News
Ya'alon: Israel can't rely on US on Iran
Associated Press
Published: 18.03.14, 12:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. Confront Iran
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.18.14)
Ask the Iranians why they need a heavy water reactor, such as the one at Arak, if they only wish to pursue nuclear power for purposes of energy generation and medical isotopes. Those purposes do not require enrichment to the degree that a heavy water reactor is geared to achieve. Moreover, heavy water reactors are much more expensive to operate and maintain -- all this while Iran has been crying poor to the rest of the world, and its unemployment and inflation rates are staggering. Simply put, heavy water reactors are needed to achieve weapons-grade enrichment. They are expensive to operate and require high levels of maintenance. Why does Iran need a heavy water reactor if, as it claims, it wishes to enrich only to the levels required for energy generation and nuclear medicine? The answer: Iran's nuclear program is oriented towards weapons production. Spin that, if you will.
2. I have "two tracks", 1..deceptive, 2..delusional, in asylum
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.18.14)
3. Jews-wake up to reality
hy   (03.18.14)
It is not enough that hitler was not stopped by a france and britain until the russians, americans and canadians and jews took it on the chin to stop and kill him. among israelis you have the delusionists, the weak hearted and cowardly fearful jews who say let us rely on the US.well you see how solid US assurances are helping Ukraine along with the empty bluster of kerry who is pathetic and obama whose has no skin in the game when it comes to europe, Israel or russia. he is more comfortable with moslems and arabs. So Israel can forget about him. Cheif among the jews harming israel is Peres who continues to whitewash abbas. Next is herzog and gal on and you could not get poorer judge of character with no understanding of defensible borders and no understanding of arabs, zero, nothing. yaalon has hit the mark right on. General allen's jordan valley plan is garbage and crap. International custodianship of holy sites is garbage. \ the status quo is the best current arrangement though israel should annex the west bank formally and quit playing games. Likud should also move to kick bibi aside with his lousy ehud barak formulations and vote in yair shamir or someone else.
4. Israel has the ultimative tools.
Albrecht ,   EU   (03.18.14)
...and comes out as the ultimative warmonger.
5. Good for the General, he needs to reveal the whole picture
Dror ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.18.14)
Saudi Arabia openly admits they have purchased nuclear weapons from Pakistan. Iran has crude nuclear weapons and they have had them for some time now... most likely from North Korea. Israel needs to be wary of the Iranians, but we must not allow ourselves to get played by the Saudis, The bloody English, and the Americans working in concert to try to isolate us into a position of desperation. We must inform our public on Prince Bandar's open comments regarding his desire for Israel to strike Iran to protect the Saudi Royal families' grip on the peninsula. We must become more savvy about the Shia/Sunni conflict raging in the mid east. Finally, in a few words.. WE MUST NOT BE SUCKERS TO ANY FOREIGN NATIONS INTERESTS.
6. he' soooo right ! THEN NOW WE MUST ACT AGAINST IRAN
(03.18.14)
7. Yaalon is absolutely right
Brod ,   USA   (03.18.14)
The problem is Obama the Islamist is in bed with the fanatical Muslim Brotherhood-Terrorist Organization. He is bad for America, Israel and the Free World. Congress should impeach him which is a popular move in America.
8. And the CIA's Iran desk is in disarray
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (03.18.14)
It was announced just this week that the head of the CIA's Iran desk, who'd earlier served in Pakistan, was put on paid administrative leave given the "open rebellion" by its personnel against their chief of operations, Jonathan Bank. Keep in mind that US assurances to Israel include the claim that the US keeps such close tabs on Iran they'd know if Iran took the final decision to build nukes. Given the disarray among those primarily tasked with intelligence on Iran, Israel can't rely on anything that comes from that group.
9. USA's "senses" at this time are anti-American and pro Islam.
tom ,   tel aviv   (03.18.14)
Hussein Obama still has plenty of time to fulfill his plan of neutering USA. At the present rate of deterioration in 10 years it will resemble Mexico!
10. What a funny guy!
sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (03.18.14)
This comes from a defense minister that allows terrorist to launch missiles at his cities with almost impunity. Of course he would want the US to take the lead and strike Iran knowing he doesn't have the stomach or balls to fight. It is amazing how the State of Israel treats missile attacks from Gaza like bad weather that will pass. Look at Hezbollah massing tens of thousands of missiles on Israel's borders. Now that's shows real strength to allow that to happen.
11. may be true- but the less said and the more done, the better
Rafi ,   US   (03.18.14)
12. Israel can never rely on foreign powers for her security
CJK   (03.18.14)
israel must always be prepared to defend herself and exercise her national security alone. the essence of the sovereign jewish state of israel is her ability to defend the jewish nation by herself against all enemies, regardless of the difficulty of the task.
