Opinion  Shimon Shiffer
Ya'alon is telling the painful truth
Shimon Shiffer
Published: 16.01.14, 01:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Article: Ya'alon is telling painful truth"
Ron Barack ,   New York, USA   (01.16.14)
Mr. Shiffer, submit this article to the op-ed page of the NYTimes, Washington Post and Wall Street Journal. One of these newspapers will publish it. The American public deserves to learn what your article conveys.
2. Manners and class do matter.
and so do you.   (01.16.14)
There is a place to voice your opinions and concerns. The DM demonstrated lack of class, grace, and judgement.
3. Peace
MSWE523 ,   LA, CA, USA   (01.16.14)
The more I read about the Obama/Kerry peace process the more I'm convinced it will never happen. Abbas, as was the case with Arafat, knows the moment he signs an agreement he is a deadman. Right now Israel and it's security forces in the West Bank are the only thing standing between Abbas and those who want him removed. Abbas will string Obsma/Kerry along as long as possible all the time painting Israel as the obstacle to peace.
4. Just say no
(01.16.14)
to Obama and Kerry. The American people will appreciate you more for it.
5. its good to see the news people jump on
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (01.16.14)
the bandwagon.
6. Yes, please!
sharpshin ,   USA   (01.16.14)
Tell America to take a hike. After all, you've still got Micronesia. Goodbye and good luck!
7. #6 Who does the US have?
Benji ,   US   (01.16.14)
Only Israel and Israel deserves more respect.
8. #2 class
(01.16.14)
Ya'alon spoke in a closed room to a few close associates. He did not expect a shtinker working for Obama would make a big deal. That said, Ya'alon should show more class, grace and judgement by taking a selfie with a beautiful blond during a funeral.
9. Thanx Shimon
Nick ,   Sweden   (01.16.14)
right on the mark, I couldn't have said it better. People like Ya'alon, who fought war for the existence of their country and saw countless of their friends perish for the same reason deserve to be listened to - as opposed to the incomprehensible stance of the diplomats from the late Land of the Free.
10. Ya'alon
Yve ,   London U.K.   (01.16.14)
I agree with every single word Minister Ya'alon had to say. It's refreshing to read a minister telling it as it is.
11. To Our BRAVE OUTSPOKEN Moshe
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (01.16.14)
We who live on the banks of the river Jordan need no reckless advice from those who live on the banks of the Potomac river.......I salute a man who was not only courageous in war and truthful in the "war of political correctness".........sadly the balance of our leadership is lacking in Mr. Ya'alon's qualities.........Am Yisroel Chai
12. moshe yaalon
baruch ,   gush etzion   (01.16.14)
shimon shiffer, good article,we must show our uncompromising support for our leaders who have the courage and independence to stand up toward outside international political pressures baruch
13. why is the voice of sober minds and the
aliza ,   israel   (01.16.14)
words of the naked truth have to end up in an unwarranted apology? are we bound to apologize forever for wanting to live in a country that does not have to face annihilation since the first day of its existence?
14. Yaalon spoke the truth
Ezer   (01.16.14)
If the 2 state solution is implemented, all of Israel will come under rocket fire and our lives will be a living hell. It will cause a major exodus out of here and Israel will be toast. Wish our leaders would have the guts to speak out loud the truth as Yaalon did.
15. "Peace talks with Palestinians" based on lies.
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.16.14)
I salute Yaalon for at least beginning to publicly expose the tissue of lies underlying the mendacious, phony "peace talks with Palestinians".
16. "Manners and Class do matter"
Alice ,   Israel/Canada   (01.16.14)
Mr. Ya'alon has the CLASS and COURAGE to voice his opinion and it's quite refreshing. On the other hand, you, you lack the basic courage to sign your own comment. Sad..
17. AND I STILL SAY....
les ,   canada   (01.16.14)
Ya'alon is 100%right! the "palestinian" (if there were such a thing) situation will be solved by force. you make "peace" with one faction, the other fire rockets on you, shoot at you, throw Molotov cocktails at children.
18. #2 class like ChiCom Ckerry
Da Nang ,   vietnam   (01.16.14)
and Viet Kong Kery who joined the navy for 3 months as a viet kong stooge to garner the worlds leftists media. To murder 3 million North Vietnamese and 57,000 Ameicans. Class. Like when a liberal farts.
19. Two Emporers Have no Clothes
i ,   jerusalem   (01.16.14)
Netanyahu, and Obama and his tool Kerry. Abbas isn't even in the parade.
20. Israel is fed up with being pushed to the sea
Nachman   (01.16.14)
The americans have to know that most israelis if given the chance to vote for Livni vs Yaalon the latter would win hands down. Israelis are sick and tired of american proposals like Oslo that only brought destruction and pain to so many living in Israel. Kerrey get this Life is worth more than your money.
21. Chaim, I begin ......
Luiz F Haddad ,   Búzios, Brazil   (01.17.14)
to agree with you. While Palestinian leaders don.t recognize Israel and claim absurd right of return, peace will be impossible. If the stalemate goes on, your State must defend itself by all necessary ways.
22. Did Obama ever say sorry to our PM?
Samuel ,   Israel   (01.17.14)
Sometime back Obama called our PM: pain in the.... along with former French Leader Sarcosy.Did any one of them appologize to our dear PM? For our Defence Minister the security of our tiny nation is top priority.
23. A knife in the back of one's own country?
Shalom Freedman ,   Jerusalem Israel   (01.17.14)
According to Yaalon he gave an off-the- record background briefing and Shimon Shiffer violated the rule of this, and created an embarassing situation for both Yaalon and Israel. Shiffer is probably right about the danger of Kerry's obsession. But he should have found another way of presenting what he thought without putting a knife in the back of his own country.
24. Telling the truth
RayS ,   NH, USA   (01.18.14)
Mr Shiffer is 100% correct. Not facing facts openly leads people to think you will in the end give in on them. The PM should say that there will be no negotiations on Jerusalem ,no withdrawal in the Jordan Valley, no troops in Judea or Samaria other than the IDF....Proclaiming the truth WILL keep Israel free and secure.
Back to article