Opinion
Israel is not alone, has an abiding friend in Germany
Frank-Walter Steinmeier
Published: 24.02.14, 08:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Dear Mr. Steinmeier
Arie Ruder ,   Ashkelon, Israel   (02.24.14)
Your sentiment towards the state of Israel is truly appreciated. It should also be mentioned that bilateral disagreements are part of any diplomatic/political arena, including the one between Israel and Germany. But there is one sentence in your Op-Ed that has to be addressed: "Germany and Europe are important partners that act decisively for Israel's legitimization and its right of existence." The sentence implies almost directly that there are states, nations and people who delegitimize Israel and drive to stop its existence. I am sure that you would agree that the priority is to expose and stop these entities by using the strongest means available before asking Israel to make any "...hard... decisions". This, Mr. Steinmeier, is a gross anomaly and highlights the fact that the heart-of the matter is not truly addressed. While any other state in the world receives "legitimization and its right of existence" as natural rights, Israel on the other hand has to make hard decisions to reach such straightforward status. Why?
2. Blah blah Germany gave all the material for nuclear Iran
(02.24.14)
3. playing on the holocaust
Yeoshua F. ,   N.Y   (02.24.14)
Israel´s ¨Hasbara¨ policy in Europe consists of 3 unwritten rules : 1. The holocaust gives us a moral free pass to do as we please. 2. Since the holocaust happened in Europe and you are to blame, you have no right to criticize us. 3. Criticizm of Israel equals antisemitism. Anytime a European official legitimately criticizes or even questions Israel´s actions, he is immediately showered by automatic ¨antisemitism¨ remarks from Israeli officials. Regardless of the content of his criticism. It´s not as if Israelis really feel offended by criticism, it´s just easier and more convenient to brush off critics by using the antisemitism card. It´s a trick. Any European who questions Israel´s policies in the the West bank and Gaza or even dares to show compassion to the people suffering there is an ¨antisemite¨ in the eyes of the Israeli government. However. the past few years have seen a massive change in the way Israel is perceived in Europe. Europeans, in key positions or not, have begun to realize that they´re being tricked and lied to. The trick is beginning to crumble as Europeans shake off the fear of being labeled as something they are clearly not. That is rapidly bringing on action from governments accordingly. No people, not even the Jews, are exempt from human and moral values.
4. Sir, does that mean that Israel is allowed to
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (02.24.14)
compalin to you when you build in Berlin? What are your rights in building in Berlin?
5. If only all leaders cared as much about their troops and peo
Rivkah   (02.24.14)
people as Angela Merkel does, it would be a better world. She won't let her troops get vaccines with toxic adjuvants and Baxter Labs has to make special batches that are safer for Angel Merkel's troops. Other leaders allow the vaccine genocide of their nations.
6. What this article shows, is that Israel is
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (02.24.14)
more alone than ever in the face of oppression and pure evil
7. #3 Yeoshiva
Darren Ben John ,   Townsville Australia   (02.24.14)
Well said! I have been saying similar for years, and at last people are waking up to the facts of Israel's barbaric treatment of people who can not fight back with anything more than skyrockets and the odd hand gun. Israel was good with the smoke and mirrors, but all will be exposed soon enough.
8. #4
Darren Ben John ,   Townsville Australia   (02.24.14)
Isreal steals land and water or bulldozes the home that is on the land and then buids ghettos and berlin walls. There is a big difference to what goes on in Berlin-everything is paid for and is legal.
9. Germany must restore the 3000 year name of Samaria
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (02.24.14)
'West Bank' is an antisemitic premise created in 1949 that seeks the demise of Israel. Germany well understands such deeds.
10. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.24.14)
Do you understand that this man's country was responsible for the massacre of one-third of the Jewish population of the world? One-third. Do you understand that that is a stain which NOTHING will ever erase?
11. To: No. 5
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.24.14)
And your comment has to do precisely WHAT with the content of the news article?
12. My reality check just bounced
Abu Zibby ,   Haifa, IL   (02.24.14)
The harsh realities in the middle east have proven again and again that Israel does not just stand alone in times of crisis but also has to defend herself against outrageous accusations by our European "friends". Steinmeier is a spook and therefore he has enough data to reach his own personal conclusions but he'll be able to change the decline of relations between Europe and Israel. The Palestinans are just a cover up - there will always be animosity towards Israel because of her mere existence.
13. To: No. 10
Daniel   (02.24.14)
Do you understand that this man was born in 1956? The Shoah was an enormous crime, but do you understand that this man was born more than 10 years after it. Do you understand that guilt is not inherited and that kids are not put in jail for what ancestors have done. Do you understand that this man is no more guilty of the Shoah than you or I are?
15. #10 ,...
split ,   US   (02.24.14)
Counting the 'great leap forward' in China, holodomor in Ukraine and gulag victims in Soviet Union your homies are responsible for ten times (10x) as much as nazis are ,...
16. Germany is a good friend to have
Shachar ,   Eilat   (02.25.14)
Germany is by far the most important country in Europe and their support is worth billions for Israel. To all the holocaust moaners, there is no greater victory than turning a country of virulent anti-semitism into a close and trusted friend!
17. ***Sarah*** at 10, You are 100 % right !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.25.14)
18. Steinmeier...you are meddling into Israels
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.25.14)
affaires, you are trying to split up the land of the Jews...YOU are NOT Israels friend !
19. Steinmeier...Israel NEVER criticized Germany,
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.25.14)
HOW DO YOU DARE, TO CRITICIZE ISRAEL ???!!!
Back to article