Opinion
If you can't treat Palestinian kids, go back to your settlement
Ahmad Tibi
Published: 22.06.14, 13:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. " doc" Tibi and reality
bob ,   yerushalayim, israel   (06.22.14)
and tell me "doc" Tibi, how many non-israeli arab docs like yourself treated jews. (treating them to olam haba doesn't really count here i'm afraid)
2. Ahmad tibi and Sharon Stav
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (06.22.14)
Read or google Islamists in the hospital ward
3. Bravo mr Tibi
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (06.22.14)
Even if I'm not Arab, I'm glad I voted for your party. You're a man of honor
4. Every time!!!
AJ - Raalte   (06.22.14)
Every time I think Y-net cannot possibly sink any lower, it does. Publishing an oped that contains IOF is far beyond the pale.
5. Occupation soldiers? Why are the Arab occupation forces
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (06.22.14)
firing at us? Isn't it about time you left Palestinian land? Palestinian land changed its name in 1948 to Israel, after 2000 years.
6. Tibi On Ynet
Ariel ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim   (06.22.14)
B"H - It is disheartening to see that Ynet publishes Tibi
7. Dr Ahmad Tibi is right.
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (06.22.14)
Its the sworn duty of every doctor to trear anybody in need of medical attention. Simple as that. And a few words about Dr Tibi...wonderful sense of humour, great knowledge of Hebrew and a proud Arab.
8. Dr Ahmad Tibi is right
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (06.22.14)
Already wrote a talkback in support of Dr Tibi.For some reason it seems to have been censored.
9. What one expects from Tibi ?
Moshe ,   Israel   (06.22.14)
The lies and distortions of Arafat's (the mass murderer) adviser are not worth to be answered.
10. FYI,many of top Arab terror chiefs are Doctors.Even Zarkawi
Alan ,   SA   (06.22.14)
11. Bravo to mr Tibi
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (06.22.14)
I'm glad I voted for your party even though I'm not Arab. You're a man of honor.
12. Dr Tibi, I am prepared to arrange for you
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (06.23.14)
to return to Syria
13. #6 Zahava Galon is any better?
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (06.23.14)
14. Jews care only about Jews, then wonder why world hates them
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (06.23.14)
15. Still I wish you had posted my comment...(time will come)
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.23.14)
16. Tibi should be stripped of Israeli citizenship & expelled.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.23.14)
Israel should not tolerate the likes of Tibi as citizens. Let alone as MKs. Zero tolerance for traitors.
17. to the naive writer from Haifa:
Pinchas   (06.23.14)
you're not Arab, you're not Jewish, you're an immigrant to Israel who is an anti-Zionist apparently-- so why did you immigrate in the first place? (And why did stupid Israel let you in in the second place?)
18. That Tibi guy pisses me off...
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (06.23.14)
to no end! Instead of warming the seat at the Knesset, he should educate himself and learn the facts. It turns out, the good doctor from Gaza has told his daughters to stay in that house, knowing full well it will be bombed because leaflets were dropped ahead of time. And now, the not so good doctor is living the high life in Toronto, practicing in our fine hospital downtown and getting accolades for being such a chump while he could have saved his daughters but chose instead to sacrifice them just for propaganda! So Tibi shut the hell up! Like all Arabs you have no clue of what you are talking about and unfortunately, that's the norm with your kind.
19. One might just as easily say
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.23.14)
"Mr. Tibi, if you must practice treason -- as you did when you traveled to Libya and kissed the ring of the late Muammar Qaddafi -- then get out of our land. Stop poisoning our souls." What an incorrigible phony. An ignorant one, too. Doesn't appear to understand the basic rules of military engagement, which are, quite simply, if you go to war and lose, bad things can happen. Like loss of land. There is no such thing as "Arab land" in Hebron, Mr. Tibi. Not any more. Too bad, but adverse consequences to those who engage in wars of aggression and lose do happen. The "palestinians" are not magically immune, you know?
