Jewish Scene
Russian state TV host: Jews brought on Holocaust
jn1.tv
Published: 25.03.14, 15:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
1. No surprise
Amichai ,   Huntsville, US   (03.25.14)
This should be no surprise. Prophecy clearly states that Russia will be an enemy of Israel in the last days.
2. Jews "flying too close to the sun" tragic examples of hubris
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.25.14)
...throughout history, myth, from Moses in Egypt, to Esther in Persia, to Romans, to Germany where less than 1% Jews, held over 20% of German wealth, and power, at end of first world war. And today, European Jews are invading Arab world, making enemies of a billion Muslims.
3. Shoah
Jarvis ,   Joseph USA   (03.25.14)
I see Christians fighting themselves in Ukraine why do they blame this phenomena on the Jews? I don't see very many Jews with an opinion on the Ukrainian matter because its simply not the Jewish fight. I speak to you on the left that seek to rest under the wings of Vladimir Putin! You have no ally in him. Remember ye are a synagogue of satan' unto them who's god can not live with out satan. The Lord is The Lord!
4. Henry-Levi?
msh ,   Haifa   (03.25.14)
I don't get it: he pushed for France intevention in Lybia only to be denied entry to this country by the same islamo-fascist rebels he suppoted, now he blesses Maidan only to be called some time late 'parhaty jid' by the same Maidan anti-semites? How impulsive can one get?
5. When the Jews burn so does everybody else....
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.25.14)
And in much more inflated numbers.... Historical fact.
6. 2 those one % , contributed MORE to mankind
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.25.14)
than the 99 other % . Here some names , without any research , Einstein , Heine , Landsteiner , Ballin , Haber , Frank , and so on .
7. no. 2 - Hatemongering/racism comes from your mother's womb
(03.25.14)
8. # 6 - Keep going ;) ,...
split ,   US   (03.25.14)
Trotsky, Zinoviev, Kamenev, the fouding fathers of Soviet commie system, Kaganowich, Yagoda responsible for 8-10 million starved to death Ukrainians during one winter 1932/33, Matvei Berman and Naftaly Frenkel, founders of Gulag labor camp system with their buddy Lev Inzhir a commissar of Soviet Gulag camps transit and administration, Firin, Rappoport, Kogan, Zhuk, commissars of camps and slave labor that supervised the construction of the Belomorsk Canal and other projects responsible for at least another 30 million worked/starved to death "enemies" of the revolution or Béla Kun (Béla Kohn) a Jewish commie with the help of Soviets established Hungarian Soviet Republic, Béla Kun (Béla Kohn) a Jewish commie with the help of Soviets established Hungarian Soviet Republic, Communist terror machinery was ruled by Matyas Rakosi, Ernest Gero, Michael Farkas and Joseph Revai. The AVH, a Hungarian equivalent of the NKVD (KGB) the bloodiest enterprise ever created, was headed by Gabor Peter also a Jew. Their departments were staffed by their fellow trusted Jews creating a situation that eventually lead to an uprising and national tragedy in '56. comrade Sidney Rittenberg, a Great Leap Forward in China founding father Mao's adviser in charge of implementation of that evil plan responsible for 45 million starved to death Chinese during collectivization, Sidney Shapiro, a member of the CPPCC National Committee for six terms, Israel Epstein, Solomon Adler, Martin Sorrell, Adolf Abramovitch Joffe for Mao's 'cultural revolution - Communism, Kolyma, Gulags, Holodomor and on, and on and on ,...
9. #2 Jews are still here, where are all those ancient empires?
Jake   (03.25.14)
I wouldn't worry about the Jews and their "hubris". Worry about the fate of your own country, lest it follow in the path of that long line of now defunct empires.
10. anyone who has something to say
liza ,   haifa, israel   (03.25.14)
about the holocaust being real or not ought to try it for him/herself.
