News
Ex CIA head: Anti-Semitism likely in Pollard case
Associated Press
Published: 08.02.14, 23:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. Sotero is a sunni...
Beary White ,   Norway   (02.08.14)
..and by keeping Pollard in jail, it is his only key-card to get an apartment in Saudi, when his days as president has ended. Then, for the rest of his life, Sotero will continue to bow for the Saudi king, every day...and kiss his hand...
2. Of course ,...
split ,   US   (02.09.14)
What would you expect from ultra-neo-con artist. It wouldn't be the first time he sold his soul to zio-interest.
3. Miscarriages of justice
Akiva ,   New York   (02.08.14)
There have long been doubts about the role of anti-Semitism in the execution of the Rosenbergs. Pollard's treatment is inconsistent with all comparable cases of spying for an ally of America. The attempt to give Rabushkin a life sentence for bank fraud was dropped when a group of attorneys-general objected. There may be many factors in these miscarriages of justice, and anti-Semitism may well be one of those factors.
4. anti semitic
Sam ,   USA   (02.08.14)
How is this anti Semitic. Pillars was not Jewish to begin with. Plus a Semite is not just Jewish. It is any of the languages that are spoken in the middle east.
5. Pollard should have eaten a kosher or vegetarian diet in pri
Rivkah   (02.08.14)
prison so he wouldn't have gained so much weight and gotten diabetes. Now he won't have much of a life if he is released. But it will be exciting to see which wife Israel supports will get him or if one of his wives will lose support when he is released.
6. Don't worry, John, you'll be in Israel soon.
milwaukeebroad ,   Haifa, Israel   (02.09.14)
Just wait for the signs in the heavens beginning April 15th. The Americans will have no choice when they realize what'll happen and why.
7. Good idea
sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (02.09.14)
Nothing else worked, it's time to play the anti-Semitic card. Why is Israel so obsessed with an American citizen that was employed by the US Navy, Is it because of his religion? Well news for you Israeli's, the American people and government separates religion from State, so Pollard will finish his sentence.
8. Is antiSemitism part of Vanunu indefinite incarceration?
lydia ,   Brisbane   (02.09.14)
Pollard an American who sold American secrets resulting in the deaths of 00s of US undercover agents must rot in Jail
9. Anti Semitism
Bill Stein ,   USA   (02.09.14)
Has been part of CIA culture for years both in hiring and promotion. It could very well part of the issue
10. Weinberger was a known anti-Semitic
Sidney ,   USA   (02.09.14)
Remember that Pollard was sentenced on the basis of secret testimony by Caspar Weinberger before the judge with no defense attorney present. The whole thing was an affront to the American system of justice. Caspar Weinberger subsequently needed a presidential pardon to stay out of prison. Since Obama has neither cajones nor a sense of justice, it will take enormous pressure for him to do the right thing.
11. He served enough. Let him go.
Jim ,   New York   (02.09.14)
12. I can give you his release date
mea   (02.09.14)
Pollard will be released when he makes the commitment to not share what he knows, that is the deal. He has zero intention of keeping his mouth shut--and soooo, just as Israel contains Vanunu, America does the same with Pollard. Of course non eof this fits the need to fashion heros from sows ears.
13. no anti-Semitism at all here
Charlie Hall ,   Bronx, NY USA   (02.09.14)
He is delusional. Pollard's sentence is the same as that given to John Walker, and shorter than that given to Jerry Whitworth, Aldrich Ames, Robert Hanssen, and of course Julius and Ethel Rosenberg. Pollard is still in prison because of his actions and lack of actions, and for no other reason.
14. #4 don't play dumb
(02.09.14)
"Antisemitism (also spelled anti-semitism or anti-Semitism) is prejudice, hatred of, or discrimination against Jews for reasons connected to their Jewish heritage"
15. #8
Daddyo ,   Philly, USA   (02.09.14)
Ludicrous Lydia with another pusillanimous posting. Please provide documentary evidence to prove your claim that the info that Pollard passed to Israel resulted in any American deaths, let alone the dozens (or, is it hundreds?) that you claim.
16. We Have To Trade Pollard.
A Simple Jew ,   Maale Adumim   (02.09.14)
Pollard is a hostage. There is no mercy from Obama. We should have exchanged him for the first prisoner release. We should publicly announce; No Pollard on Ben Gurion; We freeze the Peace Process. This is a win win for Israel; Either we get Pollard, or we get rid of Kerry.