20. Tibi shows the way
(06.23.14)
Every Arab who can't also give service to Jews (which means 100% of Tibi's Fatah) must go back to Arabia.
21. I once asked a Chabad Rabbi 2 questions
Raptor   (06.23.14)
1) Love they neighbor as thyself, does it apply to your Jewish neighbor or any neighbor. Answer, Jewish only. 2) Breaking the Sabbath in order to save a life, a Jewish life or any life. Answer, only a Jewish life. The inborn, inherent and ingrained racism prevalent in Judaism is apparent not only in these answers but also in such usage of the derogatory terms, "goy" and "shiksa", in the concept that we are "chosen", i.e. better than others. This haughty attitude and hubris also is manifest within our own society in that there are sects which regard themselves as better Jews than others, just like the caste system in India. "er ist a gute Yid", was often heard by me in my childhood, denoting that there are "bad Jews" and "good Jews". I can not possibly imagine myself driving through Wadi Ara, encountering a road an accident, and not stopping to assist, because the victims were Arabs. Dr. Tibi. I do not like his attitude and his anti Israeli activities in the Parliament, as a practicing member of the medical profession, he is 100% correct.
22. Telling it like it is, Tibi is absolutely right
Shachar ,   Eilat   (06.23.14)
Many of Israel's doctors and medical professionals are Arab and they do a great job regardless of the anti-Arab climate they live in. The great majority of Jewish doctors do the same, even Ariah Eldad. But this indignation over the kidnapping after what has happened to so many Palestinian children is sickeningly hypocritical.
23. # 14 Can you also write a truth ?
Moshe ,   Israel   (06.23.14)
Probably no, because your mission is to slander. Israel is always among the first countries to reach out to places of disasters, setting up field hospitals and sending specialists for such cases, like after the earthquakes in Hawai and Turkey. It sends also food and medicine. There is an organization of volunteer eye physicians, who travel to African countries and restore the sight of blind and almost blind people. There are more examples, but this is only a talkback.
24. Arabs care only about Arabs, then wonder why Jews hate them
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (06.23.14)
25. reality check
Jo ,   israel   (06.23.14)
lets talk about the reality on the ground and not the BS propaganda diplomatic talk for a minute. tibi why dont u take a walk thru any israeli hospital in the country and see that 30-50% of the patients are arabs being treated just like any jew would be treated. now lets take a walk thru any arab hospitals (if we can get there without getting lynched) and see how many jews are being treated there. ive never been, but im sure the answer is exactly 0!
26. To Pinchas
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (06.23.14)
If you would stop for a second looking at this world through the same googles, you would realise that there are hundreds different reasons to immigrate to Israel other than being Jewish or a Zionist.
27. To: No. 11
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.23.14)
You're a lying slug, is what you are. You're not a citizen of Israel, and therefore do not vote. Right around election time, I seem to recall your bewailing the fact that you did not have the right to vote. I guess your Arab boy-toy is the one who voted for Tibi's party. I'm sure he's dreaming of the day he might need Tibi's medical expertise. Tibi is, after all, a gynecologist.
28. so primitive and stupid lies
wise ,   eu   (06.23.14)
i have good idea all who are not jews and dont like israel go , go , go you emigrated from the pit and poverty , you safed your lifes to come to sirael living and eating there , benefiting from freedom and spiting to your plate? take your five things (if its yours) and go in peace to gaza, Egypt, ukraina, usa - ah sorry usa wil not let u in.. just go ! nobody wants you
29. To tibi
Deborah   (06.23.14)
War will end the moment you love more your palestinian children than you hate the jews. Golda was right in this statement. It is a shame you teach them to explode to kill innocent people
30. Said thing is, many of the people who write talkbacks.
Debbie ,   Israel   (06.23.14)
just reading the talkbacks, it is easy to understand why we don't have peace. It really is a shame
Next talkbacks
Back to article