News
East Jerusalem youth was burned alive, Palestinian official quoted as saying
Reuters
Published: 05.07.14, 13:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. Not a hate crime?!
jd   (07.05.14)
Burning someone alive certainly qualifies as a hate crime in my book. The question of motive is another one. Of course, the mere fact that we know that it is possible (probable) that this was done by rightists says that the rot has set in. The price tag attacks have set the stage for this and they must be treated with the full resources of the state.
2. killing of Arab youth
Joe Charlaff ,   Jerusalem   (07.05.14)
I hope the "price tag" people who murdered the Arab youth are satisfied with the mayhem it has produced. Apart from the fact that revenge is a non productive and ongoing cycle, it was a reckless and disgusting thing to do and goes against all Jewish values. I hope they are caught and punished severely.
3. Abu Liars.It is common with Arabs to kill own and blame Jews
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (07.05.14)
This is a very ancient custom among Satan worshippers called blood libel.
4. burning of youth
morice ,   toronto canada   (07.05.14)
I am sorry to say, but this incident has a "smell" about it. It is my opinion that Israeli's are capable of killing but would not go as far as burning a body in this manner, especially if it emanated from these religious Israeli's of the area. I think authorities should dig a little deeper in to this incident
5. Both are wrong!
Jew1 ,   Ashdod   (07.05.14)
This is a sad situation. We still don't know the reason behind the Arab boy's killing. But whoever did it is wrong. Killing three jewish boys was wrong also. If by any change, we jews did the killing then what is difference between arabs and us? It was sickening to hear those two arabs singing after killing our three boys but it was also sickening to see all those jewish posts asking for more blood. If we will ask for an eye for eye, then whole world will go blind. Anyone though how much does these riots on street cost us economically? How much each war costs us? Think twice before spitting anger and asking for revenge.
6. Balestinians dont need proof.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (07.05.14)
They knew Israel did it even before it was done.
7. Media and irresponsibility
Brod ,   USA   (07.05.14)
Israel's media should stop peddling this crap to incite violence against Israel and threaten Israel national security. What about Jewish children slaughtered by Arab Islamist-Jihadists? The Arab rioters on this are Islamist-Jihadist Terrorists. The IDF should round them up and incarcerate them. The rioters are HAMAS Islamist-Jihadist Terrorists swarming and threatening the Land of Israel like its counterpart-ISIS that commits mass murders of humanity. Not a word of condemnation on ISIS by Obama the Islamist. Why? Because the Muslim Brotherhood manipulates and controls him. Who is the Muslim Brotherhood? They are the father of Islamist-Jihadist Terrorist Organizations around the world including ISIS, since they sprouted in 1928.
8. abduction of Arab youth
steve ,   beer sheva   (07.05.14)
The abduction of the Arab youth leaves many questions unanswered. 1. What happened to his friends when they collected him to go to the Mosque at 4:00 am ? 2. Why didn't the boy scream and shout whilst being abducted? this would have woken the whole village at 4:00 in the morning. Surely this would have been an unacceptable risk to the abductors. Why not kidnap any Arab boy outside the village? 3. Why did they not shoot him? Jewish settlers are armed. Another scenario also exists: The boy at 16 years old was clearly gay and an abomination to all his Muslim family. Family honour was at stake and the boy was killed . This is what Muslim law specifies to "passive" homosexuals. Of course the boy was baited in leaving his house at 4:00 am by his 'friends'. He knew his abductors waiting for him; this is why he didn't call out and even if he did no one in the village would listen - they were all in on the scheme including his father. They didn't shoot him because they were not in possession of firearms whilst most Jews would be. This scenario might sound far fetched but anyone knowledgeable of Muslim culture knows 'honour killings' are common in the Muslim world. No doubt they would have been told to murder him when they can most easily blame it on Israelis.
9. so sad
Dov ben David ,   Eilat, Israel   (07.05.14)
Most probably this is done by fascist right wing Jews. I hope that the truth comes up and that the murderer/s will get the same punishment including taking down the houses of his family.
10. 3 Jews and 1 Arab dead
BUILD BY BUILD !!!!   (07.05.14)
and none of this would have happened if there were no pals in Israel. And never the twin shall meet. Time for all pals to return to Jordan for their safety and ours. KEEP BUILDING MORE HOMES FOR MORE JEWS!!!
11. Arab or Israeli?
DOV ,   USA   (07.05.14)
All intelligent people know that there are insane killers in this one world. No matter where they are from and what they believe they will act out by murder. We know the killing of the 3 Israeli boys was a cold blooded premeditated act by a terrorist organization governing Gaza and now W.B..The boy found burned alive was not a premeditated act by the Israeli government. As a matter of fact no one has claimed responsibility for this sick act and this crime has not been solved.
12. To: No. 1
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.05.14)
Well, sluggo, since all indications are that this young homosexual boy was killed by his family in an "honor" killing, you are going to have to unwind your stupid surmise, and start over.