11. Beggars Belief!
Tim ,   Brighton   (03.25.14)
Are these the sorts of people emerging out of the woodwork of Putins Pandoras Box? Quite shameful and disgraceful
12. To number 2
Pinky Lee ,   Miami USA   (03.25.14)
Too close to the sun? More like too close to the garbage dump.
13. #2 If The Richest 1% in germany Were Jewish
(03.25.14)
That is Further Supported By The Number Nobel Prize Winner who Are JEWISH, Ha Shems Chosen Shine As They Should, is because we're are Superior??? Yep we superior In Moraes, Culture, Businees Finance, Shall I Go On? Or do you get it? May Ha Shem Have Mercy on your Tourtured sole, that is if you have one!!!
14. If she were a man
steve from raleigh   (03.25.14)
Max Blumenthal would ask to marry him.
15. #6, All Europeans.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.25.14)
16. #6 No Einstein, No Heine...
Albrecht ,   EU   (03.25.14)
...without German culture and German nation.
17. 2 Benassi You have it all wrong
robert ,   Antwerpen (2018)   (03.25.14)
People as a rule with some exceptions dislike minorities , wether rich or poor, powerfull or powerless because they are different. The Germans tried to exterminate the gipsies who didn't own much and the mentally disabled and so on. The Arab world hates the small Jewish state because it's a minority in a sea of moslems. They destroyed the crusaders kingdoms in the middle age for the same reason . Because they don't have the same faith and are still busy at it in many Arab countries. If we, as Jews, are guilty of anything , it is of a lack of unity.
18. #13 In other words:
(03.25.14)
Jews controlled Germany. So you think the Nazis were right? I really do hope you're not Jewish.
19. To choose between Russia and Ukraine is pathetic.
Ira G.   (03.25.14)
First the Russians and then the Ukrainians allied with the Nazis. They are both the epicenter of antisemitism on planet earth. May they fight each other to the death. I'll root for both sides.
20. #6 What has their contribution got to
(03.25.14)
do with their Judaism? Did Haber learn his Chemistry out of the Torah? What did Jews from Yemen or Morocco contribute to mankind? Not much. Why is that so?
21. #16 - Einstein was socialized in pre-WW I Swizerland;  Heine with French
(03.25.14)
22. #2 "1% Jews, held over 20% of German wealth
(03.25.14)
and power, at end of first world war." Have you got a source for this claim?
23. Albrecht , No German culture without Einstein
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.25.14)
Heine and the many , many others
24. 8 , they acted as COMMUNISTS
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.25.14)
not as Jews .
25. #6 you put your foot in your mouth.
Jarvis ,   Joseph, USA   (03.26.14)
Much of this research produced terrible outcomes. Talk about the terrible things people do with this research. It is nothing. You got it backward. The Lord is the Lord.
26. #15, so when they're geniuses they're simply "Europeans"
Jake   (03.26.14)
But otherwise they're just "Jews". Very convenient.
27. #21 not important
(03.26.14)
change "German" into "European"
28. #22, Google "Jewish wealth in pre war Germany" then do math
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.26.14)
"Nearly 120 billion Reich marks – over £12 billion at the time – was plundered from German Jews by laws and looting...Conservatively, their money financed at least 30 per cent of the German war effort" Math... "Inflation calculator" from 1933 to 2012, multiply £12 billion by 357, for "Economic Power", equals £4.3 trillion today.
29. comment number 8 by split
(03.26.14)
Ynet is to be commended for publishing comments like #8 which other mainstream media would censor due to the uncomfortable nature of the facts involved.
30. 24, Einstein acted as SCIENTIST
(03.26.14)
not as a Jew. - same argument You, Charles, neither have to feel uneasy because of Kaganowich, nor proud because of Einstein, because your personal contribution to both of their actions is exactly zero. However, if you really can't resist identifying with other people just because they are Jews, then you'll have to accept that Einstein and Kaganowich come in one package and you'll have to take both. Everything else is cherry picking and always makes people look stupid.
Next talkbacks
Back to article