easy for me to say bring it on, because I don't live there, but if I did, I would be saying the same thing. Once could argue there is enough room for Edom and Jacob, but there can never be a lasting peace with Edom, because is Jewish requests for a peaceful coexistence are being ignored. The presence of Jews on the Jewish Temple Mount is inevitable: When the decedents of Jacob rise, Edom will fall, and the older shall serve the younger. Bring it on. King David killed Goliath because the decedents of Edom wanted to enslave the Kingdom of Israel. The same is true here, Bring it on.
6. I consider myself a leftist
Ethan ,   Eilat   (11.04.13)
If they can't respect us, bring on the Intifada and let Allah sort them out.
7. Arab Chutzpa
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (11.04.13)
The Temple Mount is Jewish. The Arabs usurped it in our absence. Delegitimizing our rights to the holiest place for Jews is a spit in our face, and an insult to our religion. As long as the Arabs are delusional about the Jewishness of the Temple Mount and all of Jerusalem, we will never have peace with them. Ultimately, they will be thrown off the hill and the Third Temple will be built there. This is a promise from G-d.
8. My compromise life over death
Avramele   (11.04.13)
As part of the negotiated settlement, a 40 year ban on Jewish rituals on the temple mount in exchange for a 40 year Israeli security presence in the Jordan valley. I will take national security over the temple cult any day. With 40 years of peace and hopefully greater freedom and prosperity for all future generations can then try and come up with a better plan. In the interim there will be no more deaths over that piece of rock.
9. Man's idiocy knows no bounds
Sagi   (11.04.13)
He is prepared to fight, kill and die over stones and his right to pray to a figment of his imagination. I say this in respect of both Muslims and Jews but I must add that it is particularly disagreeable that the Muslims believe that they are the only ones with rights, others be damned.
10. Third intafada
LION OF JUDAH ,   JUDAH THE LION   (11.04.13)
These Arabs are making threats if Israel do this or that , they will start third intifada, and it seems this threat is working for them and they are getting encouraged. During Ben Gurion time the Arabs would not dare to open their mouth because Ben Gurion will slap them very hard. Now the time came that Israel should slap them very hard indeed. Let them bring the third intifada. Should they carry with their threat Israel should use full force with very extreme heavy handed and it does not matter if 1000 + gets killed in one day. This will teach the Arabs do not start intifada. You start, you will get killed. Screw world opinion. Whatever Israel will do rightly or wrongly, Jews are wrong.\ Do not fear intifada bring it on !!!!!!
11. As an extreme secularist I say:Islam must be eradicated from
tom ,   tel aviv   (11.04.13)
the Temple Mount once and for all. There's no compromise and prolonged existence of this gangrenous edifice (Al Aqsa, Dome of Rock) will bring only more suffering to all sides.
12. THERE IS ONLY HAR HABAYIT
hadad ,   Israel   (11.04.13)
13. It's no big deal
Susan Kravitz ,   Hillendale, Ca.   (11.04.13)
These are not Jews(no pun). what Supreme Being are they supposed to be praying too.? All, if not everything that they do "breaks the PEACE.,,,, I do know G-d does hate "PEACE BREAKERS". The course/curse of this psychosis is reaching it's end, this is going to be very interesting. If these peoples were really Jews, what all powerful G-d would stop them from praying at their most revered cite/sight. If these peoples were "worthy", what all powerful G-d would stop them from,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, "Praying at a Wall", surely this is an abomination, "Jews smartest peoples in the world, praying to a damn wall.
14. Zevulen Orlev?!?!?
ari ,   jerusalem, israel   (11.04.13)
HE isn't even an MK... Horrible reporting
15. Temple mount
steve ,   USA   (11.04.13)
The attitude of the Arab MK proves clearly that we have NO PARTNER for peace - they think they can re write history? there is no AL Aqsa - they stole it from us Jews. The sooner we have the courage to rid ourselves of these murderers the better for us. Wake Up Stupid Leftists the Arabs want to kill us all
16. Praying AT the Wall
Wade ,   NYC USA   (11.04.13)
not praying TO the Wall. Don't hold Hashem responsible for the misdeeds of evil people.