13. The woods
Gady ,   Mexico City   (07.05.14)
in Jerusalem most be taken care of. I am really mad that they are throwing garbage in them and provoking fires that could harm them!
14. Immolation is a typical way Arabs murder their own.
David ,   Hartford USA   (07.05.14)
This poor teenager was an 'insult' to his family's 'honor (as if they have any.) Being gay in the Arab world is a free ticket to be killed. Just look what happens in Iran. Do you really think, even for a minute, that the family of this poor young man didn't plan to take advantage of the anarchy and 'kill two birds with one stone?' They 'honor' murder their own child and try to pin the blame on the Jews. How typical. And Obama comes running to denounce Israel, even before the investigation is completed. And now we have seen the Arabs destroy the light rail stations in their neighborhoods. DO NOT REBUILD THEM. They will be monuments to their sociopathic behavior. And you wonder why the Arabs have never amounted to anything...
15. We Do NOT Know the Facts Yet
Texana ,   Dallas, Texas   (07.05.14)
There must be a full and thorough investigation, and whoever committed this horrible crime, whether it was a Jew or Arab, is a criminal and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent. As a Jewish woman myself, I pray that this terrible crime was not committed by Jews..but if it was, I have only disgust and loathing for them. There is no justification for this crime.
16. 3 Jews and 1 Arab dead
BUILD BY BUILD !!!!   (07.05.14)
and none of this would have happened if there were no pals in Israel. And never the twin shall meet. Time for all pals to return to Jordan for their safety and ours. KEEP BUILDING MORE HOMES FOR MORE JEWS!!!
17. Keep in mind
Toby   (07.05.14)
Keep in mind that Islamic culture promotes death: killing wives, sisters and other family members for "honor" (as if there is anything honorable about murder) and they preach and believe that death in jihad results in achieving "martyrdom" and paradise. So they sow the the wind and reap the whirlwind -- and no, I have NO COMPASSION for Islam: t1) hey ALWAYS start a new round of violence. In this case by kidnapping 3 teenage Jews and killing them in cold blood. 2) They have killed over 1.5 million fellow Muslims in sectarian violence in the past 75 years in the ME and the killing continues today.
18. Crime of Opportunity?
Benji ,   US   (07.05.14)
Revenge? Honor killing? Burning alive is sacrificial and very personal. This appears premeditated and not random. It was timed to divert blame to Israel. I believe you will find the killers in this boy's community. Perhaps in his family. The father was too quick to point the finger at Jews. The Arab protests were predictable and whoever murdered this boy intended this outcome.
19. #2
Jason ,   Nahariya, Israel   (07.05.14)
I see a double standard here. So far price tag inciters have slashed tires and painted graffiti on walls. The arabs have claimed that right wing Jews have murdered the arab boy but so far the jurors are out on whether it was an honor killing or something else. Arabs rioting, beating Jews and mass destruction of public property is overlooked while graffiti and slashing tires is called a capital offence by goyim (not of our nation) on forums and in the news. Why do you always first blame Jews, like hitler did, is it so engrained in your DNA that you just can’t help yourselves?
20. Nr 8.Yes-Yes-Yes- That was my thought also.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (07.05.14)
The Murderers of the Jewish Youths could be behind this also. Arn.Sweden.
21. Dror Freedom above - I think you are right !.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (07.05.14)
You made wery god comments of sense according to me. Arn.Sweden.
22. Not the style of Jews to burn alive
Barney ,   USA   (07.05.14)
A defenseless teenager. When the truth comes out, especially if the young man was gay, it will be a honor killing at the hands of his brethren timed to cause the most trouble for Israel. This is what separates the mentality of Jews from primitive radical Islamic thought.
23. SARA B as usual support war crime
Yossi ,   USA/ISRAEL   (07.05.14)
24. Jews did NOT do this... THIS was an HONOR killing
(07.05.14)
25. definitely not by Jews
Larry ,   LA (formerly)   (07.05.14)
Jews don't do things like this; Arabs do and blame it on the Jews. Nothing has changed. The Christians used to kill some one and blame the Jews so we had to live through pogroms in Europe; we came to live in our land and the Arabs do the same.
26. Whoever did it this is an horrible crime
Dovdevan ,   Ashdod,israel   (07.05.14)
How CAN a human being make Such à crime ? Let the children out of this conflict all the criminal should be brought to justice and sentenced with a heavy hand
27. Steve Benassi
Michael ,   Haifa   (07.05.14)
Nothing really changes. There was scum in the 1930's in Germany, who wrote just like you.
28. #12 sara b
Michael ,   Haifa   (07.05.14)
What "indications" ? Your insinuations are the closest you can get to lying without actually lying. Those who insinuate, as you do, are basically cowards.
29. no. 6 - you missbelled the word broof
(07.05.14)
30. I am hoping the Arabs who had him killed will pay
k ,   US   (07.05.14)
even if the boy was a homosexual that is no excuse to kill him, I am hoping the Israelis are going to go on the family and the friends and get to the truth!
Next talkbacks
Back to article