17. Stating the obvious...this says a lot about
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.09.14)
Israels great allly.
18. Why is everyone still on about this?
Dean Concannon ,   Sydney, Australia   (02.09.14)
Get over it folks - Pollard sold out his country for money, not for reasons of promoting Israel, or the Jewish cause or any other admirable end. He should be considered by the US in the same way as Vanunu is by Israel - irredeemable and dangerous if let loose. If anything, his sentence should be elongated. At least he's doing better than the Rosenbergs did - he's still alive.
19. I used to be an adovocate of Pollard
JewishHeart ,   Israel   (02.09.14)
Until I found out he gave information to Pakistan and Australia. He is no Zionist, he was an oppurtunist. Pakistan and Australia proves it. Let him rot in jail. I say this as someone who voted Naftali Bennet and is right wing.
20. it is obious that it is antisemitism
CJK   (02.09.14)
it is obvious that pollard has been incarcerated in prison for nearly thirty years because he is a jew. do not expect obama to release him.
21. UNBELIEVABLE!!!
michal weizmann ,   safed, ISRAEL   (02.09.14)
Anti_Semitism involved in Pollard's detention??? Oh r-e-a-l-l-y........... Now tell us something we don't know. Like all the "secrets" he passed on were owed to Israel anyhow.
22. Without a doubt.
Ezra ,   SanDiegoUSA   (02.09.14)
Someone in Washington hates the idea of the Jewish nation having something over the gentiles. There's no reason for him to be in jail anymore. The NSA and Snowden have already eclipsed anything he did.
23. Replace Pollard with his handlers.
Avi ,   NYC, USA   (02.09.14)
I am sure that the US would be happy to accept a deal where Pollard is released in return to the extradition of his handlers. Are the self important Mossad clowns willing to turn themselves in for the sake of their beloved brother Pollard? What about the Jewish solidarity? So...no solidarity among thieves?
24. You'll get your martyr-hero in a damn box
Cameron ,   USA   (02.09.14)
25. If it were not tragic, I'd smile..
AVouskila ,   South America   (02.09.14)
But it is tragic for Pollard, his family and the Israel-Us relationship. Lets not try to create a "crazy" narrative to this episode. As a Moroccan Jew I was very much accepting the idea that Mordecai Wanunou was guilty. We didn't cry that it was an "Anti-Sephardic gesture " for his sentence. However, no one in the so-called human rights activists pursued the Israeli government to let Wanunou carry on living as any Israeli subject at the term of his prison time, and be a productive human being, where it would choose to be. The funny side is that Woolsey didn't call upon W. Bush or Clinton, to commute or to release Pollard. Both situations carry the same tragic human waiste. Lets not ride the Anti-semitic locomotive in this case. That'll jeoperdise claims in more serious matters dear to Judaism.
26. If Sotero wants to exchange Pollard..
Beary White ,   Norway   (02.09.14)
..for 1000 pal terrorists in Israeli jails, then we know for sure which cult he belongs to...
27. #14 most likely #4 is not playing dumb, he just is!
Jerome ,   Basalt, Colorado   (02.09.14)
28. #10
Leonard ,   Green River, U.S.A.   (02.09.14)
Virtually every letter here is the usual back & forth, pros & cons, but only #10 hit the nail on the head. Weinberger was for all intents and purposes was the oil industry's man in the Reagan administration. He was also the SecDef who talked Reagan out of retaliating against the terrorists who killed 220 marines in Beirut. History will prove him to be the real traitor.
29. to 7
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (02.25.14)
"Nothing else worked.." Name one "thing", Pollard used for his defense, rattle... During all of his trial, Jonathan Pollard, has never brought up or used his nationality or religion... And as a matter of fact, his trial did demonstrate a huge component of antisemitism... But you need not learn the facts of this case..Your wishful thinking is your moral and factual compass, sheik rattle......
30. #5 Rivkah - learn before posting.
CDG ,   Yerushalayim   (03.04.14)
Jonathan Pollard's diet is not the problem. Even vegetarians (which he has been forced to be, for years now - they won't give him kosher food!) get diabetes. Fruit and vegetables have sugar and other carbs in them, and precious little protein. Stress, however, is the more likely reason for his illness and overweight. And you (not to mention many others) are not helping with your comments!
Back to article