13. I love you Israel,
Erin ,   USA   (03.18.14)
I just wanted to say that today, and I also wanted to say that I love Muslims because Father loves them for loving only One God; Him. I know that sounds crazy to see those two in the same sentence but it's how I feel- from one heart to another that's how I feel and if I offend or hurt anyone's feelings, I am really, truly sorry- I know there has been a lot of bloodshed, but I love you both anyway.amen
14. US under Bathouse Barry is as worthless as the day is long
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.18.14)
15. somebody has seen the light
Rob ,   lost in farmington   (03.18.14)
It's about time somebody has seen the light , for what America is all about. Obama has sold out America. You don't think he won't sell out Israel. ye Right ? in a new york minute.
16. Hard to argue against Yaalon's logic
Memphis Slim ,   memphis, TN - USA   (03.18.14)
The West IS crumbling due to Obama's lack of backbone. NATO is falling apart under the pressure of what to do if Russia invades the other Baltic states. Israel on Iran: Do what you must because NO ONE has your back Israel on Palestinians: Abbas is an unelected USA backed puppet who doesn't represents anyone in the West bank, Gaza or the Pals diaspora AND US security guarantees are meaningless, after all, the USA guaranteed Ukraine's sovereignty when they gave up their nuclear weapons and now Obama is hiding under his desk.
17. Israel can rely on itself.
Kolboynik ,   Baltimore, MD   (03.18.14)
Look how USA handles anything. Crimea, Maidan,etc... Obama screws everything up. USA doesnt have a proper leader to lead USA, how will he be able to handle anything else????
18. No Country Should Be Relying On The US For ANYTHING!
David H ,   Marietta, USA   (03.18.14)
Only an American Liberal, living in a dream world could ever put any faith in the word of the United States these days. We do not support allies, we give aid and comfort to both American and our "allies" enemies, be it Iran, Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela. Until the current American regime is gone, buried, and forgotten, you can only trust your own government. Bye-Bye Miss American Pie...
19. Who is he fooling? Israel is powerless!
David   (03.18.14)
True, Israel is a regional power. But it has no power vs Iran. If it could bomb Iran it would have done so years ago. The U.S. has withheld the big bunker buster bombs capable of getting to Fordow's inner core where the centrifuges are spinning. Furthermore, as people forget, an attack on Iran is not just a bombing campaign. Iran will retaliate in the Persian Gulf. And what can Israel's navy do there? Israel's navy is a laughable joke. Only the U.S. can secure the sea lanes, so Israel knows that if it attacks Iran without American disapproval, it can kiss the "special relationship"(funded by AIPAC) goodbye. Is Yaalon right that Israel can't outsource its security to other countries, including America? Yes, he is. But does he have any realistic option to stopping Iran on Israel's own volition? Of course not. He is a powerless figure, along with Israel's military, to stop Iran. And that's not something that's good. A nuclear Iran is bad for everyone except them.
20. Spot On! How will you follow up???
Son of Cyrus ,   UK   (03.18.14)
21. To: No. 10
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.18.14)
That's because the United States and/or NATO can bomb Afghani and Iraqi civilians until the cows come home -- killing several million in the process -- but if Israel launches a retaliatory strike and kills one terrorist and two cats, it's an international crisis, replete with demands for a United Nations investigation and a war crimes trial. That's why. Terrorists operate from civilian areas. Of course, should the need arise, we'll do what we have to do to ensure our existence -- which may result in a high body count among our foes. I'll tell everyone you said it's okay.
22. Not under the current administration...
Koose E Mack ,   NY USA   (03.18.14)
We need some sane Right Wing Republicans in the WH, Congress, and Senate. Repeal Obama's Health Care Fiasco and set foreign policy back on the correct course.
23. #14, is mine. I wholeheartedly approve the comment.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.18.14)
24. Even my dog knows Iran nuke program will bite the dust
David   (03.18.14)
He even knows that sad sack Obama will come in for "mop up" only to save face.
25. #19, Correct and more, Israel knows suicide is very bad.
Michael ,   California, USA   (03.18.14)
26. #13: Thank you Erin
Israeli 2   (03.18.14)
That's real good and nice of you to write so lovingly...but DADDY has already judged the Muslims and chosen (favored) us Jews - the children of Jacob.
27. #22, Like the Israeli H-care, Obamacare will be grt success.
Michael ,   California, USA   (03.18.14)
You want Right Wing Republicans in the White House? Even if you get this nonsense dream fulfilled by some terrible mistake, the Republicans will not touch the new Health Care plan which Americans are learning to love and are signing up for it in great numbers. Now for the real question if you can reply from your ostrich sand hole: what does Obamacare have to do with Israel and Iran? Do you realize that Israeli General Ya'alon is not a right wing Republican?
28. #21, Sarah B , adopting my short choppy style, no hate, I
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.18.14)
...like it. Call me. 2, 14, not mine.
29. Make my day, bomb Iran, start WWIII, end the "Jewish State"
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.18.14)
...forever. 2,14, not mine.
30. # 22 Hopefully the mid term election will take power from
BUILD BABY BUILD   (03.18.14)
oy bama. KEEP BUILDING !!!! Make obama irrelevant.
Next talkbacks
Back to article