Opinion  Ron Ben-Yishai
Israel must crush Hamas, but do it wisely
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 01.07.14, 02:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Palestinians
Gabrielle Grossman ,   Oakland   (07.01.14)
This horrendous needless killing of 3 boys makes me very, very angry. Abbas must separate his group of Palestinians totally from the Terrorist Group Hamas, and he should honestly pursue peace with Israel, not duplicitous statements to his people and something else for the international media. He needs to reform his schools, so the innocent Palestinian kids are not taught to hate. He needs to learn to govern the opposite of Hamas--so that there is freedom of religion and separation of mosque and state-- and Abbas needs to come to Israel with honesty and openness, and refrain from seeking a "state" from the U.N. He needs to not only recognize Israel as a Jewish state which has true democracy for it's minority citizens, but also cooperate with Israel to build a democratic partner state to Israel. "Resistance" needs to be eliminated from the vocabulary of Palestinians. Antisemitism must be outlawed by edict of Abbas. This is the ONLY CHOICE for the Palestinian people to survive.
2. Ben-Ishai has yet to prove he possesses a functioning brain.
tom ,   tel aviv   (07.01.14)
3. first sign
Druker ,   USA   (07.01.14)
Here we go! Is this not the first or more likely, the second sign that Israel is going to do nothing?
4. Israelis, I have no exact words ..............
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (07.01.14)
... to express my condolences for the filthy crime, committed by awful terrorists, against two teens of yours. In fact, it is impossible to make peace with Arab Palestines till they change bad leaderships. Fatah should never accept coalizion with Hamas. You have full right to react firmly, but, of course, under the good principles that inspired your founding fathers. We support you, today and forever.
5. Another really dumb article from Ben Yishai.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.01.14)
Crush Hamas but don't disturb the status quo in Gaza!! Ben Yishai insults human intelligence. This like saying crush the Nazis but leave the status quo intact in Germany.
6. Horrors
James ,   USA   (07.01.14)
This article is absolutely horrible. Under your scenario Hamas survives under the protection of the internatinal community. The same group that has inspired and financed terror in and against Israelis. This is the same terror group that grows stronger by the day manufacturing missiles. Unlike Hezbollah, guarded by the international community and growing its missle supply, Israel can protect itself by forces that surround the terror groups. Either you are smoking crack or work for the greater Islamic empire. Your cowardice is only exceeded by the Knesset and Bibi.
7. This is Defeatist Nonsense
A Simple Jew ,   Beer Sheva   (07.01.14)
Israel is the victim of unprovoked aggression. It can arrest, deport, and liquidate Hamasniks. It can destroy enough of Gaza to stop the rocket fire, and civilian casualties are regrettable collateral damage. The theme of this article is that we are helpless before our tormentors. This is a lie.
8. Reply to Ron Ben Yishai
Israeli 2   (07.01.14)
If only your name would be DAVID Ben Yishai instead of RON Ben Yishai, you would have written differently. Just eliminate these bastards wherever they are in the world. Let them fear when they only here the word ISRAEL....because they will be chased and eliminated by the Mosad like Nazis that they are . No more Gaza for them. Let them run and hide throughout the world....and as DAVID Ben Yishai would say: "This year, I am the world and the supreme court. After I do what I must, I will listen to them again."
9. Status quo my butt!!!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (07.01.14)
This type of thinking has kept the Muslim thorn-in-side...it's wound festering and never being dealt with. Enough-is-enough! Time to destroy Hamas/Fatah; there is no difference between these godless savages. It's time to claim ALL the Abrahamic Covenant lands. Every Muslim Arab, except those who are on Israel's side, need to be deported. This really pisses me off! The Israeli leaders' have no backbone...they're a bunch of cowards if they don't respond with devastating force. Screw world opinion and their black Messiah, Obamanutless! Come-on, Netanyahu...time to act like a man and a leader. The Israeli people deserve no less! I'm sorry guys: I'm just really upset by these senseless murders of these innocent, young Jews. God bless Israel; praying for these peace of Jerusalem!!! A Christian Zionist
10. Wise midgets of Ynet worry about Abbas ,and want Israel to
ab   (07.01.14)
fight for im. I've got a secret for you-he has forged brotherly agreement with Hamas. Didn't you know it ? And even if you didn't ,why do you want to "build up human intelligence in the WB",where Abbas is your "partner for peace"?
11. @ Frederick Cross
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (07.01.14)
My bet is you're a punk that i would put down in second.And Freddie boy i have 14 dogs including 3 pit bulls so go back to your butt pirate friends
12. don't attack Hamas
(07.01.14)
All Israel needs to do is build Jewish homes.
13. Deportations
D ,   New York   (07.01.14)
First, there is nothing illegal or inherently wrong about deportations. The legal restrictions refered to in this artilce are obviously misunderstood by the author. It is illegal to round up a whole population and expel them, but deportnig a criminal is not only legal, but common practice throughout the world. Moreover, many arrested had Jordanian passports. While Isreal has no interest in deporting them to Jordan, or Jordan in accepting them, Israel is well within its rights to state that they are not permitted to remain in the territory Israel controls and, due to their Jordanian citizenship, will; not be rendered stateless either. Anyone arrested who holds citizenship of any country other than Israel should be immediately deported to that country or a third country willing to take them.
14. What is Israel's LONG TERM GOAL?
spyguy ,   seattle usa   (07.01.14)
10000 years of history have proven beyond any doubt, that it is impossible for Israel to "destroy" Hamas because no matter how many Arabs Israel kills, there will be a hundred more to take the dead person's place and the new people will be even worse than the ones that get killed. Israel can NOT, repeat NOT, kill its way to peace. All it will accomplish is an even more bloody future for every one in Israel. Israel has never actually listened to the other side and tried to reach a FAIR compromise, but has just killed more humans. The Arabs have some very VALID reasons for being angry and ignoring them ensures a very, very bad future for Israel.
15. 12
yonatan Allon ,   adelaide/Israel   (07.02.14)
Sorry, but Israel has to eliminate Hamas for the good of Israel.
16. Hamas prisoners
David ,   USA   (07.02.14)
The IDF reportedly rounded up 450 HAMAS infidels and put them in prison.Each of those Muslim prisoners should be executed by shooting them in the head.Then they should be cremated and their ashes should be mixed in with lye. All negotiations for a two state solution should end,permanently.Muslim animals cannot be negotiated with.
17. 11
Yonatan Allon ,   Adelaide/Israel   (07.02.14)
great reply to that Freddy boy.He thinks that by being in Nam was something special and therefore we should take notice-but as you say, he is just a butt pirate.He is too old to "give' but he still can receive-if you get my drift.
18. To: No. 14
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.02.14)
Israel's goal is to have a terror-free society. It means getting rid of Arabs, and we should deport them. 10,000 years ago there were no Arabs. You really are very poorly educated. Israel does not have to "compromise" with the Arabs. The Arabs started -- and lost -- six wars. They are a vanquished people and should be treated as such. Mind telling me what "compromise" was reached between the Allies and Germany? Oh, that's right! There wasn't any "compromise." So what right do the Arabs have to expect any compromise? They gave it their best shot ... and lost. Game, set, match to Israel.
19. 1 rocket/mortar = 1 destroyed hamass apartment
Beary White ,   Norway   (07.01.14)
..long term...and no warnings up front..
Back to article