Opinion  Sever Plocker
Two-state solution moving further from reality
Sever Plocker
Published: 12.05.14, 11:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
31. It's about time....
Michael ,   Haifa   (05.12.14)
that Israel's political fascist right goes to sleep and remains that way for the next couple of decades. Maybe that is sufficient time to rectify the damage that the right has inflicted and is inflicting on Israel
32. Leave Judae and Samaria Militirized
Zechariah   (05.12.14)
First Judea and Samaria ought be mainly Militirized in a Massive Survivalist Manner .Any trial agreement will lead to civil war as both the Jews and Arabs are far apart in even the Centrist Core Aspirations .For Jews its Massive Security Protection and a Resilient Identity for Arabs return to 1882.Reality may mean Comprimises on these aspirations .For the Jews the Shoah Sears the Consciousness for the Arabs the loss of Territories The Islamic Lifestyle sometimes Moderate Sometimes Fanatic but always Dominence with Dhimmi.
33. #19 Lynx. Fictional Palestine is finished.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.13.14)
#19 Lynx. You live in a world of delusion. Demography is Israel's friend. At current rates, Jews will make up 80 per cent of the population of our land within 25 years. Much less 200. Your dream is dead. Fictional Palestine is finished. The Arab world and Europe beckon. Start packing.
34. To: # 1, # 12 and # 13
Israeli 2   (05.12.14)
I agree with you. You write with inside knowledge and what you write is absolutely correct. We are not speaking of a peaceful solution. It must be done by force. This must be the people of Israel's will and desire IF they have enough intelligence and guts to ignore the howling of the dogs around the world.
35. What sample?
Raphael ,   Netanya   (05.13.14)
Binational states exist on the planet: Belgium, Canada, Switzerland. However (e.g. india/Pakistan, Sudan/South Sudan, Serbia/Bosnia), the system does not work if one of the partners is muslim.
36. #23 & #30
Harold ,   USA   (05.13.14)
What makes you so sure that you can do whatever you want. Are you still getting the US taxpayers welfare checks and never forget the economic sanctions against Russia.
37. Two States.
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (05.14.14)
The stalemate goes on. And it won't be ended without a honoured peace for the both sides. But several Israeli Prime Ministers have offered almost all old West Jordan to Arab Palestines. They have refused on the scope of "right of return", that would destroy necessary Jewish identity of Israel. While they don't change that position, no good solution can be foreseen.
38. # 36 Thank you Harold...
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.13.14)
yet again you have proven my point.
39. #27. "Zionist Forever". Get your facts straight.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.14.14)
#27. You post ridiculous "Palestinian" propaganda. There are nowhere near 4 million Arabs in Judea and Samaria. There most likely aren't half that many. Are you unaware P.A. "statistics" on this matter are proven a proven hoax? By both Israeli and American studies.
40. # 19 We know about your patience...
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.13.14)
What is more obvious to people is your expertise at never missing an opportunity to miss an opportunity. If you were smart you would have accepted the offer in 1948 to give you a state and then used that as foundation to build. Instead you said no because you wanted everything. You were not expelled by Zionists but left on advice from your own leaders who promised you Israel would be destroyed and then you could come back and have it all. Six wars and six losses and still you don't learn. That isn't patience Lynx, that's stupidity at it's finest. If there were a poster child for stupidity it would have to be a picture of an ersatz Palestinian.
41. #36 Putin laughs and spits in Oblablas face
A ,   Belgium   (05.13.14)
and #23 IS an American taxpayer, bumpkin. As for welfare checks, that's the reason you even live in America, isn't it!
42. when it is a dream
salamat ,   jerusalem   (05.14.14)
it will be personal and vague / but here the world is not the jews only and america is not the world and if it is her dream is not the same of yours nor mine
43. #19 "we waited 67 years, and will wait another 200- gladly."
A ,   Belgium   (05.13.14)
You'e gonna be waiting a whole lot longer than that, pussycat, unless of course you slaughter yourselves in the meantime, which is always a possibility amongst the followers of the "religion of peace".
44. #41
Harold ,   USA   (05.14.14)
You should not be allowed to live in a peaceful country called Belgium. You should go and live in Crimea where your ugly voice is accepted. I am sorry for Belgium to have some idiot like living in their backyard. Just imagine rotten, filthy people like you walking at Galleria Luis.
45. #44, running out of logical arguments?
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.14.14)
46. #44 Can't live in Crimea, bumpkin,
A ,   Belgium   (05.14.14)
because unlike yourself, I am an American. And you should watch the infantile namecalling, bumpkin, or Santa won't bring you any toys for Xmas.
47. #44
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.14.14)
You shouldn't be living in the U.S. unless it's in an asylum or a zoo. Looks like we are stuck with you . You just don't like "A" in Belgium because they have you pegged.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article