17. Virtual Jewish Jerusalem
Wade ,   NYC USA   (11.04.13)
Tibi et al. are in denial- no Temple Mount, no Jewish history, no King Solomon or King David. It's just bluster to preserve a very unfair status quo. They will have no choice but to co-exist. No way Israel should back down from equal religious rights in Israel's eternal holiest city.
18. Why are you asking Arabs for permission (again) (and again)?
Bastile ,   Israel   (11.04.13)
Just pass the law and enforce it. If they don't like it TOUGH. Democracy is democracy.
19. Build temple
olavi ,   espoo, finland   (11.04.13)
Israel should build the temple on temple mount. Mosque was erected later and should be removed to Saudi Arabia, with the palestinian population.
20. Islams 3rd holiest site compared to Judaism's most holy site
Arnold ,   Montreal-Canada   (11.04.13)
We Jews are barred from even entering the Kingdoms of Mecca and Medina though Jews lived there for thousands of years in ancient times. We Jews understand this and respect the Saudi ban and out of this Islam claims them as their two holiest sites. That does not give Islam the right to disallow Jews from praying at their most holy site. I am surprised that the Christian world does not see this and does not back Israel in their demand of religious right to their holiest even though the Jews are ready to share the site. This is but a microcosm example of the problem of Arabs and Muslims not willing to share the world and its parts.
21. The rebellious Arab MKs always have
The real truth   (11.04.13)
the chance of resigning their positions, renouncing their posh lives and leaving for Gaza. There, they can express opinion which is being dictated to them. Make no confusion, they cannot do it two ways, enjoy their free and plentiful lives and at the same time bite the feeding hand. The Temple Mount was, is and will always be ONLY Jewish.
22. If it
PaulD ,   Jerusalem   (11.04.13)
smells like a racist, speaks like a racist, and threatens violence, you can be sure it is an Arab.
23. Time to send in . . .
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (11.04.13)
There is only one way to deal with the Temple Mount. We must send in people who believe they have the right to pray anywhere they want, any time any way, any how and with whomever they choose. Who could fill that bill? Send in the WoW .
24. Al aqsa IS the third temple
joe ,   saudi   (11.04.13)
The religion of God changed from Judaism to Christainity and then to Islam in 3000 years. You welcome to pray in Al Aqsa as a muslim.
25. De-Construct Al Aqsa
ASTRONAUT ,   SC, USA   (11.04.13)
stone-by-stone and RE-construct your Holy of Holies in Mecca. A bie gezint.
26. such hateful and disrespectful arab MKs
David ,   Boston, USA   (11.04.13)
if citizens are like this, no wonder no peace with arab neighbors. Its a fact, the temple mount was built to house the Temples. It is Judaisms holiest area. If the Arab MKs cant respect it as such, there is no way to make peace with them. You may not like it, but respect its my holiest site. Jews didnt blow up the Dome. They could have. In fact this is the freest Jerusalem has ever been. Its time for the Muslims to respect other religions too. Jerusalem is the holiest Jewish city and the Temple Mount is the Holy of Holies. Respect our holy site. Zero change of peace until they do.
27. If we stand for our principles ...he's right !
Roland Seener ,   London England   (11.04.13)
28. Partners for peace?
Akiva ,   NYC   (11.04.13)
They use the site of Solomon's Temple for a soccer pitch and a picnic area, and then go crazy when we want to pray there according to an agreed map and timetable. Are these 'partners for peace'?
29. Joe # 24
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.04.13)
Who made you God's mouthpiece? The God of Israel and Christians isn't Allah. Muslims are welcome to pray in Mecca where they belong.
30. joe saudi
AL QUDS ALYAHUDI ,   Jerusalem Jewish   (11.04.13)
Al Aqsa is in Mecca & Medina as per your quran. The proof is in the pudding. You Islamic are uneducated and cannot count, how the hell Judaism changed to Islam, while your religion Islam is only 1400/1500 years old.. You can pray in Mecca but not in Jerusalem. Mecca/Medina is yours and Jerusalem is Jewish. Period.
Next talkbacks
Back to article