Jewish Scene
Tiles found in Treblinka confirm existence of gas chambers
Ynetnews
Published: 30.03.14, 20:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. 1
zionist forever   (03.31.14)
Of course millions of non Jews were killed during the Holocaust nobody has ever denied that. The thing about the Jews is they were the largest individual group targeted for mass extermination. How many bathhouses did they try and create for non Jewish victims? Other than groups like homosexuals and gypsies how many other non Jewish groups were specifically targeted?
32. Holocause Industry?
Maurice Solovitz ,   London, England   (03.31.14)
if you know anything at all about history then you will appreciate that the allied nations had a problem with the German plans for eastern Europe. The Nazis wanted to murder almost all the people living in the East but they were happy to use Eastern and Central European collaborators to do the dirty work in the first instance. The Americans (primarily) understood that the old model of revenge - retaliation - revenge would doom Europe to decades if not centuries of continued bloodshed if it demonstrated that the Shoah was not unique. In fact the early estimates were that 12 -13 million people died in the camps, ravines and forests not 6 million - there were 700,000 Serbians murdered by Croats. The list is long. Appreciate what happened after Yugoslavia broke up and then understand what America feared after 1945 if war crime trials were not limited and specific. Your obsession with attacking 'us' seems to be a problem. It is not always our fault - I happen to think that the American decision which Britain and France agreed to was the incorrect one because it allowed the Holocaust denial industry to take shape. But that is another argument. In any case the Jewish people had no choice in their 'martyrdom' post WW2 - the reason that other nations do not want their own martyrdom during the war made into an issue is an entirely other subject which again, has absolutely nothing to do with the Jews.
33. Suppressing negative news
Maurice Solovitz ,   London, England   (03.31.14)
In the early 1980's a curious atrocity took place somewhere on the outskirts of a big city. A group of bikers entered a diner and rounded up all the diners and then proceeded to 'have fun' with them. Violence, obscenity, mayhem ensured. A brother was forced to have 'simulated' sex with his sister. All this happened while the diners were vastly superior in number and could have overcome their oppressors if they had so endevoured to do so. Does this sound familiar? That one incident was reported in the news only very temporarily and then it simply disappeared from the national press. No interviews with social commentators or psychiatrists, no discussion - NOTHING. If we are being truthful nations don't like to discuss the fact that what happened in the Shoah could and did happen to any group. Being macho is no defense against a regime intent on genocide. The Germans understood that. So the Europeans did not censor the 'other Shoah' they were just afraid of the consequences for their national self-image, their legacy of hatred and revenge - now that is a subject that has not been approached - the what if scenario. What if the Americans had allowed justice to take its course and not simply focused on the Jewish tragedy of WW2?
34. 24 Comments from Split
Claude ,   UK and Cape Town   (03.31.14)
This obsession with the old canard of hatred towards Jews probably extends to other "less" desirable types, blacks, gays, Roma people. Split and similar posters would have made a wonderful beaurocrats in some old African Colony. Why not take a walk clearing minefields in Mozambique or Cambodia. Do something useful before its too late. When the time comes to exhume your corpse and examine the brain, maybe we will learn a little more about the minds of racists, anti semites and haters of humanity. I just wonder do these types get enough sex, they need an orgasm. But then who would want to be the participating partner.
35. dickhead @24
A ,   Belgium   (03.31.14)
"it's your conduct over the centuries" And how do you justify Christianities conduct...wars, oppression, murder, theft, etc, all in the name of Jesus...over the centuries, Kowalsky? Can you justify it as being correct and acceptable? Or do you only see Jews as being the villians of history, polakius ignoramius?
36. #29 - Too dim to find on your own? ,...
split ,   US   (03.31.14)
Google, "Happy Birthday, Mr. Kissinger" - Right from the Jewish horse's mouth or rather donkey ;) ,...
37. # 31 ,...
split ,   US   (03.31.14)
"how many other non Jewish groups were specifically targeted?" ,... Many, just during WWII - Elites, intelligentsia, potential leaders, activists by Germans and in addition to listed above military and police brass by Soviets, especially by your commie homies to make it easier to take it over after war. It was not limited to Poland but to all other nations designated for Soviet domination - Famous Katyn ring a bell? Other lesser places are still popping up here and there used for the same purpose and waiting for forensic assessment but how would you know ,... Crimean Tatars by Stalin's goons (read your homies) - By 1946 Crimea was cleared of Tatars to make room for Jewish settlers ,...
38. With thanks to Edward Lear
Claude ,   UK and Cape Town   (03.31.14)
There was an old poster called Split. Who's great joy in life was pressing submit. All alone in his trailer park. He fell prey to Shylock the loan shark. And that old poster called Split, Had no time to say oh S--T
39. #14 - Religious authorities are often called upon by the ,.
split ,   US   (03.31.14)
Not to forensic excavations at alleged mass murder or extermination sites - I know they did that in the middle of forensic excavations in Jedwabne (Poland) when numbers and forensic evidence not only didn't match the already sensationalised 'expectations' of those making living of so called 'Polish' antisemitism but when it turned against their BS they called a black hatted freak that started yelling 'gevalt' and the crap became a 'historical' (not histerical) fact - Anyone who dared to protest (including forensic experts working there) was tagged an antisemite ,...
40. #31, Slavs, Russians, see "Generalplan Ost" targeting 100M
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.31.14)
41. #5 and 8 ,...
split ,   US   (03.31.14)
If there was a Marsian that fell out of flying saucer in Israel and had an access to Jewish media he would never found out that others than Jews died in concentration camps or WWII ,... Arthur Koestler, a Hungarian Jew who lived in pre-Israel Palestine once described you as "a race of eternal victims with it's flayed skin and exposed nerves" and moved back to civilised world ,...
42. ky @ 17 - Try to read and process not interpret ,...
split ,   US   (03.31.14)
I don't challenge Ms. Colls' professionalism I just pointed out that those black hatted control freaks are exporting their dark age crap abroad and those gutless 'authorities' caved in - Even the damn commies had more pride and balls than the present a$$ kissing eunuchs ,...
43. 34 and 35
(03.31.14)
best responses to a brainless hog farmer polsky (split) i have ever read. good for you guys. keep up the good work and exposing liars and haters like polsky and herr hitler.
44. #27 Hiding behind Hitler, so pathetic split
Benji ,   US   (03.31.14)
And noteworthy, you can't respond to Charles with a link to your fake quote.
45. 24 , the illiterate criminal
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.31.14)
why were Jews , when expulsed from Spain , so welcomed in Turkey and Holland ? Not catholic countries then . Why were Jews who converted to Catholicism allowed to stay in Spain ? Why did the most murderous pogroms occur in Catholic countries ? And you dare to say that this persecution of Jews was NOT religiously motivated ! Why had you to flee your country ? Did the US immigration authorities know your TRUE past ?
46. 32
zionist forever   (03.31.14)
A Holocaust industry has developed. Its fashionable for big cities to have their own Holocaust museums. Israel has naturally milked the Holocaust for everything it can get to get things like cheap submarines from Germany or political concessions from other countries. Bad taste maybe but at the same time why not, we cannot bring back the dead but if we can use their sacrifice to bring benefits to Israel especially considering Israel was a state that was founded on the back of the Holocaust because whilst the zionist movement was 50-60 years old before 1948 its the Holocaust and the fact nobody wanted the Jewish refugees that tipped the balance.
47. #14 again ,...
split ,   US   (04.01.14)
Moslem leaders were and are still being consulted ,... Except at the site of Museum of Tolerance (sic) in Jerusalem ;) ,... Read the sentence again dickhead it's about giving PERMISSION not CONSULTING ,...
48. #36 No such quote you fraud
Benji ,   US   (04.01.14)
49. 45 - Check your 'facts' dimmie ,...
split ,   US   (04.01.14)
Expulsion from Spain took place in 1492. Holland was Catholic prior to 1570's and only after that date part of Netherlands became Calvinist the other part remained Catholic ,... They showed up in both countries and were allowed to stay under certain conditions in designated places, working in limited trades, paying additional taxes, that's hardly of being invited and welcomed ,... The acceptance of Spanish Jews in Calvinist Holland wasn't an act of brotherly love but a need for hard cash in war torn country, an act of rebelian against Spain and Holy Roman Empire so don't complement yourself on the demand of your valuable presence in Netherlands.
50. 42 Splits Control Freaks
Claude ,   UK and Cape Town   (04.01.14)
What about those also usualy in black garb ( why always black )who's various Church authorities control the way families remember their lived ones on grave stones. We have Muslim clerics, probably also in black , with their endless rants against Jews, Christians, gays, women. Object to re internments and some in UK have refused to offer religious prayers at burials done in a more natural way, like woodland burial sites or places where all faiths are buried alongside each other. But equally we should not forget the brave Rabbis in Sarajevo who saved Muslim and Christian lives, and today a very brave Church leader in CAR making his church a sanctuary for local Muslims fleeing the braying mob. From Split's endless traler park diatribe against Jews , Judaism in particular , it's impossible to imagine him offering a helping hand to anyone in need. Bet he wears black too.
51. #38 Claude
GS ,   Germany   (04.01.14)
This is a good one. Thank you, Claude.
52. Jews in Turkey WERLCOME !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (04.01.14)
Sultan Bayazid II's offer of refuge gave new hope to the persecuted Sephardim. In 1492, the Sultan ordered the governors of the provinces of the Ottoman Empire "not to refuse the Jews entry or cause them difficulties, but to receive them cordially." According to Bernard Lewis, "the Jews were not just permitted to settle in the Ottoman lands, but were encouraged, assisted and sometimes even compelled".
53. Jews in Holland .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (04.01.14)
Jews who fled the inquisition had to leave all their possessions in Spain [ a catholic big thief ! ]. So , they could NOT help the Dutch financially . Why did you flee your birth country ? No answer from you only proves that you had a criminal history , that you did hide to the US immigration authorities
54. 53 ,...
split ,   US   (04.02.14)
They managed to move their usury loot long before they got kicked out.
55. 54 , By electronic bank transfers ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (04.03.14)
They fled their country because they were Jews , not criminals as you are . Converted Jews left their country , years later . They could take their wealth with them . settled in Amsterdam , returned to their TRUE faith , and made their new town the great center it was then . They knew of course that 42-32 = 10 By not answering my question you only confirm what I say : you had a big criminal record and you needed to flee your country .
56. #55 tov, tov meod
GS ,   Germany   (04.03.14)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article